You are here: Los Angeles Politics Civil Liberties Examiner

J.D. Tuccille

Civil Liberties Examiner
J.D. Tuccille’s warnings that the folks tasked with protecting us may be just as worrisome as the people they're protecting us from have been quoted by media including Wired and the New York Times. Published by newspapers such as the Washington Times and the Denver Post, he has most recently written for his own widely cited Disloyal Opposition blog.

  

Examiner Feeds

These websites were picked by the Civil Liberties Examiner as useful resources.

Right-Wing or Left-Wing?

Obama Nation

Civil Liberties organizations

Commentary

Online Tools

National Examiners

Gaby Cora
Workplace Health Examiner
Most Recent Post
Young doctors leading under pressure
Jay McDonough
Progressive Politics Examiner
Most Recent Post
The General Motors plan
Michele Lerner
Residential Real Estate Examiner
Most Recent Post
Foreclosure crisis worsened by fine print in contracts
Kristen Houghton
Relationship Examiner
Most Recent Post
Holidays, love, and food!
 
 

(i.e. Los Angeles hiking, Los Angeles parenting)

Consenting to a police search can be a one-way ticket to trouble

December 2, 2:06 PM
by J.D. Tuccille, Civil Liberties Examiner
 
I am forever astonished by the number of people who willingly consent to have their vehicles and possessions searched, even when the only possible outcome is a world of legal trouble. It's not that hard to say "no" in the hopes that the police officer will have neither the inclination nor the probable cause to seek a warrant. After all, you might get off if you decline the polite invitation; if you agree to the search while in possession of contraband, you will get into trouble.

That said, the following announcement from the Arizona Department of Public Safety is making the rounds:

On Monday, December 1, 2008, at 1530 hours A DPS Officer, stopped a Large Penske Moving van that was identified as a Commercial Motor Vehicle through an interview with the driver. The officer stopped the vehicle for following too close and unsafe lane usage and conducted a Level II inspection. As a result of the inspection the officer placed the driver out of service for not having a log book and noted numerous violations. While conducting the Level II inspection the officer observed numerous indicators of illegal activity, including an unreasonable explanation of the trip, highly nervous driver, unusual rental length, non cost effective trip for merchandise being hauled as well as numerous other items. The officer asked for and received written consent to search the vehicle. The officer identified a false front wall in the truck by newly caulked walls, phillips head screws in the front wall and sheet metal along the top of the wall. A search of the false compartment revealed 1849 pounds of Marijuana.

What does the better part of a ton of marijuana look like? Take a gander:

Confiscated marijuana

So, you have that sitting behind you in a false compartment in your truck, a police officer clearly has his spidey senses tingling, but nothing else to go on (that's the formal translation of "an unreasonable explanation of the trip, highly nervous driver, unusual rental length, non cost effective trip for merchandise being hauled as well as numerous other items"). The cop asks if he can go probing through your belongings and, with that motherload of ganja behind your seat, you say ... yes?

Ummm ... that's the wrong answer, folks.

Here's a hint: The Fourth Amendment requires that, even in searches of vehicles, which enjoy reduced constitutional protection, police must still have probable cause. Refusing consent isn't a firm and fast roadblock to a search, but it's better protection than permitting the search to proceed.

 

 
Civil Liberties Examiner is now on Facebook!
You can discuss hot topics with other readers, click through a regular feed of Civil Liberties Examiner headlines, and check out categorized compilations of stories. Join now!

Or follow me on Twitter: Libertywriter

Contact J.D.: civilliberties (at) tuccille.com


Topics: advice
   Subscribe   Feed
 

Comments

Name:  
Email Address:  
Comments:  

More from Civil Liberties Examiner

Illegal immigrants find shelter in the underground economy

December 2, 12:25 PM
Not long ago, Arizona joined the immigrant-bashing frenzy by adopting a law (signed by Janet Napolitano, soon to head up Homeland Security), that essentially requires all new hires to be vetted through the federal government's buggy E-Verify system... Read More
Topics: analysis

Is getting high on drugs always a bad thing?

December 1, 1:52 PM
A while ago, I reread Jacob Sullum's Saying Yes: In Defense of Drug Use, several years after first picking the book up. I was struck, once again, by his treatment of the consumption of marijuana, cocaine, methamphetamine, heroin and any other intoxicant... Read More
Topics: analysis

U.S. troops to deploy at home for use in 'emergencies'

December 1, 11:26 AM
In a move foreshadowed by the September announcement that 3rd Infantry Division’s 1st Brigade Combat Team would be stationed at home as a rapid-response force for "natural or manmade emergencies," the Washington Post reports, "[t]he... Read More
Topics: developments

Subversive Santa smashes the state

November 30, 9:18 PM
You knew that Santa Claus (aka Kris Kringle) brought joy into the lives of millions of kiddies across the planet. But you didn't know that he's also a freedom fighter who challenges the dead hand of government and battles for individual liberty.It's... Read More
Topics: developments

Michael Mukasey denounced as 'tyrant' by Washington Supreme Court justice

November 29, 1:31 PM
Richard Sanders has long made a name for himself in Washington as a strong (though not completely consistent) advocate of personal freedom on the state Supreme Court. Now he's also known as the jurist who decided that enough is enough and publicly denounced... Read More
Topics: developments

In praise of free trade -- and productive foreigners

November 28, 10:27 AM
When good economies go bad, otherwise intelligent people sometimes advocate stupid policies -- like protectionism. When the Great Depression set in, Congress pushed through a tariff bill, better known as Smoot-Hawley, inspiring a round of beggar-thy-neighbor... Read More
Topics: analysis , stupid government tricks

Trials the only reasonable step for Guantanamo detainees

November 26, 9:20 AM
In defense of the detention center at Guantanamo Bay and the treatment of prisoners there, Charlotte Law & Civil Rights Examiner Michael A. DeVine writes: POWs have never before had access to military, much less civilian courts, even for war crimes... Read More
Topics: analysis

Rahm Emanuel discusses his own plan for compulsory service

November 25, 7:05 AM
The selection of Rahm Emanuel, the Illinois congressman and Democratic apparatchik, as President-Elect Barack Obama's chief of staff, has raised a few eyebrows -- at least partially because of Emanuel's advocacy of a civilian draft. That plan for "universal... Read More
Topics: abuses , Elections 2008

Join the San Jose Police -- and blow stuff up

November 24, 7:25 AM
Flaming lettering, explosions, marching troops, spinning cars -- and a soundtrack worthy of a TV promo for a cheesy shoot-em-up show or a violent video game. That's the gist of a 2006 San Jose, California, police recruiting video that's making the rounds.... Read More
Topics: abuses

More from this examiner