Search articles from thousands of Examiners
Write for us
Minneapolis Politics Volusia County Foreign Policy Examiner
Volusia County Foreign Policy Examiner

Heavenly Serbia: From Myth to Genocide book review

November 9, 10:19 AMVolusia County Foreign Policy ExaminerMatthew Becker
81 comments Print Email RSS Subscribe

Subscribe


Get alerts when there is a new article from the Volusia County Foreign Policy Examiner. Read Examiner.com's terms of use.
Email Address


  Include other special offers from Examiner.com
Terms of Use

Branimir Anzulovic’s Heavenly Serbia: From Myth to Genocide (1999) discusses the beginnings of the idea/myth of a “Heavenly Serbia” and the establishment of the Kosovo Myth to modern times. The Kosovo Myth (and others) has had a direct impact on Serbian culture up to the present day. The foundation of the Serbian Orthodox Church in 1219 by Saint Sava also plays an important role in Serb nationalism and the destructiveness of the recent Balkan Wars of the 1990s. In this review, I will focus on the establishment of the idea of a “Heavenly Serbia” and the importance of a battle that took place on 28 June 1389. By doing so, modern Serb nationalism may better be understood, and how these myths were used in the Balkan Wars of the 1990s. The role of the Serbian Orthodox Church, the Serbian fear of vanishing, along with the role of the intelligentsia of the 1980s will be explored as well.

On 28 June 1389 – Vid’s Day – The Battle of Kosovo took place on Kosovo Field between the Ottoman-Turks and the Serbs (along with a substantial number of Bosnians, Bulgars, Croats, Wallachians, and Albanians). The leaders in both camps – Serbian Prince Lazar Hrebeljanovic and Ottoman Sultan Murad I – were killed in action. The Kosovo Myth is the story how Serbian Prince Lazar Hrebeljanovic chose the heavenly kingdom over the earthly one. On the eve of the battle, Saint Elias appears to the prince and gives him a choice: a military victory and expanded earthly empire, or defeat (and death) with the promise of securing a place in Heaven for himself and his people. Prince Lazar chose the heavenly kingdom; he thus becomes the second most important saint in Serbian Orthodoxy, the first being Saint Sava.

The original – and perfectly normal – function of “...the legend of Prince Lazar’s choice of the heavenly kingdom was to transform an alleged military defeat into a moral victory” (Anzulovic 1999, 12). This helped the Serbs deal with five centuries of domination by a foreign civilization. However, the legend was gradually expanded to portray the Serbs as a people who “…at every decisive turn in their history opt for the heavenly kingdom by taking the moral high ground” (Anzulovic 1999, 12). The domination by the Ottoman Empire contributed to the development of the Serbs’ “…self-image of a holy people whose moral superiority makes them victims of the immorality of others” (Anzulovic 1999, 33).

The core of the Kosovo myth is the linking of war with Serbia’s salvation, and Prince Lazar as its martyr. Linking Prince Lazar with Jesus Christ can be seen in the folk song KneΕΎeva vecera (‘The Prince’s Supper’), “…which tells about Prince Lazar’s supper with his knights on the eve of the battle. …‘What is the Kosovo Supper but a repetition of the Last Supper? The Sacrificial Victim presides over both. At the Last Supper it is Christ, God, who sacrifices himself; at the Kosovo Supper, a ruler and a people sacrifice themselves’” (Anzulovic 1999, 12). This analogy can be seen in paintings in Serbian Orthodox Churches as well.

Since the foundation of the Serbian Orthodox Church in 1219 by Saint Sava, the Serbian Orthodox Church and the Serbian state have had close relations. Unlike the Catholic Church, the churches of the East have a history of subservience to the state; in fact, one of the salient features of the Orthodox Church is its “…subservience to state and nation, [and] provides moral support to internal oppression and external aggressiveness” (Anzulovic 1999, 112).

Saint Sava makes this point clear: he was “…the youngest son of the founder of the Nemanja dynasty, and brother of the first Serbian king” (Anzulovic 1999, 23). Turkish rule in Serbia did not end the politicization of the Serbian Orthodox Church; rather, it simply changed its nature. Since the Serbian state ceased to exist, it served the Ottoman state under the millet system. The Serbian Orthodox Church was a “…cultural and quasi-political institution, which embodied and expressed the ethos of the Serbian people to such a degree that nationality and religion fused into a distinctive ‘Serbian faith’” (Anzulovic 1999, 25). It became the main carrier of Serbian national identity.

 Since the Serbian nation was no longer linked with a Serbian state, its link with the national religion became still more pronounced. “The myth of the Heavenly Serbia was a manifestation of the radical union of nation and church” (Anzulovic 1999, 33). This fusion of church, state, and nation is known as Saint-Savaism (Svetosavlje), and was established by Saint Sava himself in the early thirteenth century. A Serbian theologian defined Saint-Savaism as “…‘Orthodoxy ennobled by a healthy Serbian nationalism’” (Anzulovic 1999, 30). This is also the most potent and dangerous source of intolerance and occidentophobia in Serbian society.
 
The Serbian fear of vanishing has been a source of their aggressiveness in the past. For the Bosnian-Serbs, the fear of once again being dominated by “the Turks” was a fear that led to the tragedies in Bosnia and Hercegovina in the 1990s. The nationalizing state in Croatia reminded them of what happened during the Second World War under the Independent State of Croatia (NDH) with the Ustaša. This fear of vanishing inspired fear in others, but this fear reflects the “…insecurity of a people dominated by a foreign civilization for five centuries…. The fear of again being dominated by ‘others’…” was a re-awakened fear in the break-up of the former Yugoslavia (Anzulovic 1999, 109). The fear of the “Muslim threat” – the so-called ‘Turks’ (Bosnian-Muslims/Bosniaks) – was also used in the effort to mobilize Serbs in a nationalist front.
 
The fear of Serbia’s demise became a prominent theme among Serbian intellectuals in the 1980s. Twentieth century Serbian fiction has “…served the purpose of psychological mobilization for a war…” that is marked with an intense pre-occupation with history (Anzulovic 1999, 130). It was the Serbian intelligentsia – especially those linked with the Serbian Academy of Sciences and Arts – novelists, poets, literary critics, psychiatrists, artists, and others who prepared society for war and kept the fear of vanishing alive. It was Serbian literary works of the time that brought back manifestations of old sufferings; the other nations of the then-Yugoslavia produced no such works. Slobodan Selenic’s novel Timor Mortis (1989; ‘Fear of Death’) is one such novel, which provides the reader with accounts of the eternal Croatian hatred of the Serbs.
 
This fear of vanishing may be seen in Serbian author Milorad Pavic’s novel Dictionary of the Khazars: A Lexicon Novel (1988). Its subjects, the Khazars, formed a vast state somewhere beyond Transylvania “…stretching from the Dnepr to the Volga Rivers from the seventh to the tenth century, but they subsequently vanished, leaving hardly a trace” (Anzulovic 1999, 111).
 
The Khazars once belonged to a single, unknown faith and spoke their own unique language. Their empire fell apart because the Khazars were no longer united in a single faith, but rather converted to Islam, Christianity, or Judaism. They later completely vanished from the Earth. Within the novel, there are three different sources on the “Khazar Question,” each belonging to one of the three great faiths (Pavi? 1988). Behind the plot of this novel, “…‘there
lies, unhidden, the Serbian anxiety, that of a small, besieged nation afraid of disappearing. As if there were a conspiracy to eliminate it’” (Anzulovic 1999, 111).
 
A Serbian sociologist described the role played by the Serbian intelligentsia “…‘particularly the one assembled around the Academy of Sciences and Arts, that is, the institutionalized intelligentsia’…” in the following way:
 
This elite of the Serbian intelligentsia was the first to start talking…of the genocidal character of the Croatian people. …It was their duty to explain to their compatriots who have never had direct contact with the Croatian people how much the latter are…murderous and incurably dangerous. …After half a century bones began to be pulled out of the earth. The academicians, these chosen people dedicated to a cause, patriots, ‘fathers of the nation,’ have marched like necrophiles toward mass graves, while the people whose trauma and distress began to be manipulated stood by as public and victim (Anzulovic 1999, 140).
 
Poets added poems about the heavenly aspect of their people as well. All of this kept the idea of Serbs as eternal victims, of a Heavenly Serbia, of a fear of vanishing, fresh in the minds of the Serbs. It would later be the cause of so much death and destruction in the Balkan Wars of the 1990s when Yugoslavia fell apart into chaos.
 
The Battle of Kosovo on 28 June 1389 and the Kosovo Myth, the Serbian Orthodox Church and Saint-Savaism, the fear of vanishing, and the role of the Serbian institutionalized intelligentsia have all been explored. Branimir Anzulovic's Heavenly Serbia: From Myth to Genocide (1999) is a well-written book that I enjoyed reading and would recommend to others.
 
 
 

*Please view my article on national self-identity in South Slavic literature. I use Milorad Pavic's Dictionary of the Khazars: A Lexicon Novel (1988) for Serbs, Meša Selimovic's Death and the Dervish (1966) for Bosniaks, and Antun Šoljan’s A Brief Excursion and Other Stories (2000) for Croats:   http://www.examiner.com/x-27426-Volusia-County-Foreign-Policy-Examiner~y2009m10d22-National-selfidentity-in-South-Slavic-literature-Bosniak-Croatian-and-Serbian.*

 

 

 

 

 

(They Would Never Hurt a Fly: War Criminals on Trial in The Hague)

 

More About: Book Reviews

Comments

Name:


Comments:
characters left

NOTE: Do Not Alter These Fields:

Recent Articles

Friday, December 4, 2009
The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) has accepted Montenegro into its Membership Action Plan (MAP), a key step towards full NATO membership. …
Thursday, December 3, 2009
Foreign Ministers of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) will meet today and discuss extending Membership Action Plans (MAPs) -- essential …

Things to see and do

George Winston
20 Dec 2009 - 7 pm
Orchestra Hall
More music »
Cincinnati Bengals at Minnesota Vikings
Hubert H. Humphrey Metrodome

International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia