Screenshot from Massively
I didn't like WoW.
But first, a story. Once upon a time, there was a company that was supposed to be brainstorming for a Brand! New! Game!, but everyone there loved WoW so much that it was deeply coloring their "new ideas."
For the record, I think existing MMOs should be closely studied in terms of interface and communication tools (for reasons I've mentioned before), as well as combat system conventions. And then I think the designers of the "new" game should log off whatever their current brand of crack is, and stay off for the initial design cycle. Otherwise we as players wind up with derivative crap. Copying features never works unless you understand the problem that the feature organically evolved to solve. If the feature doesn't feel like a natural part of the game, the audience correctly identifies it as less than deeply rooted in the game.
We players are totally cool with devs stealing features *if* they improve the experience we're having at the moment. If a feature was copied just so the developer could put it on their box, we inevitably think, well, heck, I might as well go play the game that designed this feature for a reason rather than play a cheap knockoff.
Anyway, enough of my ranting. The point was, at the company to which I refer, it was pretty clear that if you wanted a seat at the idea table, you needed to be in the team leader's WoW guild. That was where everyone was bonding, building their relationships, and drawing all of their plans. Since I was supposed to doing some consulting with that team, I installed the game.
I uninstalled it the same night. It was a highly polished, smooth and easy experience. It was brilliantly executed with a lot of humor and style. Every rough edge had been meticulously sanded off, and for the first time in my life I found myself reading quest text written by someone with a mastery of English grammar and punctuation.
And I felt exactly like I did when I did the "It's A Small World" ride at Disneyland. I felt like a hamster being nudged through a maze with no branching tunnels, just one long piece of orange pipe. I felt like the genre had finally been reduced to the simplest possible Skinner box, and the lore didn't interest me enough to distract me from the pellet bar whacking.
You know what? That's okay! Did you see how I phrased my critiques? All about my feelings and interests. Your mileage may totally vary. The crazy jihad people go on when someone doesn't like their favorite game is just incomprehensible to me.
Anyway. You won't see many WoW pieces from me, but when they do highly notable things, I will always try to link you to someone who does an excellent writeup. Like... this one!
Comments
Personally, I always loved your grab bags and such Sanya. Sometimes you had to dress up a pile of turd for the company...but you posted frequently and pretty transparently. Honestly, I felt you have always tried to be as honest as possible. Also your grab bags were ALWAYS the best. The new DAoC and ESPECIALLY the warhammer grab bags are utter crap. Questions a lackey would come up with. Your grab bags had questions that were actually indepth. They addressed systems implementations, concerns, future plans, bugs, and all.
You, from the beginning of my MMO experience (DAoC v1.0) and now seemingly to the end (don't have much left in me after WAR and other flops) have been, is, and will always be one of the few people I respect fully in the MMO industry.
In specific reference to this post of yours I admire your willingness to admit how you are not a fan of WoW yet give an unbiased opinion. This was a great read and this site is now bookmarked because of this post alone. I wish you luck in future adventures and keep up the good work! Some of us truly appreciate people like you in the field.
P.S. totally didn't realize you lived in dallas. Fort worth here lol. Anyways...out of curiosity what MMO is currently consuming the most of your time and you enjoy the most? Also, where did you go after DAoC?! Are you doing the same gig different company? One minute you were posting....next thing I know I see someone else introducing themselves and my guildies saying you were out the LA Gear >.<
Bring back the Tweety persona and get back to railing asshats such as the CEO and trolls at a *cough* certain company *cough* who seem to have learned jack all in their previous MMO and their attempt to copy WoW.
ps: you took PR rep to the next level. ^5 to you.
It's an interesting perspective, certainly not one I've considered.
I'm just sad you formed all your conclusions with one night of play (how many hours is that if you include install/patch time).
Seems kind of like dismissing a movie or book based on the first few minutes or pages... er wait - I've done that!
Ok bad analogy! But it does seem like you're making fairly sweeping conclusions based on very little exposure.
Yup, a lot of us missed you at DAOC when you left. Mythic was worse off not to have you there.
Got something to say?
Examiner.com is looking for writers, photographers, and videographers to join the fastest growing group of local insiders. If you are interested in growing your online rep apply to be an Examiner today!