Skip to main content

See also:

The Official Jersey Mike's Secret Menu

R&R Special
R&R SpecialJersey Mikes

Upon special request, this article is a work in progress featuring the Jersey Mike's Sub Shop secret menu. Right now, we only have two items, if you know of more secret menu or off menu items at Jersey Mike's, leave them in a comment below (or email me devonlantry [at] gmail.com and they'll be added to the main article (with of course credit given where credit is due).

The Jersey Mike's Secret Menu

Thanks to David Kania, Mike Sway, Kevin H., Caitlin Rivas, and all the anonymous contributors for your secret menu submissions!

The R&R Special
The R&R special is a classic east coast delicatessen reuben sandwich with a little extra flair. It has corned beef, pastrami, swiss cheese, russian dressing, and cole slaw on rye bread.

The BLT
Bacon Lettuce and Tomato sub sandwich. Not listed on the menu but easily ordered. Ask for chipotle mayo or the secret spice shaker to add a little kick.
If you know of more secret menu items at Jersey Mike's, leave them in a comment below to add them to the list.

#99
Big kahuna with chipotle mayo

Stickball
Turkey and salami

#4
Proschuttini and cappaulacola

Caveman
Turkey and cappaulacola and proschuttini

#28
Chicken parm with pepperoni

#12
The Cancro Special (named after the owner) Roast Beef, Provolone and Pepperoni

California Club
Turkey, provolone, and avocado

Hot Brock
Take a #43 and add bacon and ranch.

#11 Stickball Special
Provolone, ham, and salami

#19 Bar-B-Q Beef
Roast beef put on the grill

#420 Stoney MacOtis
Swiss, turkey, salami, honey mustard and jalepenos.

R&R Special
R&R Special Jersey Mikes

R&R Special

The R&R special is a classic east coast delicatessen reuben sandwich with a little extra flair. It has corned beef, pastrami, swiss cheese, russian dressing, and cole slaw on rye bread.

The BLT
The BLT Jersey Mike's

The BLT

Bacon Lettuce and Tomato sub sandwich. Not listed on the menu but easily ordered. Ask for chipotle mayo or the secret spice shaker to add a little kick.

#99
#99 Jersey Mike's

#99

The Big Kahuna with Chipotle Mayo seems like only a small change, but it adds an entirely new set of complimentary flavors to this Jersey Mike's Sandwich. 

#12 Cancro Special
#12 Cancro Special Jersey Mike's

#12 Cancro Special

The Cancro Special is named after the owner of Jersey Mike's.  It's his signature and personal favorite sandwich, with Roast Beef, Provolone, and Pepperoni thrown on the grill and toasted to a melty perfection.  

The Stickball Special
The Stickball Special Jersey Mike's

The Stickball Special

This sandwich is an homage to growing up as a kid in urban New Jersey.  The sandwich features Provolone, ham, and salami, with Mike's Way style toppings and oil and vinegar.