Choose Your Location
|
![]() |
Instead of operating enclosed beer gardens, organizers of the annual event decided Thursday to forgo the liquor license and host a dry celebration after community members raised concerns about high levels of public drunkenness. Organizers also said they could not shoulder the expenses associated with the insurance, security and maintenance needed to run the gardens.
Other street fairs have also experienced increased pressure in the last year to decrease alcohol consumption and regulate unruly crowds. Both the North Beach Festival and North Beach Jazz Festival were almost canceled last year when The City tried to ban alcohol at the events.
The Haight Ashbury Street Fair, held across six blocks from Stanyan Street to Masonic Avenue, is scheduled for June 10. The daylong event, which attracts 70,000 people each year, was in jeopardy after community members complained about drunken fairgoers who have urinated in public, left trash in the street and disturbed local businesses in the past.
Two weeks ago, the Interdepartmental Staff Committee on Traffic and Transportation threatened to deny fair organizers a street-closure permit for the event this year because of community members’ complaints.
“Tens of thousands of people come in, and they have a trashing and call it a fair,” said Arthur Evans, a member of the Haight Ashbury Improvement Association, which opposed the event.
Attempting to compromise, ISCOTT gave fair organizers two weeks to develop a plan that included fenced-in beer gardens to contain people drinking alcohol. Fairgoers would not be allowed to consume alcoholic beverages anywhere else at the event.
It was, however, all or nothing for Robert Leon, the fair’s executive director.
At an ISCOTT hearing Thursday, where organizers were to present their beer-garden plan, Leon announced that there would be no alcohol at the fair at all.
“We have always prided ourselves in producing a street fair that celebrates the free spirit of the community,” Leon said. “Restricting free movement … and compromising the personal decisions of our attendees are contrary to the nature of this community celebration.”
Leon said the fair could not financially support the proposed beer gardens, which organizers estimated at $7,000 each.



Comments from Examiner Readers
1:46 PM MST on Fri., Jun. 15, 2007 re: "Beer will flow at North Beach Festival"
Report as inappropriate
11:24 PM MST on Fri., Jun. 8, 2007
re: "Beer will flow at North Beach Festival"
Report as inappropriate
9:35 AM MST on Tue., Jun. 5, 2007
re: "North Beach Festival still debating booze sales"
Report as inappropriate
9:13 AM MST on Tue., Jun. 5, 2007
re: "North Beach Festival still debating booze sales"
Report as inappropriate
3:10 AM MST on Tue., Jun. 5, 2007
re: "North Beach Festival still debating booze sales"
Report as inappropriate
8:48 AM MST on Mon., Jun. 4, 2007
re: "Beverage debate rages anew"
Report as inappropriate
Examiner Reader said:
It's not the alcohol that's the problem, it's the people who can't control themselves when drinking it in the hot sun. I live in North Beach and enjoy the freedom of having a beer with friends while listening to a band play for free in the park. It's great. Really. You should try it. Allow the beer/wine. Yes, there are many bars nearby that can serve beer too. That's fine too. And the doofus that gets out of hand drunk should be plucked out from the crowd. This is San Francisco. Don't ruin my lovely North Beach with your puritan laws. If someone's getting out of hand in the park, boot them out. Don't ruin it for the rest of us just trying to have a good time.
213 agree | 204 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
Joe said:
These events aren't "San Francisco street life". They're big business interests turning the streets into a mall, with the intention of separating suburban frat boys from their money.
235 agree | 224 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
Examiner Reader said:
The last time I checked, all the bars and nightclubs in North Beach are still serving alcohol. Alex, instead of being so dramatic and caterwauling about "Prohibition" you can maybe drop a little of your cash at one of those local establishments during the fair?
240 agree | 201 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
alex said:
who would've thought that prohibition would be rearing its ugly head in san francisco...
227 agree | 242 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
jaderock said:
I don't see why alcohol has to be such a major factor in a Street festival success. I mean Chinatown has street festivals several times a year. I believe it's one of the most successful ones as well. However alcohol has never been a part of it. Why can some folks enjoy life without booze?!? It should be a family friend event for ALL not just party goers. In fact, without the booze, people are less rowdy.
227 agree | 231 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
James, San Francisco said:
Yes, alcohol should be allowed. The way to manage it is to cite or arrest those who are publicly drunk or otherwise creating a nuisance. San Francisco's much-lauded street life should not be the purview of only the closed-minded property owners who always see a devil when alcohol is around. Geesh, people - get a grip!
519 agree | 269 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree