Search articles from thousands of Examiners
Write for us
St. Louis Religion and Spirituality Philadelphia Critical Thinking Examiner
Philadelphia Critical Thinking Examiner

Alleged prayer killer gets dose of irony

May 17, 11:41 AMPhiladelphia Critical Thinking ExaminerDave Mauriello
4 comments Print Email RSS Subscribe

Subscribe


Get alerts when there is a new article from the Philadelphia Critical Thinking Examiner. Read Examiner.com's terms of use.
Email Address


  Include other special offers from Examiner.com
Terms of Use

Yesterday, the case against the mother of poor Madeline Neumann finally got underway, but only 20 minutes in and they had to recess because mom of the year Leilani Neumann required medical care. Let that sink in for a moment. The woman who is charged with killing her daughter because she decided to pray for her instead of getting her medical care, needed medical care in court and got it.

How nice, huh?

I've been waiting for this case for some time. I think this could really make shock waves across the nation as there are several states which have laws comparable to Wisconsin's concerning rejecting medical care on religious grounds. I have no problem with adults making such a choice about their own lives, but that kind of reckless decision can't be made by a minor nor for a minor.

In Minnesota, the law is somewhat different, requiring parents to provide children with "medically necessary care", which is why a judge has ordered an x-ray of Danny Hauser's chest to assess the need for further care to address his lymphoma. At least Danny's parents aren't completely nuts, since they do recognize some need for doctors, which is how his condition became known to the court as concerned doctors reported the situation to child protective services. Also, thankfully, his mother has admitted she'd reconsider chemo if Danny's condition worsened. Unfortunately for Madeline, no medical professional was aware of her condition, and under no circumstances were her parents going to give up on prayer.

Across the nation we're seeing the effects of going with prayer. Abstinence only sex ed, essentially shutting your eyes and praying kids won't explore their sexuality, has resulted in skyrocketing teen pregnancies and STDs. Fearful parents using religious exemptions to get out of vaccinating their kids, resulting in a return of such things as polio as well as making their little unvaccinated snowflakes into little Typhoid Marys, endangering both toddlers too young to be vaccinated yet as well as seniors. (There was a recent Law & Order episode on this)

So I think it's long past the time we drew a line in the sand. People's prayer claims can be humored when it concerns finding lost keys or even if someone wants to endanger themselves and themselves only, but when it comes to endangering others, especially those in need of protection like children or elderly seniors, that prayer nonsense won't be tolerated as a substitute for real solutions. Feel free to say a prayer as the needle goes in, though. Knock yourselves out.

More About: prayer

Comments

Name:


Comments:
characters left

NOTE: Do Not Alter These Fields:

Inside 'New Moon'
Get inside info on all things New Moon.
Robert Pattinson | Taylor Lautner

Recent Articles

Friday, September 18, 2009
According to the Sun, British retail and grocery chain Tesco has been accused of religious discrimination because they banned a Jedi for wearing a …
Tuesday, September 15, 2009
Having just read this bit on former British Prime Minister Tony Blair's raving about the necessity of religion, I'm reminded again of how god belief …

Things to see and do

Holiday Wreath Auction
25 Nov 2009 - 9 am
Missouri Botanical Garden
More special event »
Penguin Feeding
St. Louis Zoo