Fantasy trade debate: Who's hot, who's not

Fantasy Football Examiner Brad Hostetter and I agree this would be a great time to make a trade in fantasy football. We even agree the time is right to acquire Peyton Manning, Jamal Lewis and Braylon Edwards, and to unload Aaron Rodgers.

So how are we going to make a trade if we agree on everything? Trust me, there's a lot we don't agree upon.

For the sake of discussion, Brad has selected six players he likes a whole lot more than I do at this point, and I've picked six guys Brad isn't very excited about. Linked below are our point/counterpoints on the 12 players in question.

Dave Del Grande: Trade for Derek Anderson
Brad Hostetter: Don't do it

Brad Hostetter: Trade for David Garrard
Dave Del Grande: Don't trade for David Garrard

Dave Del Grande: Trade Ben Roethlisberger
Brad Hostetter: Don't do it

Brad Hostetter: Trade J.T. O'Sullivan
Dave Del Grande: Don't trade J.T. O'Sullivan

Dave Del Grande: Trade for Chris Perry
Brad Hostetter: Don't do it

Brad Hostetter: Trade for Steven Jackson
Dave Del Grande: Don't trade for Steven Jackson

Dave Del Grande: Trade Julius Jones
Brad Hostetter: Don't do it

Brad Hostetter: Trade Ronnie Brown
Dave Del Grande: Don't trade Ronnie Brown

Dave Del Grande: Trade for Chad Johnson
Brad Hostetter: Don't do it

Brad Hostetter: Trade for Wes Welker
Dave Del Grande: Don't trade for Wes Welker

Dave Del Grande: Trade DeSean Jackson
Brad Hostetter: Don't do it

Brad Hostetter: Trade Santana Moss
Dave Del Grande: Don't trade Santana Moss