Los Angeles
CHANGE MY LOCATION
Jay McDonough
Progressive Politics ExaminerJay began writing politically themed commentary and founded his blog, Swimming Freestyle, in October 2007. Here he'll write about politics from a progressive perspective.
Examiner Feeds
These websites were picked by the Progressive Politics Examiner as useful resources.National Examiners
Auction Wally
Auctions and Antiques Examiner
Most Recent Post
An interview with Will Seippel on the GoAntiques - Worthpoint merger
Auctions and Antiques Examiner
Most Recent Post
An interview with Will Seippel on the GoAntiques - Worthpoint merger
Michelle Kerns
Book Examiner
Most Recent Post
Which fictional character would you most want as president? Cast your vote here
Book Examiner
Most Recent Post
Which fictional character would you most want as president? Cast your vote here
Progressive Politics Examiner
Forget The Law, Cover Your Butt
Jay McDonough - Progressive Politics Examiner
In 2002, lawyers within the Bush Administration (Addington, Yoo, Bybee, et al) were busy putting the final, gruesome touches on opinion memos that authorized and rationalized the Presidents use of torture to interrogate terrorist detainees. An integral component of the new strategies was deniability. It just wouldn't do that the President admit the U.S. was now violating Geneva Convention articles and U.S. law and engaged in torturing suspects, so Administration officials were forced to do an elaborate dance; deny the use of torture and, at the same time, refuse to specify what techniques they would consider torture. It was all kind of 4th grade, but it worked fairly well with the help of a non-inquisitive media. The Pentagon, obviously, had the opportunity to balk at the Administrations new interrogation rules. But like the Administration, some Pentagon officials chose to play fast and loose with the law and work on deniability and obfuscation instead. From Brian Buetler in the American Prospect:
On November 4, 2002, Sam McCahon, chief legal adviser to the Defense Department's Criminal Investigation Task Force, raised objections to a legal opinion authored by Lieutenant Colonel Diane Beaver of the Army's Judge Advocate General Corps that greenlighted a number of controversial interrogation tactics. In a memo to CITF Commander Brittain Mallow, McCahon wrote: "Any policy decision to use [techniques that could violate the Constitution's prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment] will be contrary to my recommendation."None are what you might call profiles in courage. All seemed to understand they were steaming ahead, in violation of that law. It just wasn't all that important to them. It wasn't about how to legally engage in a new kind of fight with a new kind of enemy. It was, instead, all about how to keep from being held accountable for breaking the law..
"Nonetheless," McCahon went on, "if the application of the requested measures is approved, I recommend the following actions to mitigate the adverse impact on the CITF."
McCahon suggested first that detainees subjected to harsh treatment be interrogated at a facility other than Guantanamo. In addition, though, he recommended that those selected for harsh interrogations "not be a (sic) considered for referral to the Military Commission" in order to "reduce the risk that the more aggressive techniques used against a few detainees [will] be revealed." His last request was that "CITF personnel should not participate in aggressive techniques... [to] preserve the integrity of our investigations [and] insulate CITF personnel from potential administrative or criminal liability."
The goal, in other words, was to keep blood off CITF's hands.
One can't help but wonder how much safer would we be had Addington, Yoo, Bybee, McCahon and the rest expended even half as much effort developing strategies on how to win this war on terror as they did developing strategies on how to avoid getting caught.
Topics: Torture
More from Progressive Politics Examiner
A Picture for the Day
Jay McDonough - Progressive Politics Examiner
Benjamin Arthur: "Fisher boys in a boat in the ethereal, magical Halong Bay in Vietnam" (Photograph: Benjamin Arthur) ... Read More
Topics: A Picture for the Day
Hey, Palin WAS vetted
Jay McDonough - Progressive Politics Examiner
In 2006 by Democrats. And it's not all bad news - she did some good things. Here's the full vet (PDF). Sullivan points to Palin's record on the Wasilla and Alaskan economy:Debt Service Increased 69 Percent Under Palin.In fiscal 2003... Read More
"They must think you're stupid"
Jay McDonough - Progressive Politics Examiner
It takes a quantum leap of faith to presume anyone, after spending 26 years on the job, will suddenly become an agent of change. John McCain's new "trust me, I'll change things" campaign might make some wonder why, if he's been so outraged,... Read More
Topics: John McCain , Barack Obama
Coming attraction: "Not Vetting Sarah Palin"
Jay McDonough - Progressive Politics Examiner
Coming soon to a theater near you(h/t Boing Boing)... Read More
Topics: John McCain , Sarah Palin
Please, not that American flag thing again.
Jay McDonough - Progressive Politics Examiner
There are, apparently, some out there still desperately trying to build a case that Democrats don't sufficiently respect the American flag. Just for the record, here are photos of John McCain and Barack Obama addressing the Republican and Democratic... Read More
Topics: American flags
Building the Palin narrative
Jay McDonough - Progressive Politics Examiner
Last night I posted a short piece on Alaska's executive jet and the urban myth being constructed about Sarah Palin selling the jet on eBay for a profit. It's untrue - the jet was not sold on eBay and it was sold at a loss. A reader commented:...you... Read More
Topics: John McCain , Sarah Palin
"What do you talk about when you can't explain"
Jay McDonough - Progressive Politics Examiner
Go Joe Biden. While Ms. Palin is esconced away (like a delicate flower), hidden from the press and interested voters hoping to learn something about her positions, the McCain camp and Ms. Palin apparently too afraid she would blow their carefully... Read More
Topics: Joe Biden , Sarah Palin
Zardari wins presidency of Pakistan
Jay McDonough - Progressive Politics Examiner
Asif Ali Zardari, widower of slain former prime minister Benazir Bhutto, won the presidency of Pakistan today. He has his work cut out for him; Pakistan has raging inflation, a Parliament split among rival parties, resurgent Taliban and al Qaeda... Read More
Topics: Pakistan , Asif Ali Zardari
Palin: No questions allowed
Jay McDonough - Progressive Politics Examiner
So much for transparency and respect for voters. According to Nicole Wallace of the McCain campaign, the American people don't care whether Sarah Palin can answer specific questions about foreign and domestic policy. According to Wallace -- in... Read More
Topics: Sarah Palin
