You are here: Los Angeles Politics Progressive Politics Examiner

Jay McDonough

Progressive Politics Examiner
Jay began writing politically themed commentary and founded his blog, Swimming Freestyle, in October 2007. Here he'll write about politics from a progressive perspective.

  

Examiner Feeds

These websites were picked by the Progressive Politics Examiner as useful resources.
MSNBC Top Headlines - 2 hrs 27 mins ago MSNBC Top Headlines - 2 hrs 42 mins ago MSNBC Top Headlines - 3 hrs ago MSNBC Top Headlines - 3 hrs ago MSNBC Top Headlines - 4 hrs ago

News

Opinion

Progressive Politics Examiner Links

National Examiners

Jacob Osterhout
College Sports Examiner
Most Recent Post
ACC Basketball Preview: Florida State University
Trevor Bothwell
Politics Examiner
Most Recent Post
Who says your 401(k)'s worthless?
Michael Street
Asian-American Sports Examiner
Most Recent Post
Ching and US men's team prove too much for Cuba
Find the Examiners
writing about your
favorite topics.

How Would McCain Have Handled North Korea?

June 26, 10:01 AM
 
 
The good news came yesterday.  The United States would, upon receiving North Korea's full declaration of its nuclear programs, remove North Korea from the "terrorist watch list".   As promised, North Korea delivered the declaration to China today.

President Bush today:
...we welcome today's development as one step of a multi-step process."
He added, "If North Korea continues to make the right choices, it can repair its relationship with the international community much as Libya has done over the past few years."
Again, congratulations to the Bush Administration for defusing (or, at least, beginning to defuse) a very dangerous situation.  There are reports the diplomatic path was strenuously opposed by some in the Administration,  calling any negotiations with the Koreans appeasement.  They favored, instead, turning the screws, tougher sanctions and some openly discussed a possible military intervention.  Those individuals, thankfully, were overruled.

Given today's news, I would argue the Administration took the wise, prudent path and the results speak for themselves.

There's probably some value in documenting John McCain's public statements on North Korea.  After all, the Senator's statements would give insight into how a McCain Administration would handle a nuclear powered North Korea.  From an analysis of McCain's March 1999 speech at Kansas State University:
The cornerstone of his thinking was a sweeping doctrine, "call it rogue-state rollback if you will" of "supporting indigenous and outside forces that desire to overthrow the odious regimes that rule these states."

McCain repeated this trope throughout the speech, drawing on his personal history and adopting the rhetoric of moral seriousness about the consequences of committing American forces. But awareness of the consequences was, for McCain, no reason to avoid starting a war. Indeed, McCain almost seemed disappointed that the Clinton administration managed to peacefully resolve the North Korean nuclear crisis with the "agreed framework" of 1994. He remarked in Kansas that "a firmer response to North Korea might have triggered a war, a war we would win, but not without paying a terrible price." McCain was sophisticated enough to recognize that other policy options such as refusing aid to the North might nonetheless have resulted in conflict "as the North's last desperate measure."
In a May 2008 editorial to the Asian Wall Street Journal (co-written by Joe Lieberman), McCain writes:
"We must use the leverage available from the U.N. Security Council resolution passed after Pyongyang's 2006 nuclear test to ensure the full and complete declaration, disablement and irreversible dismantlement of its nuclear facilities, in a verifiable manner, which we agreed to with the other members of the six-party talks." McCain and Lieberman write. The Bush administration essentially abandoned enforcement of the U.N. Resolution when early in 2007 it decided to negotiate an end to the impasse.
It's clear a McCain Administration would have, at the least, continued to implement additional sanctions that had proved ineffective and refused to engage diplomatically with the North Koreans.  And, in all likelihood, North Korea would be even further down the road in terms of its nuclear capabilities.  In the worse case, Senator McCain seemed resigned to the possibility the U.S. would be required to initiate a war in order to end the Koreans nuclear ambitions. 

I never thought I would say this: thank God the mature and cool heads of the Bush Administration prevailed and didn't heed the careless and simplistic recommendations of folks like John McCain.

The world is a wee bit more peaceful today as a result.
Topics: McCain , North Korea
   Subscribe   Feed

Comments

Name:  
Email Address:  
Comments:  

More from Progressive Politics Examiner

"Permission"

October 15, 3:44 PM
While the Connecticut Supreme Court just ruled banning gay marriage as unconstitutional, California's Proposition 8 (changing the state constitution to include a ban on same sex marriage) is very tightly contested.  (h/t The Daily Dish)... Read More
Topics: Gay Marriage

Barack Obama and William Ayers, Part 2

October 15, 3:33 PM
Continuing from the earlier post:The McCain campaign has alleged Barack Obama continued to "pal around" with William Ayers when the two served on the boards of two government and privately funded projects in Illinois in the 1990's.The first... Read More
Topics: Barack Obama , Bill Ayers

President Bush Urges Panic

October 15, 1:44 PM
From the Onion:WASHINGTON—In a nationally televised address to the American people Wednesday night, President Bush called upon every man, woman, and child to spiral uncontrollably downward into complete and utter panic.Speaking from the Oval Office,... Read More
Topics: Bush , The Onion

No wonder Sarah Palin is so popular in Alaska

October 15, 1:42 PM
When John McCain named Alaska governor Sarah Palin as his vice presidential running mate, he proudly procaimed Ms. Palin is the most popular governor in the United States, with over an 80% approval rating.  (Note: the governor has dropped to 68%... Read More
Topics: Sarah Palin , Alaska , Permanent Fund

Who is Batman really?

October 15, 12:25 PM
Batman and the Penguin debate.   Does this remind you of anyone else? (h/t Marc Ambinder)... Read More
Topics: Debate

McCain's debate preparation video

October 15, 12:16 PM
Smuggled out of McCain for President campaign headquarters, here's the video preparted for the Senator in advance of tonight's debate:... Read More
Topics: John McCain

Wonder Woman: I'm afraid of Sarah Palin

October 15, 12:07 PM
Lynda Carter, who played Wonder Woman in the 1970's television show of the same name, has labeled Sarah Palin as the "anti-Wonder Woman"."She’s judgmental and dictatorial, telling people how they’ve got to live their lives,"... Read More

Believe it or not, Bush still has some juice

October 15, 11:53 AM
I know.  You're thinking: President Bush? Hmmm, is he still around?  Despite diligently working his way towards complete irrelevance, President Bush still has the pen to sign off Congressional measures into law.  But not without some caveats:The... Read More

Barack Obama and William Ayers, Part 1

October 15, 11:15 AM
Since John McCain has now vowed to raise the issue at tonight's debate, the extent to which Barack Obama and William Ayers are "palling around" warrants some investigation.  After all, were Obama and Ayers hanging at the sports bar every... Read More
Topics: Barack Obama , Bill Ayers