Search articles from thousands of Examiners
Write for us
National Health Denver Health Examiner
Denver Health Examiner

France as medical care icon? Not.

July 28, 5:19 PMDenver Health ExaminerDonna Feldman
Comment Print Email RSS Subscribe

Subscribe


Get alerts when there is a new article from the Denver Health Examiner. Read Examiner.com's terms of use.
Email Address


  Include other special offers from Examiner.com
Terms of Use


Obesity Kills.  www.cnao.fr

The poster says "Obesity Kills".  It's part of a campaign by the National Collective of Associations of the Obese in France, designed to make the point that obesity-caused diseases are deadly.  Why such a poster in France, home of the eternally svelte?  Because French women (and men and children) do get fat.   And when they do, they get the same diseases overweight Americans get.  And those diseases are expensive. 

The overweight/obesity rates in France don't approach that of the US yet, where 2/3rd of adults are either overweight or obese.  But the Population Reference Bureau, which publishes obesity data on 10 European countries, doesn't hesitate to sound an alarm: "Rising rates of obesity can explain 27 percent of the growth in real health care spending between 1987 and 2001."  According to a recent report on NPR, the national health system in France was $9 billion in debt last year.   At the moment,  French workers are required to contribute a whopping 21% of their income into the medical care system.  Employers cover about half of that cost, but the result of that enormous expense is that employers are loath to hire more people.  Every new hire represents another huge expense in taxes.  

Meanwhile the $9 billion debt from last year caused the Sarkozy government to start charging more for many medical services, while investigating other ways to cut costs and charge more.  Sound familiar? But you've been to France and only seen thin people sunning on the Mediterranean beaches or strolling in Paris.  There's an explanation for that. Rates of obesity  are higher in less glamorous regions, such as the northeast of France.  Large cities and Mediterranean regions have the lowest rates.   

Why care?  During the 2008 US presidential election campaign, you'll hear plenty about the need to reform the US medical care system.  France will be held up as the ideal:  a population that's healthier thanks to the low-cost single-payer system.  The logic is exactly backwards.   The French people have enjoyed good health because of a healthier lifestyle, not because they get "free" (21% of paycheck) medical care.   But now the healthy tradition of wholesome food, small portions and more physical activity in daily life is changing.  As the obesity rate rises, the system is going into debt trying to keep up with the increased demand created by obesity-related diseases.  In France, at least, the government is taking the threat seriously.  Obesity doesn't just kill individual people.  It can kill off the medical care system. 

Medical care comparisons: The NPR report has a handy chart that compares medical care systems in various developed countries.  What the chart doesn't tell you is the lifestyle traditions in each country that help keep people healthy and reduce medical costs.

Add a Comment

Name:


Comments:
characters left

NOTE: Do Not Alter These Fields:

Recent Articles

Wednesday, September 10, 2008
Barbarian Invasiona DVDWe rented the Academy Award winning Barbarian Invasions last weekend. To judge from the DVD case, it was a funny look at …
Monday, September 8, 2008
Which is the better breakfast? Whole wheat bagel and 100% juice smoothie or 2 scrambled eggs and Canadian bacon? Well, if you're a dieter, a new …