Search articles from thousands of Examiners
Write for us
Minneapolis Society and Culture Providence Women's Issues Examiner
Providence Women's Issues Examiner

Dealing with gender bias: Does sex matter in coaching a team?

June 29, 10:43 AMProvidence Women's Issues ExaminerJune Coan
Comment Print Email RSS Subscribe

Subscribe


Get alerts when there is a new article from the Providence Women's Issues Examiner. Read Examiner.com's terms of use.
Email Address


  Include other special offers from Examiner.com
Terms of Use

Digit Murphy, a woman coach for Brown University’s women’s hockey team, may apply for the opening for Brown’s men’s hockey team. The opening occurred after Roger Grillo resigned to become regional manager of USA Hockey’s American Development Model.
According to reports, Murphy didn’t respond to whether or not she would apply. However, she told reporters it doesn’t matter what sex the person is, as long as they can coach.
True, but how do other people feel about this?
So far, according to the poll on the question “Should gender ever be a factor in hiring a college sports coach?”; about 50% of the poll favored yes. How far have we come if people still feel gender matters?
The biggest issue people have is those opposite sex coaches in the locker room. But, does pep talks need to be in a locker room? And what about setting rules by having someone let the coach know it’s clear when people are dressed, if that’s the issue?
“I don't know, should opposite genders be hanging out in the locker room? Should a man be coaching in your daughters Lacrosse locker room?” says one commentator on the poll.

Actually, there are plenty of male coaches who coach women’s teams. East Providence High School had male coaches for the women’s soccer team, both for varsity and junior varsity. Also, women’s track had two male coaches, one for runners and another for throwers. The head coach for women’s basketball was also a male coach also at East Providence High School at one point in time. Plenty of high schools, junior high schools, middle schools, colleges and universities have opposite sex coaches.

The problem seems to be not that male coaches coach the women’s team, but that the female coaches coach men’s teams. Does it really matter?

Some may argue that it’s not because of the locker room, but that can a woman teach a man to be tough? When sports were taught at an early age, it was about learning skills and having fun. It should still apply even today, even if you are getting a scholarship or getting paid to do it. Besides, it’s not about being tough. If you don’t have the skills, then no matter how strong you are, it’s not going to mean anything if you don’t know how to hit a puck or shoot a ball.

It is really sad that in 2009 people are still caring about gender in sports. The issue should be whether or not a person can coach, do they have people skills and can they deal with a crisis. It shouldn’t be Billy vs. Bobby anymore.
 

For more info:

Providence Journal on Murphy

Successful Women's Coaches

Add a Comment

Name:


Comments:
characters left

NOTE: Do Not Alter These Fields:

Recent Articles

Friday, November 6, 2009
If you picked up the December 2009 issue of Marie Claire, you would notice that there is a second column of “Big girl in a skinny world” …
Tuesday, July 28, 2009
For Voting Information: League of Women Voters of Rhode Island: “The League of Women Voters, a nonpartisan political organization, encourages …