How to be a good beta reader

Whether you are part of a writing group or simply a working with one or two writer friends, getting a valuable critique is an art in and of itself.

But how do you know when to simply give your opinion or whether to correct the work in question?

Here are two different ways to critique the work of your writing peers. 

The Line Edit

The line edit is exactly what it sounds like - you read through the entire piece, editing spelling, grammar, repetitive words or phrases - every little detail that needs fine tuning.

While being this detailed is helpful, be sure not to project your own personal writing style into your edit.

Remember that this story is written by someone else and that you are reading it to offer your opinion on what works and advice on how improve it. But don’t forget that each writer is different and your critique partner’s writing, theme, style or choice of words may differ from your own preferences.

The Big Picture Critique

Generally, the 'big picture' critique is more of your opinion on the piece as a whole. Critiques should be more focused on the content rather than the finite details of grammar, punctuation, and spelling.

After reading the piece a few times, your comments should be geared toward how the story works as a whole, including the believability of the POV character, the story's cohesiveness, the plot and the general flow of the work.

Don't forget that you are looking at the story as an outside observer. When making suggestions, make them in relation to the goals of the author and not how you would write the piece. 

The Bottom Line

Working with a critique partner can help your writing in a variety of ways. Providing valuable feedback is just part of the process.

By reading the work of another writer, you also learn a great deal about your own writing, and can use these lessons to improve the way you work with others as well as honing your own craft.

Resources 

In the Toronto area and looking for a critique partner? Join The Toronto Writer's Group: a monthly meeting for writers looking for support and review of their work from other writers. Their next meeting is August 10, 2010.

If you are looking for a comprehensive list of questions for your next critique, check out What To Ask Beta Readers from Roni Griffen.

Did you enjoy this article?
Share it & SUBSCRIBE to stay informed!

Toronto Writing Examiner

Promote Your Page Too

stumble upon

facebook

twitter

rss feed

email me

subscribe