.jpg)
Hey, Self, even the cover says "stay true to you"!
In case you've been summering on the moon, America is all atwitter over the latest Self magazine cover featuring singer Kelly Clarkson and the creative photo editing that went on.
Jezebel.com, which is always on top of magazine cover witchcraft, early on pointed out the fact that the photo of Clarkson was obviously altered to make her look slimmer.
To address the controversy, Self editor Lucy Danziger took to the magazine's blog to explain why they messed with the photo. She writes:
This is art, creativity and collaboration. It's not, as in a news photograph, journalism. It is, however, meant to inspire women to want to be their best.
Here's the truly galling part:
But in the sense that Kelly is the picture of confidence, and she truly is, then I think this photo is the truest we have ever put out there on the newsstand.
Huh? Do you think that putting her through that whole photo shot process only to look at the photos on the light table and presumably say "Oh, we've gotta slim that girl down in post-production" is confidence boosting? I don't think so.
You can read her entire post HERE, including the reader comments that so far have skewed entirely against her.
So, slimming Kelly Clarkson is supposed to be inspiring to those of us who don't have fun-house mirrors installed throughout our house. And what, the real Kelly Clarkson would send us all to Baskin-Robbins? Please, the girl's not obese -- she just has a little extra junk in the trunk, and I'd bet she's probably no larger than a size 12. Really, Self, we can handle a normal-sized human on your cover.
Basically that's Fairytale Kelly on the cover and they have the video to prove it, which points out the photo trickery even more:
And here's Self editor Danziger on the Today show with model Emme also trying to talk her way out of the controversy. Fail:
Visit msnbc.com for Breaking News, World News, and News about the Economy
- Sherri Shepherd's bathing suit weight loss
- How did Robin Quivers lose weight?
- Fergie's diet and workout secrets in Allure
- Kirstie Alley on Oprah
- Lindsay Lohan's shocking weight loss
- President Obama's secret to staying fit
- Biggest Loser: Where are they now?
- How did Perez Hilton lose weight?
- Seth Rogen's diet secret
- How did Britney Spears lose weight?
- Jessica Simpson is not fat
- Beyonce says gaining weight is fun
- Horatio Sanz's weight loss secret
- British singer Adele is fine with her size
- Dancer Cheryl Burke is most certainly not fat
Comments
wow- after watching that video and comparing it with the cover photo, it is very obvious that it had been altered. I agree, how would photo-shopping a girl's figure to make her appear smaller build up her self confidence? Quite the contrary!
This ticks me off. Kelly Clarkson is beautiful just the way she is. If they didn't have even one flattering picture out of the whole photo shoot, so they had to basically create a fake one, that tells me something about the ability (or lack thereof) of their photographers.
If I were Kelly, I'd be hurt. I'd like to see her speak out against the cover, and against Self.
Good article! people will try to get away with anything these days..
Great coverage, Gail. Too bad the magazines with the most influence over young women and their self image present a gifted and accomplished woman as "not good enough" because she's not a size 4.
Great article! I love how the magazine cover says "You at your best" next to the title. Are they implying that she is not at her best so they had to make her that way? We have a long way to go to make people, for the sake of our young women and girls, realize that healthy does not mean size 2, 4, or 6 for everyone.
>>But in the sense that Kelly is the picture of confidence, and she truly is, then I think this photo is the truest we have ever put out there on the newsstand.>>
I'm sure it is.
Got something to say?
Examiner.com is looking for writers, photographers, and videographers to join the fastest growing group of local insiders. If you are interested in growing your online rep apply to be an Examiner today!