I've created my own scoring model for players this season and I'll be updating it all year to see how it ends up for each player by the end of the season.
The first post will be on starting pitching. The Cardinals have used 6 starters this season: Adam Wainwright (5 starts), Michael Wacha (4), Lance Lynn (4), Shelby Miller (4), Joe Kelly (3, currently on the DL) and Tyler Lyons (1).
For the score, I used weighed amounts broken into 4 parts: Runs, Control, Record, and Defense. Control is the largest part, and contains hits, walks, strikeouts, home runs, wild pitches and hit batsmen. Runs is second largest and incorporates runs and earned runs. Record is next and based off wins and losses. Finally, defense looks at put outs, assists, errors and double plays.
Here are the scores for the starters.