Welcome to Look Who's Been To Music School night at the Monterey Jazz Festival, in which otherwise capable musicians decide the priority du jour is demonstrate their mastery of alternative composition techniques.
First up on the noise parade was Buffalo Collision, an aptly named side project of troublesome trio The Bad Plus. I've never witnessed a set so hostile to the notion of melody, and that includes a performance by an improvisational group that used the sound of car falling off a scaffolding as percussion. This was the only show of the festival where noise from passing aircraft improved the experience.
Next up was keyboardist Jason Moran, a normally affable young fellow who knows how to strike that fine balance between creative boundary-pushing and traditional tunefulness. Tonight, however, the main piece of piece of business was to premiere "Feedback," a new piece commission by the festival.
At least there was method to Moran's madness, as he explained the piece was a tribute to Jimi Hendrix's landmark performance at the 1967 Monterey Pop Festival and generously gave the audience leave to plug their ears or check out altogether. And a number did as Moran and his rhythm section explored the limits of prepared piano, amplifier squeal and other aspects of atonality for a full 20 minutes. Who knew the overamplified sound of a cymbal being scratched was so close to nails on a blackboard?
At least Moran knew how to pull it together at the end, Sonic Youth-style, as he and the band hit a funky groove enlivened by his electric piano licks and the vocalizing of the surprisingly obliging crowd.
Thank god for local lads the Shotgun Wedding Quintet, who were more intent on giving the audience a funky good time than displaying their theory & composition credentials.
Send tips, comments and good karma to the author.
Comments
MJF gives young artists permission to go beyond what is comfortable, and the MJF audience is more and more learning how to enjoy the ride
It's "journalism" like this that keeps jazz in the dark ages. Free your mind Becker. You'd think you were 90 years old by the way you whine about the non-traditional stylings.
Moran's shows were especially amazing.
With all respect Mr. Becker, you simply should not be writing about this festival, with this kind of line up. Get assigned to gigs you know that are your cup of tea. You sound beyond ignorant regarding this type of music.
Is this "real" or some kind of a parody?
you should stick to reviewing the music you hear at your next dentist office visit... you're over the hill...or better yet..you're over.
Which part of "critic" am I not understanding?
It's journalism like this that makes jazz really jazz. Jazz isn't about the perfect melody, or a terrible idea for that matter. It's about honesty. A true jazz musician says what's on his mind, and a critic does the same thing. If a critic were to kiss ass every time, the whole notion of "being a critic" would be pointless.
It's sad to see that the listeners who are chastising Mr. Becker can't appreciate his honesty. He has a certain aesthetic, and I commend him for having standards.
Every listener is a critic. Every listener has personal tastes. The fact that none of you can accept criticism that contradicts your praise shows how close-minded you really are. There hasn't been a single arguable statement from any mudslinger on here. All of you criticize him because he thinks differently. What kind of "open-minded" people are you?
Got something to say?
Examiner.com is looking for writers, photographers, and videographers to join the fastest growing group of local insiders. If you are interested in growing your online rep apply to be an Examiner today!