Suspicion surrounds forced cancellation of Shen Yun's Hong Kong shows

Last week, the world's premiere Chinese classical music and dance company, Shen Yun Performing Arts, returned to Washington, DC and performed for over 11,000 Washingtonians in seven shows at The Kennedy Center. This week, Shen Yun remains in DC, but not to perform.

On January 27, Shen Yun was scheduled to make their first and highly-anticipated appearance in Hong Kong. However, their performances were abruptly cancelled due to the surprise, last-minute visa denials of seven key crew members.

The Hong Kong shows were particularly important because the expression of traditional Chinese music and dance is currently not permitted in mainland China. Shen Yun, along with members of the Chinese-American community, viewed the Hong Kong performances as an important first step in bringing such art forms back to China.

A January 21 letter from Hong Kong’s Immigration Department explained that the visas were denied because the crew members’ positions could be “filled locally” by Hong Kong workers. Shen Yun Performing Arts is skeptical of this reasoning and believes that other, more alarming reasons are in play, particularly influences of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and the gradual suppression of freedoms in Hong Kong, an island that typically enjoys more freedoms than mainland China under the principle of “one country, two systems.”

The news of Shen Yun’s cancelled performances comes on the heels of recent, widespread protests in Hong Kong, where demonstrators expressed disapproval of Hong Kong’s unelected legislators and called for pro-democratic reforms.

Speaking yesterday at two emergency conferences, one for the media at The National Press Club, the other for congressional staffers at the Cannon House Office Building on Capitol Hill, Shen Yun’s crew and performers discussed their disappointment, suspicions regarding the Hong Kong visa denials, and the importance of defending freedom of expression in Hong Kong.

Gregory Xu, production manager, explained, “[Shen Yun] has been to many other countries and no other has raised this issue.” He went on to note that those who were denied visas are integral to the performance because they possess special skills that cannot be acquired over a short period of time. He called Hong Kong’s decision “illogical,” and said that Shen Yun provided Hong Kong officials with all the information they requested throughout the visa application process.

During Shen Yun’s conference on Capitol Hill, Congressman Gus Bilirakis (R-FL), who saw Shen Yun at the Kennedy Center last week, expressed disappointment over Hong Kong’s refusal to grant the visas. “It’s very disappointing that Hong Kong didn’t grant the visas, which led to the cancellation of the shows. Nearly 8,000 people in Hong Kong had paid for tickets and were eagerly waiting to attend the performances only to be disappointed in the end.”

Leeshai Lemish, spokesman for Shen Yun, said that over 7,700 ticketed audience members have been directly affected by the show’s cancellation with a price tag of up to $200,000. Mr. Lemish also explained why tickets were sold in Hong Kong without first securing every visa. “[Shen Yun] views Hong Kong just as other democratic countries. The whole process was done in good faith and there was no indication of any potential problems.”

Congressman Anh "Joseph" Cao (R-LA) voiced his support for Shen Yun Performing Arts and his displeasure with the Chinese government for prohibiting freedom of expression in China's mainland. 

“Not allowing Shen Yun to perform in China is just another indication of how the Chinese government is trying to suppress any kind of expression that will challenge or supersede their right to govern their people with a totalitarian grip. As a representative of the most powerful democracy in the world, I believe that the action of the Chinese government is something we have to challenge.”

Congressman Cao said that he became aware of China's "strong-arm tactics" during a recent visit to Asia, explaining that China continues to "flex their muscles" to bully small companies like Shen Yun Performing Arts, as well as smaller countries in the region, particularly those in southeast Asia. He urged the international community to speak out, push for democracy, and advocate for basic human rights.

Lead dancer, Leon Chao, a DC native, expressed his feelings about the cancelled shows. “My personal dream is to one day perform in China. Hong Kong was a very important first step and now it is lost. As an American, I ask Americans to take a stand and not take our freedoms for granted.”

Vina Lee, Shen Yun’s company manager, explained that most of the performers were shocked by the news, “especially the young dancers who grew up in the West.” Ms. Lee said that Shen Yun will still try to go to Hong Kong as well as mainland China. “We want to bring Chinese culture – truth, compassion and beauty - back to China.”

Shen Yun Performing Arts is an NYC-based, nonprofit organization dedicated to reviving Chinese traditions that have been prohibited since the CCP came into power. Their mission is to “revive Chinese traditions that thrived before decades of suppression.” The show depicts traditional Chinese stories and legends as well as events in modern-day China, such as the persecution of the Falun Dafa, a spiritual practice that is prohibited in mainland China, along with other religious groups.

Shen Yun's cast members are of Chinese descent but live outside of mainland China, which allows them to perform without fear of censorship.