... to a debate. Here's how it works:
Check out Mr. Fantasy's draft ratings at www.mrfantasy.com.
If you believe Mr. Fantasy has rated a player too high, tell me why you think so. Pick a player rated below him on Mr. Fantasy's list and explain why these guys are in the wrong order.
The same goes if you believe Mr. Fantasy has rated a player too low. Tell me why he should be ahead of someone currently higher than him on Mr. Fantasy's list.
Do this in 100 words or less using the comments function at the bottom of this article. I will then copy it over to a new file, state my rebuttal and let fantasy fans everyone vote for who they believe is right and wrong.
Want to take on Mr. Fantasy? Go ahead, give it a crack. But be prepared to be WRONG.
For more info: For everything fantasy football, check out www.mrfantasy.com.
Comments
i cant believe you made a post like this since i would love to challenge you, in my opinion you are know absoutely nothing about fantasy and anyone that remotely values your opinion has no idea what their doing in fantasy sports. i just made a comment in one of your articles but i guess you'd rather me right here and i'd love to see how you can possibly support your rankings, ok this was just my intro i need to use all the characters for my actual post bc there are just so many problems with your rankings its insane.
ok my first post was based off just looking at your top 40 rb but now that i saw the rest of your rankings i just feel bad for you. i don't know how you have a job as a fantasy football analyst, ok lets get to my problems.
LT #2: This compared to everything else you messed up isn't awful since there is a chance, but the fact that you said your "down on him" but still put him two makes no sense.
Westbrook #3: Ok this is when I first realized your not a legitimate fantasy writer. You do realize that he's been injury plagued his whole career, now is getting older and worn down by time and is entering training camp not healthy. Further they just drafted McCoy whose going to steal a ton of his carres.
Joseph Addai #8: Somehow you topped your westbrook pick, were you alive last year? Addai HAD manning and was awful. Now with Brown around I don't understand how he can be a top 10 rb, really hes not even top on his team.
Turner #9: Way too low, damn ran out of space your too d
ok clearly I don't have enough room to write explanations I will just state the average of the rest of fantasy world vs yours
Tom Brady: You: 1, World: 15ish
Randy Moss: You: 2, World: 15ish
LT: You: RB2 World: RB7
West: You: 6, RB3 World: 20ish, RB15ish
Addai: You: 12 RB8 World: 50ish, RB20ish
ok now im just wasting my time ill wait for your response before embarassing you more
Brady and Moss, #1 and #2... makes zero sense.
AP is the #1 overall pick and arguments can be made for Turner (TD heavy), as well as Forte, Westbrook, and MJD (PPR leagues).
The only way Brady is the #1 pick is if points are awarded for completions, 300 yard games get you a bonus of say 10 points, and TDs are worth 10 points. Otherwise, nope... and Brees would still be my first QB.
Moss needs to get in line behind the other elites: Fitzgerald, Andre, and Wayne. Moss can go 4th. ADP for Brady should be late 2nd, early 3rd. ADP for Moss should be middle 2nd.
I don't know that the harsh words are warranted, but I do disagree with quite a few of your selections. I guess that's the point... good discussions!
1. Do you really have 19 running backs above Steve Slaton, including Marshawn Lynch, who will miss the first three games of the season? Slaton had 1650 total yards and 10 TD as a rookie.
2. Ray Rice will be the most productive of the Ravens' running backs. McClain is going back to fullback and McGahee has worn out his welcome.
3. In no format does McNabb belong above Peyton Manning or Aaron Rodgers. I'm not sure who you are referring to when you say the Eagles have a deep set of receivers.
Got something to say?
Examiner.com is looking for writers, photographers, and videographers to join the fastest growing group of local insiders. If you are interested in growing your online rep apply to be an Examiner today!