Although the words were uttered silently, Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito's response to the open Obama attack on the high court, i.e. 'that's not true,' blasted forth like Gabriel's Trumpets across the planet.
Alito's response was the 'Joe Wilson moment' of the speech. Real Clear Politics has the video.
(AP Photo/Network Pool)
Joe Wilson is the U.S. Congressman from South Carolina who spontaneously yelled out 'You Lie' to the President during his last address to Congress. But Alito's response was non-disruptive and highly telling.
For the first time in U.S. history a sitting President has used the State-of-the-Union speech to slam the U.S. Supreme Court--one of the three branches of the federal government. Even FDR in his rage over the Court's many decisions that declared his programs unconstitutional did not dare take a swipe at the Justices during a State-of-the-Union speech.
Given the historic nature of the Obama attack, one would think that the issue at hand is one of extreme national significance that represents the outrage of Congress and the citizens concerning a Court ruling.
Not in this case.
The issue is restoring the First Amendment right to free speech and free expression, which the Congress infringed by passing into law the ominous McCain-Feingold bill under the guise of 'campaign finance reform.' The problem is that the law has not prevented dirty money from passing into the hands of candidates (Obama's sleazy campaign of 2008 is a perfect case in point) but banned organizations representing millions of citizens from placing political ads on TV and radio in the days leading up to an election.
While groups of ill repute such as ACORN, SEIU, Apollo, the Tides Foundation, George Soros' Marxist front groups and others continued to pump millions of dollars into Leftwing campaigns, groups such as the NRA were hamstrung from presenting issue-oriented ads on TV prior to the vote.
The Court decided that the law is unconstitutional for that reason--the suppression of free speech. There are to be no 'anti-free speech zones' in the United States with regard to elections. Free speech is the very key to a clean, fair election based on an informed electorate.
But this is what sticks in Obama's craw. The Leftwing and 'progressives' don't want free speech for the fear that the public just may become informed about real issues pertaining to the vote.
As we are witnessing right before our very eyes, Obama himself was elected on the strength of hiding facts from the public. When he uttered the words 'hope and change,' the electorate thought he meant change from George W. Bush, not discarding the Constitution and fundamentally changing America from top to bottom into a Marxist state.
And Obama continues to lie and hide facts. Even the Associated Press, which has been very lenient with this President, did a fact-check showing multiple instances where Obama failed the truth test.
In addition to the analysis of the AP, it is clear that Obama engaged in some barefaced whopper-telling, the most glaring of which are the notion that he has 'created 2 million jobs' and that he has 'cut taxes.' These statements are FALSE. We have lost double the number of jobs Obama claims to have created, and tax credits are not the same thing as tax cuts...a typical trick of semantics this President is famous for using.
But the big stunner is that even the New York Times took Obama to task over his remarks, going as far as saying that Alito was right and Obama was wrong.
When a Leftwing President loses the Leftwing New York Times on any issue, we can rest assured that trouble is brewing in paradise.
For commentary on other issues, visit my blog at The Liberty Sphere.











Comments
I don't feel it was so much Alito's "You Lie" moment but Obama's "YOU LIED" moment and in front of the judges he was referencing.
I am woundering if the SCOTUS can hold the President now in contempt of court for deliberately misleading the public. (Not to mention Obama holds a Law Degree and should be able to decipher a simple ruling from the SCOTUS.) That is unless there was an alterior motive to lie "Under Oath" which Obama is still under contract to uphold.
The Judges were in their official robes and like an officer of the law, once the uniform is on all things are official thus making Obama's statement a contemptable offence.
A lie is a lie no matter how you slice it and Clinton was impeached for lying under oath to a grand jurry now Obama has Lied to all three branches of government and the American people in one sitting with no take backs as it was live on the air.
Just a thought what do you think?
Gandalff
I don't know if it would hold up under intense legal scrutiny, but I admit I was thinking at the time O said it that the Chief Justice should immediately arise, walk to the podium, and place O under contempt of court. We certainly have all the evidence we need concerning the multiple lies he told in that speech.
If anything we have him on badgering the witnesses. =D
Joking aside: I really felt enraged and sorry for the SCOTUS at the time he made the statements, especially knowing some of the details of the case and the opinion that Kennedy wrote.
That is no excuse for Obama & his highly paid team of consultants & Czars not to inform him of the facts on a case he is about to go public with and scold-lie in front of all three branches of government and the American Public.
The "Office of the President" is the most powerful in the world but that does not put him above the law. He is no longer a Senator Campaigning & looking to score political points, he is my President as well even if I did not vote for him & he like all Presidents are held to a higher degree of scrutiny under the law to proport the facts as they are on all subjects(excluding divulging Security) & to project Americas future with optimism and truth as his or her guiding light. "Because justice is blind... not deaf"
Got something to say?
Examiner.com is looking for writers, photographers, and videographers to join the fastest growing group of local insiders. If you are interested in growing your online rep apply to be an Examiner today!