We think you're near Los Angeles

Currently in Los Angeles

Location: Los Angeles Current temperature: 50°F: Current condition: Clear See Extended Forecast

Authors Arguing: The Harlequin Debate

On November 17th, Harlequin announced Harlequin Horizons, its new self-publishing venture with Author Solutions. The newly formed Harlequin Horizons made their motives quite clear in this quote from the original press release:

Titles published through Harlequin Horizons will be monitored for excellence and retail potential for possible pick-up by Harlequin's leading traditional imprints.

 
The result? Immediate debate. The RWA, MWA  and SFWA expressed outrage, concern and overall disapproval of Harlequin’s new program, especially due to Harlequin’s decision to refer aspiring writers to Harlequin Horizons in rejection letters from the traditional press.
 
A Vanity Press?
Google Harlequin Horizons and you’ll find a plethora of websites and blogs referring to the new program as a vanity press. What exactly is a vanity press? The US National Endowment for the Arts defines a vanity press as:
one that does any of the following: requires individual writers to pay for part or all of the publication costs; asks writers to buy or sell copies of the publication; publishes the work of anyone who subscribes to the publication or joins the organization through membership fees; publishes the work of anyone who buys an advertisement in the publication; publishes work without competitive selection; or publishes work without professional editing.
 
In the Book Examiner’s opinion, the problem with the term vanity press is that it’s dated. It can’t include Print-on-Demand presses because many authors who choose to use POD technology 1) have their work professionally edited 2) only use the press as a printer and 3) pay nothing to the press. POD presses such as Lulu allow authors to utilize their services in a manner that permits complete publishing freedom with no cost to the author.
 
Are Times a-Changing?
At the core of this debate is still the traditional vs self-published tirade. New technologies are allowing writers to publish their work at no cost, thus creating a new market. Authors can use Amazon’s Digital Text Platform and upload their work for Kindle download in a matter of moments. Another publishing service, Smashwords, allows authors to upload their work for purchase in multiple electronic formats. It’s easy. It’s quick. And many call it a shortcut to publishing.

If shortcut implies skipping the man in the middle, then perhaps POD and ePublishing are shortcuts to publication. But what if the shortcut wasn’t just a shortcut, but a new path entirely? Blazed by a few, ventured by many and proven successful, new technologies can change the publishing playing field entirely. If one were to consider the eReader as an iPod for books, this change seems not only possible, but entirely inevitable.


Follow the Debate:

 

Advertisement

By

Pittsburgh Books Examiner

Holly Christine is an author and avid reader. For review requests, blog and contact information, visit her website.

Comments

  • Eva Ulian 2 years ago
    Report Abuse

    I’ve heard all kinds of accusations made against such publishers- that they are luring naive authors with the “farming” bit, with the distribution- even world wide- bit, with taking the author’s money and run, with inundating the author’s garage with thousands of unwanted books, that they are desecrating the name they bear. However, there’s one thing I’ve not heard at all sounded in the air and that is, the money such publishers earn from the self-published authors is bunked together with the traditional branch- now that piece of news should have at least made quite a few bones rattle in the publishing world- and yet not a word.

    So I shall say something about this: All you agents, published authors out there, it is time to stop moaning, it is time to stop calling self-published authors stupid because it will be thanks to the money I spend on publishing my book, that yours gets printed for free and it is my money that it will get it sponsored and agents can reap the rewards. There’

  • Eva Ulian 2 years ago
    Report Abuse

    (Continued from above) There’s no justice. Justice will be done if and when I get to sell a heck lots more books than yours ever will and I will get the same amount of royalty for 100 books sold that you would for 10,000. So all you moaners out there who enjoy cat calling us “inferior” authors will one day have to find answers for these questions. Who is a second class author? Who is naive? Who is mentally retarded? A WestBow Author is, of course, is what you say today... We’ll see.

Add a new comment

Join the conversation! Log in here or create a new account if you've never registered before.

Got something to say?

Examiner.com is looking for writers, photographers, and videographers to join the fastest growing group of local insiders. If you are interested in growing your online rep apply to be an Examiner today!

Don't miss...