Skip to main content
  1. News
  2. Top News

VHS rental jail time: Woman jailed over 2005 late dues, 'Monster-in-Law' movie

See also

Jail time for an overdue VHS rental? That appears to be the case for one South Carolina woman who was recently arrested for never returning a movie she rented back in 2005 — “Monster-in-Law” starring Jennifer Lopez. KCENTV News reveals this Monday, Feb. 17, 2014, that the identity of this “suspect” has been made clear as 27-year-old Kayla Michelle Finley, who is fighting against these charges, claiming that she is no criminal.

While the nature of this story might sound strange in and of itself, the VHS rental jail time incident came into public awareness this week after media sources learned that a woman spent a night in jail earlier this month for not ever returning a video that she rented over seven years ago in 2005. The movie was a now-outdated VHS tape of Jennifer Lopez’s “Monster-in-Law,” and apparently these overdue fees were enough to land the woman behind bars.

Kayla Michelle Finley was formally placed under arrest this Thursday in South Carolina on a misdemeanor charge of neglecting to properly return a licensed video. The VHS tape that might have started with simple overdue fees but eventually led to jail time was originally rented from a now out-of-business video store known as Dalton Videos.

The 27-year-old woman was allegedly at the county sheriff’s office for different reasons when it was discovered by police that there was in fact a still active criminal warrant out for her arrest on charges of the failure to return the VHS tape from the movie store back in 2005. County Chief Deputy Creed Hashe said that a judge for Pickens County had filed for the warrant after Finley never brought the VHS back several years ago.

According to the press release in this VHS rental jail time case, Finley had been formally sent a number of letters about the overdue tape and to turn herself in to police authorities. The woman was forced to spend a night behind bars due to her hearing not being available to take place until that Friday morning. She was later released on a $2,000 bond.

Finley said that her being put in jail was completely uncalled for. She explained that while renting the “Monster-in-Law” VHS tape, she was suddenly forced to move out of state due to her husband’s job being changed, and just forgot about the movie.

"I'm no criminal, but Pickens County Sheriff's office sure made me feel like I was,” she added.



  • Gaza school shelled
    Israeli airstrikes topple a school in Gaza suspected of housing rockets; dozens killed
  • Ebola outbreak
    An American with Ebola virus died shortly after boarding three planes
    World News
  • Why dogs smell butts
    Researchers figure out why dogs like to smell each other's butts
  • Time to stop tanning
    The surgeon general advises us not to tan as melanoma cases are on the rise
    Health News
  • Zimmerman lands dream job
    George Zimmerman lands his dream job as a security guard at a gun/motorcycle shop
  • 10 smartest states
    Here are the 10 most educated states in the U.S., did yours make the cut?
    US News