Skip to main content
  1. Leisure
  2. Food & Drink
  3. Restaurants

The best key lime pie at Fogarty's in Key West

See also

Believe it or not Key West is not known for it's beaches and yet, it's always teeming with both locals and visitors alike. People flock to the island for it's great bars and restaurants. They also go for the key lime pie and Fogarty's restaurant on famous Duval Street serves some of the best key lime pie you'll ever eat.

The key lime pie at Fogarty's is priced at just $3.95 and is truly a little slice of heaven. It has the consistency and creaminess of a cheese cake. It's tart and sweet and both flavors are balanced nicely. Neither one is overpowering. It's topped with homemade whipped cream and a slice of key lime.

You will not find better key lime pie anywhere else.



  • Nail art
    Top 5 ways to express yourself whether your nails are short or long
    Nail Art
  • Cars
    These cars have gotten the heave-ho: Will you miss them when they’re gone?
    7 Photos
  • Spinach quiche
    Mini spinach quiche are great for party snacks or for appetizers
    7 Photos
  • Peacock Inn
    Seasonal five course tasting menu at The Peacock Inn in Princeton
    6 Photos
  • Makeup
    Is the new Wonder Woman makeup similar to Kim Kardashian's look?
    8 Photos
  • Wavy hair tips
    Grab your flat iron and start curling with it to get these beautiful waves
    7 Photos