Skip to main content
  1. News
  2. Top News

Supreme Court won't hear case about business refusing service for gay wedding

See also

On Monday, the Supreme Court of the United States declined to hear the case involving a photographer from New Mexico who refused to photograph a gay couple’s wedding ceremony. By declining to hear the case, the decision made by New Mexico’s highest court is left to stand. That decision, which was also supported by lower courts, was that the photographer was discriminating against the couple.

The photographer, named Elaine Hugeuenin, and her husband run a photography studio together. Though the studio says it will offer services such as portraits to gay couples, they would not be able to photograph a “nontraditional” wedding. The Huguenins’ statement to the court was that photographing a gay or lesbian wedding would “require them to create expression conveying messages that conflict with their religious beliefs.”

Though the couple’s statement often discusses their religious background, the defense that was used was the First Amendment. In their petition to the court, the Huguenins and their lawyer say that since Elaine’s photography is an artistic expression, she shouldn’t be forced to say something she doesn’t believe by the government.

However, the New Mexico human right commission found that the couple did violate the New Mexico Human rights act. The commission stated that not providing your public service to a gay couple would be on the same level as not providing service to a mixed race couple. The high court stated that offering photography as a public service was a business decision and is not about freedom of speech.

Gay rights groups are viewing the Supreme Court’s declination as a ‘win’ for gay rights issues. In their view, they believe that selling a public service, like wedding photography, does not explicitly mean that the business owner supports the customer’s marriage. They state that it is simply a business owner’s responsibility to protect customers from discrimination. They believe it is a practice that businesses must all adhere to, without exception.



  •  Day 17
    Israel continues their ravaging bombardment on Gaza as the conflict wages on
  • MH17 victims arrive home
    40 bodies of the MH17 plane crash return to a somber homecoming in Holland
    Top News
  • Military advisers to Ukraine
    President Obama announces the deployment of military advisers to Ukraine
  • Bubonic plague in China
    A bubonic plague outbreak in Yumen prompts China to quarantine the city
    World News
  • Air Algierie disappearance
    A flight headed from Burkina Faso to Algeria disappears from radar over Mali
  • Windows Phone training portal
    Microsoft launches Windows Phone training portal in attempt to woo consumers