Skip to main content

See also:

Robert Oscar Lopez: Same-sex parenting is slavery, banned by 13th amendment

Robert Oscar Lopez
Robert Oscar Lopez

On April 7, 2014, Robert Oscar Lopez appeared on Sandy Rios in the Morning to claim that same-sex couples who are raising children are "redefining what it means to be human" and reintroducing slavery.

"I believe every child has a natural born right to his mother and father and ultimately those rights were taken away from them because adults made a decision that the child was not a party to because he didn't exist or was too young to decide that," said Lopez. "Even if you could come up with some study that showed that 95% of the children are okay with it, we as a society already went through a huge debate in the United States about owning other people and we decided — the Thirteenth Amendment is worded very sweepingly not just to ban what was specifically happening on Southern plantations but to ban any kind of practice. It says 'slavery shall not exist,' any kind of arrangement where you have a legal contract upon another human being is banned.

"So the mother-father relationship to the child is a natural one that is structured around obligations to the child, anytime that you turn that around and you say that adults have a right to a child, really all of society then becomes put into an ethical problem because all of society is redefining what it means to be human, what it means to be a child, what it means to be a free citizen and what it means to have freedom. I don't think you can really be free if you're born with a price on your head."

This is not the first time Lopez has tried to inject slavery into the marriage equality debate. He had previously come to this column's attention for promoting a conspiracy theory that gay men were going to use women as "breeding slaves".

To call this grasping at straws would be a tremendous understatement. Especially given that Lopez's argument, when taken to its literal conclusion, would define all forms of parenting as slavery.

This is the slippery slope the American Taliban has been trying to ice skate up for over thirty years. Their positions cannot possibly be articulated without sabotaging themselves except to directly advocate for blatant inequality.