Summary: Juliet goes undercover on a dating site while Shawn tries to contain his jealous. Meanwhile, Gus has luck with the dating site when he believes that he’s found his dream girl.
Guest starring: Cybill Shepherd (TV show ‘Cybill’), Parminder Nagra (Bend it like Beckham)
Maggie (Shepherd) leads Shawn helping Henry into his house. Her and Shawn talk and she wants him to take care of Henry after she leaves in a couple of days. She says that Shawn should use this time to get ot know him in a ‘different way’. He says he won’t promise her anything but will think about.
Shawn is helping Juliet assemble a desk. He tells her his lease is almost up. He tells her that he’s going to move in with Henry, but she thought he was going to move in with her.
Shawn walks in on Gus taking pictures of himself. He says it’s for his online profile. He shows her a picture of a woman he has a date with. Shawn tells Gus he’s moving in with Henry. Gus looks through the website and finds Juliet’s profile as Helene and he shows Shawn, who didn’t know about it.
Shawn goes to the restaurant where Juliet is on a date with a man named Mike. Juliet tells the man that Shawn is her ex. Lassiter is listening on the conversation. McNabb comes over and Shawn realizes that it’s a set-up. He apologizes. Shawn goes to the kitchen and Lassiter yells at him.
At the station, Chief is giving a run down of the two female victims that have died. They are connected via the dating website that Gus and Juliet were on. There are 6 possible suspects. Shawn steps to the front of the room and gets mad at her for what she’s doing. He asks in on case and Chief agrees.
Shawn goes to the Psych station where Gus is on a date with Rachel (Nagra).Shawn sees them getting along and he’s not liking it. Gus gets mad at him and shoos him out of the office.
Shawn goes to see his parents. Maggie tries to get Shawn to talk to Henry. Henry tells him to clean the garage. Shawn asks for the truck to go to a date that Juliet is having with another man. Maggie says she will be moving in until Henry is up on his feet and Shawn sees it as him moving in with his parents.
At Juliet’s date with Lorden, they are the movies. Gus sees Juliet at the movies. He gets mad at her but doesn’t make a scene. At the end of the date, Lorden asks Juliet to turn around because he’s got a surprise for her. Juliet gives off the code phrase and Lassiter and Shawn rush off to where she is.
Lorden ends up putting a necklace on her. Shawn and Lassiter appear and she gives them message that she’s fine. Shawn starts hugging Lassiter as a way to not blow cover.
Shawn gets home and his parents are watching a movie. Shawn joins them in watching the movie.
Chief introduces Juliet and Shawn to a Fielding, a tech rep for the dating site. They look up Mr. Possibilites. Chief and Juliet admire his good looks. Fielding says that he needs to spruce up her site.
Gus shows up at the station with Rachel. Shawn comes out and gets mad that they are still together.
Juliet is trying on dresses for Shawn. She runs into Lorden that sent her the necklace. Maggie shows up and tries to buy him clothes. Lorden asks out Juliet. But she says no. Juliet asks why he Mr. Possibilities won’t ask her out and she gets jealous of the victims. Shawn gets an epiphany that it might be one of the jealous girls that he wouldn’t talk to.
Shawn had Fielding look up Mr. Possibilities inbox. They find a girl who sent him a whole bunch of messages that weren’t respond. The girl is Rachel.
Shawn goes to Gus/Rachel date at mini-golf. He says he bust in to apologize. Then he accuses her of being a murderer. Shawn asks about her messages to Mr. Possibilities. Rachel says she was in New York when the first girl was murdered.
Shawn calls Juliet and asks her out. And she rejects him saying she’s going out with Mr. Possibilities. She says that she wants him to be there but he gets mad because everyone has someone else.
Shawn goes home to talk to his parents and catches them in bed together. Henry goes to talk to Shawn. He sees Mr. Possibilities in an ad. He realizes that the pictures on the profile are photo-shopped.
Gus takes Shawn go to where Mr. Possibilities (Ken Dowling) lives, where he is married with a family. Shawn and Gus goes inside and tell Ken’s wife and tells her about Ken’s online profile. Shawn calls in the arrest.
Shawn tells Lassiter/Juliet about how he got Ken.
Fielding calsl Shawn and says that there is activity on his account, ten minutes ago. He says that the guy they arrested is not Mr. Possibilities.
Juliet goes to leave her rendezvous when Mike shows up.
They start talking. Mike says that Mr. Possibilities doesn’t exist.
Shawn tells Lassiter that Juliet is in trouble.
Mike pulls a gun on Juliet. He says that he’s doing this to prove a point that the women want to date the good looking guy and not the good guy. Shawn figures out that it’s Mike from the 1st date. Mike continues talking about the girls he dated and why they broke up. Shawn/Gus/Lassiter arrive at the scene. She turns around to talk to him and he pushes her to the ground. She says that she didn’t think he liked her. She starts flirting with him. She takes off his glasses and continues flirting. She kisses him before tackling him to the ground.
Shawn and Juliet talk. He tells her that she is his home and that he wants to move in with her. And she says yes.
Gus deletes his online profile. Rachel comes in. Shawn apologizes again. Rachel says she would never interfere with their friendship. She tells him she has a son.