Coal-fired plants emit twice the CO2 than gas-fired plants
Other Articles
Commentary:
Boxing's pound-for-pound king and Filipino superstar Manny Pacquiao voiced his opposition last month against the construction of a 200-megawatt (MW) coal-fired power plant. The proposed initiative is located in Pacquiao's hometown of Sarangani Province, which is situated in the southern Philippines.
Pacquiao, who intends to run as representative in the Philippine Congress during the May 2010 elections, galvanized support from various civil and religious groups to prevent the proposed large-scale project from being built.
The Kamanga Power Plant (KPP) proposes to supply electricity to the Mindanao grid, and is a project championed by Conal Holdings Corporation (CHC). CHC is a joint venture with Thailand company Egko and Mindanao-based Alsons Consolidated Resources. The family of the Sarangani governor holds a significant equity stake in the venture, as reported by Philippine Inquirer.
The project would require an initial capital outlay of $450 million (or nearly 21 billion Philippine pesos), and would be operational by 2012 at the earliest. There are several proposals around the country for building similar power plants. In 2008, Taiwan-based Cogeneration International Corp., a partner of Aboitiz Energy, proposed a similar project in Subic, the site of a former U.S. naval base and converted commercial complex. CHC attempted to pacify opposition by advancing plans for a 10,000 hectare "carbon sink" resorvoir, where harmful greenhouse gas such as carbon dioxide (CO2) can be re-injected into the ground, where the stored gas would avoid polluting the atmosphere.
Coal
Coal is the most plentiful fossil fuel, but it is also the dirtiest. Coal-fired generation facilities can emit twice the CO2 than a natural gas-fired power plant. Methane gas, another climate change pollutant, is at least 20 times more powerful than CO2, and is another greenhouse gas (GHG) that numerous industry sectors (such as landfills, mining operations, and manufacturers) are emitting into the atmosphere. These factor into the global warming phenomenon as the sun's heat is unable to escape into outer space. Rather, they are reflected back to the earth. The sulfuric content of hydrocarbon fuels also contributes to acid rain.
Unfortunately, few technical data were provided that laid out the operational specifications for such a "carbon sink" in Sarangani. The advancement of carbon capture and storage (CCS) technologies is critical for the continued economic advancement of developing countries like India and China without a high negative impact on global environment and climate conditions. However, associated large-scale CCS technologies are in the proving stages and can be very expensive. The Canadian government, for instance, is deploying capital from its C$2 billion fund dedicated solely for CCS, including the capture, transportation, injection, and storage of CO2. Canada's CCS initiative in the Alberta oil sands aims to reduce carbon emissions by one million tons a year. As an added benefit, the carbon will be used for enhanced oil recovery operations. By pumping and injecting it over 2,000 meters below the earth's surface, oil yields increase on surface wells. The carbon would be permanently stored underneath cap rock.
Advancing initiatives such as CCS require numerous operational controls, company guarantees, financial commitment (despite retracted lending and investing practices), coordinated government oversight and protocols, media transparency, and management culture. These would all have to be in place to ensure that a long-term re-injection project would not harm the region's drinking water, environment, and citizen public.
Alternatives
Proposals for coal-fired power plants appear to be sprouting around the Philippines because the political climate enveloping North America, Europe, and international institutions such as the United Nations, is clearly directed at managing and reducing carbon emissions. The referenced C$2 billion Canadian fund aims at reducing four to five million tonnes of emissions per year by 2015. The strategy might be viewed as pre-emptive: "build the long-term dirty plants now, before clean laws are passed, and people and officials won't be able to do anything about it once the massive complex is built."
An Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle (IGCC) plant would be a better alternative. A reaction between coal and water produces synthesis gas, or syngas, which can then undergo purification. It can emit half the GHG pollutants than a conventional coal-fired power plant. Gasification is a proven technology and is gaining greater implementation around the world.
More information:
Pacquiao Politics Requiring Competency Exclusive Interviews: Manny Pacquiao
Manny Pacquiao and Global Transcendence 5 Risky Moves for Manny Pacquiao
1 or 2 More Fights for Pacman? Defending Manny and the Meaning of Loyalty
Manny Pacquiao and American Equivalence Boxing's Climax: Manny vs. Mayweather
Coal is a quick and cheap way to get "dirty" energy. The initial capital investment for a straight coal-fired plant - without appropriate CCS technologies - is cheaper than say a cleaner natural gas-fired co-generation facility. But it appears they will be more expensive to maintain over the long-run, especially if the Philippines adopts international treaties and environmentally-related protocols that the West is pushing for. The United States Congress is taking action that could make cap-and-trade legislation the impetus for new co-generation benchmark practices; one that hinges on renewable and clean technologies that preserve the global environment, as well as, further enable economic efficiencies to materialize for emerging advances. World energy consumption is expected to increase from 472 quadrillion Btu in 2006 to 552 quadrillion Btu in 2015, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration.
Matthew Simmons, founder of Houston-based energy investment bank Simmons International and widely considered as an authority on the oil sector, believes in the peak oil theory - that oil fields are declining in petroleum output and cannot keep up with mounting global demands. Various data support his view, and many industry experts and policymakers warn of an energy crises if other resources are not fully utilized on a mass scale.
Renewable altenatives for power such as natural gas, coal bed methane, synthetic gas (gasification) and hydrocarbon cleansing enablers, biomass feedstock (algae to fuel, animal fats, oilseed plants), wind, and solar can be a more expensive proposition on the front end, but the cost curve appears to be declining as technologies, efficiencies, and the compliance landscape evolve. These renewables are sustainable long-term solutions for energy demands. Anticipated improvements and global adoption will make them palatable and practical. Their higher up-front costs will require tremendous financial, long-term, consistent, transparent, and technical commitment from the Philippine government, and from nationally elected officials. There is no room for monkey business. President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo, a trained economist, has been ramping up tax collections on the private sector. But the country remains economically weary from a sustained global recession that is expected to extend beyond the 2010 horizon. Any uncoordinated effort spearheaded by sporadic local governments is likely doomed to failure due to lack of advanced technical know-how, community understanding and support, corruption, and a backlogged court system should company actions fall outside legal parameters.
1 2
| Part 2 |
Comments
marv damon...i really dont like your article.....zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz!!!!!!! im not interested with your topic....this is boxing site fyi
Sir, 21 billion pesos po hindi 2.1 ang estimated na katumbas sa 450m US dollars
Marv- This is the best article I have ever read by an Examiner. Congratulations!!! I have spoken to Manny about the importance of CleanTech and I am energized by seeing this. The Philippines MUST quickly move toward clean/renewable energy sources to meet many of the goals that many young politicians currently favor in your country. Manny is my buddy. I will get him to see the light, but if you know MP, you know there are some folks around him who could care less about CleanTech and are more interested in fleecing your national icon. There are some good people around MP, you just need to know who to approach to get the job done. MP has a great wife and kids. They give him immeasurable strength and I have huge trust in them showing him where the light comes from. Keep the faith, Marv. Don't give up on Manny. He is the ONE for your country.
Great article Marv, just ignore the guy below "ofw".
Why Manny wants to enter politics is beyond me. He has the name, money, fame........... politics and being government official will destroy the Manny that we all know.
No way he can change the traditional way of working in the Philippine government. Sure he can try it'll be a waste of his time. He can help other people in many ways. Don't need to be goverment KURAKOT official.
Though Manny shows concern about climate change, he is still ignorant or i may say innocent about this coal project.
Me,too is totally at a loss about this coal.
In pinoy lingo, coal means uling. We use this coal or uling for cooking and for ironing clothes sa plantsa.
And where do we get uling, from coconut shell or bao and from fire woods that came from fallen trees.
So, Manny thought coal would be cutting trees again that may result in climate change.
As you know, mindanao mountains are now bald like an eagle,ask the logger who are now politicians.
That is Manny's point, coal or uling will means logging tha may result in climate change as uling smoke is maitim that may blacken the sky. But uling is useful, as our kawali or frying pan uling is used in ulingan, a children's game or in wake.
Let's give Manny a chance about coal,at least he is concern about trees that may become uling...meaning forest inundation again.
Gloria: why don't we make Mindanao a big parking lot?
Teodoro: we don't have enuff cars & trucks to park there.
Gloria: ur right.
abu sayyaff: long live Arroyo & Estrada!!!!
America is the greatest. The land of the free and gr8 crusaders.
mang godo, you too is ignorant! please read and research!
mang godo bobo ka ba? alam ni manny yan.. baka di mo alam. coal is mined.. the one that u are referring to is charcoal. americans also use this.. ang bobo mo naman. sanasabi mo pa n si manny an bobo. isang ka kang ignorante at tanga
when i take a dump in the toilet, harmful and very p[olluting coal comes out it harms the atmosphere and damages the lungs
there is also gas the comes out of my pipeline and goes subsea it is powerful enuff to produce electricity if you let it ferment in laboratory watch u mean to tell me i can turn my waste into cash? who do i call?
pinoy4ever says:
"mang godo bobo ka ba? alam ni manny yan.. baka di mo alam. coal is mined.. the one that u are referring to is charcoal. ang bobo mo naman. isang ka kang ignorante at tanga."
pasensiya ka na pinoy forever, grade one lang ang tinapos ko.kaya medyo hindi ako nakakintindi lalo na yang climate change.
akala ko coal e uling, kasi maitim din.
you monomania, dementia praecox.
mga igans maraming pweding ilagay na power plant dito pinas maliban diyan sa coal fired plant na yan .Kung gastusan lang gobeyerno ang solar power energy di walang polllution, walang climate change ,walang uling ,walang maitim na ulap at hangin,at wala ng pelegro sa baha.gaya ngayon patuloy pa ang pakawala ng tubig sa mga dumsite sa lahat ng parte ng Luzon at sana wala na rin mag uuling para di na makalbo ang bundok, sa mga mag to troso diyan aba ay tumigil na kung ayaw niyong mabura ang mapa ng pilipinas dahil lang sa ellegal logging na yan at kahit nga legal di pwede.mag isip na dapat ang pinoy!
Juggs,
who do u call?
u call Ghostbusters!
mas bobo pa pala itong Juggs na ito
geothermal power should be exploited in manny's province.
To MangMang Godo,
Below is the link of the article that Manny's wrote about the above captioned subject. And after you read this I want you to slap your face hard enough to awaken your still dreaming blood clotted brain.
omit the space between http: and // and . and com
http: //philboxing. com/news/list.articles.php?aid=1130&id=27688
Good article! Manny is winable this coming election if he knock out first cotto on thier upcoming bout this coming 14th of november.
This is not Sandigang bayan pasa mo yan ang article mo sa gobyerno sila ang pweding magbigay nang solusyon dyan pare..ang mai tulong sa atin ni pakyaw ay hwag magpatalo sa kay cotto pero ung coal power mo sa tingin ko matagal na na issue yan pabalik balik lang gusto lang magnakaw ang mga iyan pare sa pera ni pakyaw basta pakyaw hwag kang magpa uto pera mo yan pinag hirapan mo yan dapat bago nila makuha sa iyo boxing muna sila sa yo....
Got something to say?
Examiner.com is looking for writers, photographers, and videographers to join the fastest growing group of local insiders. If you are interested in growing your online rep apply to be an Examiner today!