Skip to main content
Report this ad

Opposition to Arizona immigration bill exposes Neocon hypocrisy

The New immigration bill which is by far the toughest in the nation has created controversy. Many of its critics say that the bill amounts to racial profiling and even compared it to Nazi Germany.  There are Constitutional concerns that the bill violates the 4th Amendment's right against unlawful search and seizures, because it gives law enforcement the authority to detain those suspected of being in the country illegally.

While it is understandable that the left and civil libertarians would oppose such a bill some of the staunchest criticism of the bill is coming from the same neocons who supported the Patriot Act and other measures to crack down on civil liberties. Fred Barnes of the Weekly Standard and Fox News pundit called the bill "draconian" and says "it goes way too far." George Bush's former political strategist Karl Rove denounced the bill saying "I think there is going to be some constitutional problems with the bill...."I wished they hadn't passed it, in a way."

While he makes legitimate points about the bill he has no credibility considering the fact that George Bush violated the constitution on many occasions such as the Patriot which also violates the 4th Amendment, enacted an unconstitutional war, and even said that "The Constitution is just a G_D piece of paper."

Besides prominent Neocons many hawkish Pro Israel organizations such as the Anti-Defamation League, American Jewish Committee, and Simon Wiesenthal Center have also condemned the Bill. The ADL stated it "seduces the people of Arizona with the false promise of improving safety and security in our state, but fails to do either," said Bill Straus, Arizona Regional Director. "In actuality, this bill drives a wedge between local law enforcement and the communities they are sworn to serve and protect. Members of our state's significant Latino and immigrant populations - citizens and non-citizens alike - will hesitate to come forward to report crimes or serve as witnesses. Instead, they will reside in the shadows and law enforcement will lose some of its best partners in the fight to keep our communities safe."

Assaf Oron points out in an article on the blog Mondoweiss titled "Israel has been ‘Arizona' all along" that "In Israel, laws like the Arizona one - and worse - have been in effect ever since independence. No, I'm not talking about the Occupation, but inside Israel proper. Any resident sixteen years of age or older must at all times carry an Identity card, and present it upon demand to a senior police officer, head of Municipal or Regional Authority, or a policeman or member of the Armed forces on duty. And guess against which ethnic group this requirement is enforced."

I guess if its good enough for Israel why not Arizona? But much like Karl Rove and Fred Barnes the ADL endorsed the Patriot Act, lobbied for thought crime laws, and was discovered to have a role in the Missouri State Police's targeting of those in the Patriot Movement. It is clear that these individuals and organizations do not care about individual liberties, so what is there incentive for opposing the bill.

In his article titled "MidEast Policy-Immigration Policy: Is The Other Boot About To Drop?" CSULB Prof. Kevin MacDonald points out that "the two issues of Israel and immigration relaxation (in the U.S.) have in common a deep and straightforward Jewish commitment to particular policies. My contention is that both policies have been construed by Jewish leaders as being helpful to the security and political influence of their community."

MacDonald adds "in the case of Israel, this is self-evident. In the case of immigration policy, there ample documentation of a consistent interest by the Jewish community, both in America and in Europe, in ending the hegemony of the host community amongst whom they live. The measures taken to enforce their chosen objectives suggest there is indeed an element of truth in what Foxman dismisses as "the old canard and conspiracy theory of Jewish control of the media, Congress, and the U.S. government".

Besides ethnic motivation among these special interest groups there are other motivations such as corporate and financial interest backers who rely on the cheap labor. However it not just proves their phoniness in concern for civil liberties about the bill but shows their insincerity in fighting the war on terror.

Former Constitution Party candidate for president Chuck Baldwin in an article titled "Open Border Prove War On Terror is Superficial" stated that "that for some seven years since the 9/11 attacks, our nation's borders and ports are as open and porous as ever. These open borders make the argument that "we are fighting them over there, so we won't have to fight them over here" look absolutely disingenuous--even laughable."


Baldwin adds "If the Bush administration was serious about fighting a war on terror, it would absolutely, resolutely, and immediately seal our borders and ports. It is nothing short of lunacy to send our National Guard forces to Iraq for the purpose of protecting that country's borders, while leaving America's borders wide open!"

There is legitimate concern about the bill leading to the arrest of American citizens but we are already in a police state with  random searches and warentless wiretaps. The Same individuals who are the biggest supporters of the police state are now outraged that it is targeting illegal immigrants. This is because they are globalist who have a vested interest in keeping our borders open.


















  • 5 years ago

    Nice job. Loose ends were related in meaningful ways to give clarity to a confusing issue.

  • JohnZ 5 years ago

    Strange how all those neocons as well as the organizations listed are all zionist/jew fronts for israhell.
    This simply proves the zionists goal to destroy America is being put into practice. By forcing America to accept the millions of illegals especially from Mehico, they are forcing American citizens to allow drug traffickers, murderers, rapists, thieves and anchor babies to infest our once great nation until it becomes a broken down cesspool. We are halfway there now.

  • soulsweet 5 years ago

    Thanks for this article....You've penetrated the real force that is behind the attempted destruction of Arizona's immigration bill...If you listen to the supposed conservative talk show host Michael Medved he has advocated an Amnesty for illegals but with the exception that they pay a fine(big friggin deal)and supports every action that Israel takes to control its problems with the Palestineans

  • MeanJeep 5 years ago

    Israel’s problem with some immigrants is their militia sworn duty to kill infidels using terror. America's problem with illegal's is that open borders does not differentiate between friend and foe. The hypocrisy that never gets mentioned is the fact that the Patriot act is still alive and well. Only now, those opposed to it then ARE using it against their own countrymen to protect the elites and government largess, while they put the screws to people like the Salahi's for crashing their elitist party. The classic common thread of deflection is the juvenile labels like Party Crashers, teabaggers, birthers, ad nauseam. Kind of like the Lewinski scandal, when in fact it was Clinton’s scandal filled name that should be front and center. It’s like redirecting fault, getting the media to cover in revisionism and your base to buy it, is the name of winning the hypocrisy game.

  • JKnTX 5 years ago

    "Strange how all those neocons as well as the organizations listed are all zionist/jew fronts for israhell.
    This simply proves the zionists goal to destroy America is being put into practice. By forcing America to accept the millions of illegals especially from Mehico, they are forcing American citizens to allow drug traffickers, murderers, rapists, thieves and anchor babies to infest our once great nation until it becomes a broken down cesspool. We are halfway there now".

    Kosovo. How many Americans today recall that we blasted the daylights out of the Orthodox Christian Serbs to save the majority Muslim ethnic Albanian "Kosovars" back under the reign of Slick Willie?
    Now it is coming back home to roost, what is good for the goose is good for the gander. America said it was ok for the Kosavars to infiltrate and take over what was the Serb holy land, so be it, now it is by the same token ok for the illegals here to move in and steal the American Southwest.

  • Mihail 5 years ago

    They are the so-called neo-cons, or neo-conservatives. A compact group, almost all of whose members are Jewish. They hold the key positions in the Bush administration, as well as in the think-tanks that play an important role in formulating American policy and the ed-op pages of the influential newspapers....

    Seemingly, all this is good for Israel. America controls the world, we control America. Never before have Jews exerted such an immense influence on the center of world power." Uri Avnery, "The Night After,"

    Counterpunch, April 10, 2003.

  • Edgardus de la Vega 5 years ago

    Our European-American homeland is now contending against two very 'anti-white' forces: neo-Aztec supremacism and Jewish Zionism. Unfortunately, both movements are further supported by gentile, white puppets in Congress.

    Such cowards as posturing actors (i.e. Congress) also reign 'supreme'. What folly!

  • goof 5 years ago

    To the people who wrote below my post: We are all candy. I'm a pack of Smarties...and you are all Dum Dum's.

  • OZZY 5 years ago

    Israel has a strict immigration policy.
    So does Mexico.
    So does almost every other (non-European) country

    So why can't the U.S.A?

    Because, we are being invaded.
    Our 'leaders' are committing treason by allowing and encouraging it to happen.

    They need to be tried, and prosecuted to the full extent of the law.

  • Bert 5 years ago

    Jewish extremism runs deep in supposedly liberal organizations such as the ADL and the ACLU.

  • dan 5 years ago

    ronald bola of 12764 newport ave #d tustin ca 92780 married and paid a US citizen to obtain a green card. he also used fake documents to get a US tourist visa and work here illegally in california. he is now a naturalized citizen.

Report this ad