Skip to main content
  1. News
  2. Top News

New York school cutting gifted program because too few minority students qualify

See also

This must be what Barack Obama meant in his State of the Union by a “ladder of opportunity.” Ladders, after all, are bidirectional. You can go up, but you can also go down.

And “down” is the only direction available from now to gifted applicants to P.S. 139 in the Ditmas Park section of Brooklyn. On Thursday the school announced that its SOAR program — short for “Students of Academic Rigor” — is being phased out. Smarter kids will just need to make the best of it down there with the kids who couldn’t make the grade.

Maybe I’m just being a gloomy Gus, failing to see the “good” that will come out of this move. New York’s left-leaning Daily News apparently sees it. The headline of the newspaper’s article reads “Brooklyn school cutting gifted program to boost diversity.”

The piece goes on to smear lipstick all over this pig, claiming that “school officials chose diversity over exclusivity.” In a letter to parents of prospective incoming kindergartners, Principal Mary McDonald wrote:

Our Kindergarten classes will be heterogeneously grouped to reflect the diversity of our student body and the community we live in.

The first part of the statement — the part about heterogeneous grouping — is pure doubletalk. But the part about “the community we live in” is a reflection of a harsh reality and an even harsher sentence imposed on students unlucky enough to come from privilege. The Daily News writer cites Education Department records that indicate that better than two thirds of the school’s roughly 1,000 students are black or Hispanic. If the mountain won’t come to Mohammed…

But not to worry. The letter from McDonald turns warm and fuzzy and upbeat:

At PS 139, we believe all children can learn and achieve high standards. We also know that we want all children at PS 139 to have equal access to high quality, challenging curriculum….

But “equal access” (in a second letter she calls it “equity”) and a “high quality, challenging curriculum” are mutually incompatible goals. If they weren’t the school wouldn’t be phasing out its gifted program.

For the Obama administration and Democrats to rail out at the wealthy and ascribe an unfair advantage to people whose only sin is ambition is wrongheaded. But when liberals start seeking to level the playing field for children by dumbing down learning for smarter kids to spare the feelings of the slower ones, they are crossing a dangerous line.

Related Articles

For more articles and headlines, be sure to check out Liberty Unyielding. Follow me on Twitter or join me at Facebook.

Advertisement

News

  • Obama's Asia trip
    President Obama arrives in Asia, though he's not necessarily getting a warm welcome
    Video
    Watch Video
  • Ferry survivors deal with guilt
    The few heroes of the Korean ferry disaster deal with unimaginable survivor's guilt
    World News
  • Biden in Ukraine
    Vice President Biden urges Moscow to avoid further unrest in Ukraine
    Politics
  • Pujols hits 500th home run
    Albert Pujols becomes the latest player to hit 500 home runs in his career
    Camera
    Sports
  • North Korean nuclear test?
    South Korea detects another possible nuclear test from North Korea
    Headlines
  • NYPD's Twitter campaign backfires
    NYPD's campaign designed to amicably engage New Yorkers and cops backfires horribly
    Video
    Watch Video

User login

Log in
Sign in with your email and password. Or reset your password.
Write for us
Interested in becoming an Examiner and sharing your experience and passion? We're always looking for quality writers. Find out more about Examiner.com and apply today!