Skip to main content
  1. AXS Entertainment
  2. Arts & Entertainment
  3. Movies

'Mistaken Identity' movie: True story of Rebecca Chittum-Callie Johnson

See also

"Mistaken Identity" is a movie based on the true story of switched at birth babies: Rebecca Grace Chittum and Callie Marie Johnson aka Callie Conley. The movie first aired under the title "Two Babies: Switched At Birth" in 1999 on CBS, according to Variety. The name was later changed to "Mistaken Identity" when the movie was released to DVD. The movie now airs on Lifetime and Lifetime Movie Network. The real names were changed in the film to disguise the basis of the true story.

"Mistaken Identity" synopsis/plot

Advertised as a movie "based on actual events," it follows the story of two young women, a single mother and a married woman who bond in the maternity ward as they go through labor. Linda Wells and Sarah Barlow are bonded together forever when a DNA test for a paternity suit reveals that Linda's 2-year-old child is not her biological child. The two families must make a decision: Switch the babies back or raise the children as their own but keep in contact.

According to the Movies Based On True Stories Archives, the real story happened in Virginia in 1995 involving a single mother and a couple. The real story ending is more tragic than the movie version.

You can read Traciy Curry-Reyes' research notes on the true story at the Movies Based on True Stories Archives.

Did you like that? Follow me on Facebook and subscribe by hitting the button above.


Today's top buzz...

  • Mariah Carey
    Mariah Carey requires kittens before a show, but that's not the strangest celebrity rider
    Music Buzz
  • Clayton Kershaw
    Watch Clayton Kershaw throw a ball at Jimmy Kimmel
    Today's Buzz
  • Jessie J
    Jessie J enlists Ariana Grande and Nicki Minaj for her new song 'Bang Bang'
    Music Buzz
  • Journey
    Journey and Steve Miller jam out at the Shoreline Amphitheater
    16 Photos
  • Batman
    Batman and Robin Originals reveal comedy secrets at Comic-Con press conference
    12 Photos
  • Metta World Peace
    Metta World Peace gets physical during the Venice Basketball League game
    Sports Buzz