Skip to main content
  1. News
  2. Top News

Manhattan Libertarian sues fed cops for illegal arrest

News from the Liberterrain…

"An amateur photographer is suing the Department of Homeland Security, saying his arrest for filming a political protest outside a Manhattan courthouse was illegal." – New York Daily News

The harassment of Antonio Musumeci ("Bile" to his
   friends) by federal officers has caught the attention of
   mainstream media news outlets, libertarians and civil
   rights advocates. (photo courtesy Antonio Musumeci)

More Libertarian Examiner coverage:

Last fall, Antonio Musumeci, membership director and webmaster of the Manhattan Libertarian Party, was forced to the pavement by federal officers, had the video card from his camera confiscated, arrested, detained, ticketed, and further harassed and threatened with arrest on two successive occasions.

On Thursday, the New York Civil Liberties Union filed a civil rights lawsuit on Musumeci's behalf against the Department of Homeland Security, Federal Protective Service, Inspector Clifford Barnes of the Federal Protective Service, and an unnamed federal officer.

The suit charges the agencies and individuals of "unconstitutionally restricting photography on federal property, including public plazas and sidewalks."

Musumeci, known to his friends as "Bile" from his online "Blog of Bile" was manhandled by the federal officers on November 9, 2009 while he was recording an interview in front of the courthouse steps in Manhattan with Julian Heicklen, well known to Libertarian News Examiner readers as a libertarian activist who frequently attempts to distribute Fully Informed Jury Association (FIJA) pamphlets at the site.

A week later, Musumeci was again harassed and threatened with arrest by the same Inspector Clifford Barnes and a "John Doe" officer while again trying to record Heicklen at the federal courthouse.

This past Monday, Musumeci was harassed a third time by the same federal officers.

While videoing Heicklen's FIJA pamphlet distribution efforts that day a man appearing to be a plainclothes officer "takes a photo of me using his cell phone," Musumeci wrote on his blog, and Officer Barnes "looks over at me and yells 'Having fun yet?'"

Later, as Musumeci is leaving, he reports, "Officer Barnes waves to me and yells from across the street, 'Bye, see you next week!'”

“I do not believe government agents have the legal or moral authority to stop people from filming on public property," Musumeci, told Serf City, a Manhattan Libertarian Party blog. "In this case, the outcome is particularly frustrating because I was creating political content and engaging in a form of political activism."

"The lawsuit seeks a court order to bar federal officials from harassing or arresting people taking photos while standing in outdoor public areas by federal buildings." – New York Times

Libertarians and civil rights advocates will be watching this one closely. 

Don't miss a NATIONAL LIBERTARIAN NEWS EXAMINER article: Click the Subscribe button at the top of the article and enter your email address or choose the RSS button. Either way you’ll be alerted to the latest piece when it's published. And don't forget to click Email to send this article to a friend.


What's happening in your area? Send me stories, photos, videos to publish in Libertarian News Examiner.


  • bile 4 years ago

    "A week later, Musumeci was again harassed and threatened with arrest by the same Inspector Clifford Barnes and a "John Doe" officer while again trying to record Heicklen at the federal courthouse."

    This is incorrect. I was harassed and threatened with arrest that day, Nov. 16th, 2009, but it was by separate officer who apparently shares my surname but is not listed on the complaint.

    All posts related to this can be found at my blog on the Activism/Filming Julian Heicklen page.

    Thanks for covering this.

  • Kent McManigal- 4 years ago

    Pathetic LEOs. Too stupid and/or lazy to get an honest job, so they attack people who are better than them.

  • RSDavis 4 years ago

    Fight the power, dude!

  • Garry Reed 4 years ago

    Bile, thanks for correcting the record. Every writer needs someone looking over his or her shoulder to keep the facts straight!

  • Jesse - Cochise County Libertarian Examiner 4 years ago

    Ahh and the true dictatorship emerges...welcome to the new America sheep...

Add a comment

Join the conversation! Log in here or create a new account if you've never registered before.

Got something to say? is looking for writers, photographers, and videographers to join the fastest growing group of local insiders. If you are interested in growing your online rep apply to be an Examiner today!



  • Obama's Asia trip
    President Obama arrives in Asia, though he's not necessarily getting a warm welcome
    Watch Video
  • Ferry survivors deal with guilt
    The few heroes of the Korean ferry disaster deal with unimaginable survivor's guilt
    World News
  • Biden in Ukraine
    Vice President Biden urges Moscow to avoid further unrest in Ukraine
  • Pujols hits 500th home run
    Albert Pujols becomes the latest player to hit 500 home runs in his career
  • North Korean nuclear test?
    South Korea detects another possible nuclear test from North Korea
  • NYPD's Twitter campaign backfires
    NYPD's campaign designed to amicably engage New Yorkers and cops backfires horribly
    Watch Video

User login

Log in
Sign in with your email and password. Or reset your password.
Write for us
Interested in becoming an Examiner and sharing your experience and passion? We're always looking for quality writers. Find out more about and apply today!