Skip to main content

See also:

Italian judge speaks out about controversial Amanda Knox murder conviction

Alessandro Nencini, the president of the Florence, Italy appeals court, which reinstated the murder conviction against Amanda Knox and her former boyfriend, Raffaele Sollecito, spoke out on Jan. 31, 2014 about the verdicts, hinting at reasons for the controversial rulings, according to The Independent.

An Italian judge has spoken out about the new murder convictions against American Amanda Knox and her ex-boyfriend, Raffaele Sollecito.
Photo by Franco Origlia/Getty Images

He told Corriere della Serra that decisions made by Knox on the night of Nov. 1, 2007, led to a series of events that resulted in the murder of British student Meredith Kercher.

Judge Nencini also said the court had determined there was a motivation for Meredith’s killing and noted that reasons behind the new verdicts would surface when the judgment is published within the next few months.

He also stated, “…all I can say is that at 20.15 that night, they had different plans; then these were ditched and the occasion [to commit the crime] was created… If Amanda had gone to work she probably wouldn’t be here now. There were coincidences and on this we have developed our reasoning. We realize this will be the most controversial part.”

On Jan. 30, 2014, the court sentenced Knox to 28 ½ years behind bars for the crime, while Sollecito was sentenced to 25.

Knox was convicted in Dec. 2009 of the 2007 killing of Meredith, 21, with whom she shared a cottage in Italy. The American student was initially sentenced to 26 years behind bars in an Italian prison.

View slideshow: Photos regarding the Amanda Knox case, including evidence and key players

Also found guilty of participating in the murder was Sollecito, who was sentenced to 25 years in prison, and drifter Rudy Guede who had his initial 30-year sentence reduced to 16 during an appeal.

In Oct. 2011, a panel of judges overturned both Knox and Sollecito’s convictions and acquitted the two of murder.

View slideshow: Photos of Raffaele Sollecito and His Alleged Girlfriend Annie Achille

Knox and Sollecito were released from prison and she subsequently returned to her hometown of Seattle, Wash., while he remained in Italy. Knox has not returned to Italy since.

On March 26, 2013, Italy’s highest court overturned Knox and Sollecito’s acquittals and a new murder trial began in September.

Knox will not likely be extradited to Italy to serve out her new sentence due to U.S. law that prohibits a person from being tried for the same crime twice, according to CNN.

Sollecito was detained on Jan. 31 near Austria by Italian police. He has subsequently said he was not trying to leave the country, but had crossed the border with his girlfriend and had returned to Italy to spend the night at a hotel in the mountains, reports the Irish Independent.

Recommended articles:

Amanda Knox ex Raffaele Sollecito stopped by police at Austrian border

Italian court finds Amanda Knox, Raffaele Sollecito guilty of murder again

Texas woman accused of faking rape, killing fiancee’s 2-year-old girl

Justin Bieber turns himself in to Toronto police amid a sea of fans

Teleka Patrick case: Frozen lake searched in quest to find missing doctor

Police release photo of woman sought for questioning in Kim Pham beating death

Second woman arrested for murder in beating death of Calif. woman Kim Pham

Family of missing Teleka Patrick: ‘We are past the point of desperation'

Teleka Patrick case: Prayer group organizing day of fasting for missing doctor

Teleka Patrick case: Missing doctor got letter from Marvin Sapp regarding church

Teleka Patrick case: News conference clarifies information about missing doctor

Avonte Oquendo case: DNA confirms remains found belong to missing boy

Teleka Patrick case: Authorities to release new info regarding missing doctor

Avonte Oquendo case: Report says skull found may belong to missing teen

Singer Marvin Sapp urged to hold fundraiser for missing doctor Teleka Patrick

Police: Md. Mom charged with killing 2 children while performing exorcism

Avonte Oquendo case: Lawyer says ‘not looking great’ for missing boy’s family

Heather Elvis case: SC Gov. Haley helping in search for missing woman