When a bill appears to have the support of the majority of citizens, yet fails to pass, it is important to know how our representative voted. It is important because those we elect into office have an obligation to vote the will of the citizens. It is the obligation of the citizen to hold those they elected accountable.
Regarding the bill that would have made it a crime to be in Arizona illegally, no Democrat voted for it. It was assumed that this bill would be supported by most Republicans however that was not the case. Three Republicans, Russ Jones of district 24, John McComish of district 20 and Andy Tobin of district 1, voted no.
According to the Gila Courier, six Republicans were not present at the vote. These were votes that could have possibly passed this bill. Those who were not present to vote on HB2280 were, Nancy Barto of district 7, Rich Crandall of district 19, Adam Driggs of district 11, Bill Konopnicki of district 5, Lucy Mason of district 1 and Doug Qwelland of district 10.
There was no explanation as to why they missed the vote. Is it possible that these representatives missed this vote for political reasons? Is it possible that they did not wish to be on record as being either too hard or too soft on illegal immigration? Is it possible that some, if not all, will soon be up for re-election? Whatever their reasons, they owe their constituents an explanation.
Contact your representative at: www.azleg.gov
Comments
Got the bill number wrong, it is HB2280. And you misunderstood the process too...this is a republic and elected representatives need not vote as if they were public opinion polls - they are to examine the full consequences of a proposed act. Missing a vote does not mean either a no or yes vote - you might be over in the Senate working on an issue or discussing the budget with the Governor. Lots of misunderstandings occur when intent is imposed on a action.
Ted, thanks for the correction, I appreciate it.
I agree that full consequences be examined by our representatives AND the voters. In a republic with elected officials, it is our responsibility as citizens to be informed about bills that are presented to the officials we elect. It is our responsibility to let those officials know, in the form of letters, emails, articles, etc. what our expectations are for them while in office. It is also our responsibility to vote them in or out if they do or don't represent our beliefs regarding important issues. We have the right to know and a responsibilty to the democratic process to know how they voted or why they didn't vote at all. Voting representatives into office isn't the end of our responsibilty. Holding them accountable for the job they are doing is.
Terry and Christina
Holding a Legislator accountable is very difficult due to redistricting. There are only 5 competitive districts out of the 30 in Arizona. This means that the 2+ party system is not working and extremist in each party take over the dialogue. It means that PRIMARIES define the legislature. Right now, this favors the Republicans, but shortly, given demographic changes, it will favor the Democrats. Flip all issues upside down and you will see the future of Arizona. To keep things balanced, we need to redistrict to assure competition - and not one Party domination as we have now. Look at the mess in budget to see what happens when one party takes over.
While it may be difficult, it's not impossible. I agree that there are problems with government being perhaps one-sided. All you have to do is look to the federal government to see that. You're right. Competion is key to ensure the best for all. It's a basic economic principle that certainly applies to politics as well. That's why we need to write letters, state opinions and remain informed and keep writing until someone hears. Redistricting is emotional, personal, and while never perfect, can be better. I don't live in Arizona, but the problems there are not unique. I refuse to walk away because something is difficult. Isn't that what makes this country great? The fact that it's hard to make changes only emphasises how important it is to reform. We, as citizens, still have the right to write letters and voice our positions. Only then, will we be able to make a difference. If we step back because it's too hard, everyone loses.
Well said Terry.
Got something to say?
Examiner.com is looking for writers, photographers, and videographers to join the fastest growing group of local insiders. If you are interested in growing your online rep apply to be an Examiner today!