We think you're near Los Angeles

Green Day: Best punk rock band of all time - Aw Dookie!

Asking its readers two weeks ago to select their favorite punk rock bands, Rolling Stone Magazine published the results today.

In a stunning turnaround the best punk rock band of all time was christened.... Green Day.  Taking the silver and bronze were The Clash and The Ramones, respectively.

The top ten list ranked as follows:

o1. Green Day

02.  The Clash

03.  The Ramones

04.  The Sex Pistols

05.  The Dead Kennedys

06. Iggy and the Stooges

07.  Black Flag

08.  The Misfits

09. Social Distortion

10. Bad Brains

Was this poll taken as people exited Hot Topic?

With all due respect to Green Day and their Gilman Street roots, the list touched off a nerve with those who disagreed and left comments saying as much, in addition to listing a bevy of artists who could have easily replaced them such as Minor Threat, The New York Dolls, The Cramps, Wire, Circle Jerks,  The Buzzcocks, Patti Smith, U.K. Subs, Husker Du, etc. The list goes on for about a mile.

Advertisement

Green Day being chosen as the best punk band is not like the earth stopped rotating around its axis, but it’s pretty darn close.

How did so many ill-informed have access to computers at exactly the same moment for precisely the same poll? It’s dookie for sure.

, SF Music News Examiner

Robyn Chelsea-Seifert is a journalist who has written on all genres of music for The Miami Herald, Creem, Hit Parader, The South Florida Sun-Sentinel and International Musician, and is a frequent contributor to several media outlets. Robyn also contributes to CBS Local, and can be read here.

Don't miss...