We think you're near Los Angeles

Currently in Los Angeles

Location: Los Angeles Current temperature: 65°F: Current condition: Clear See Extended Forecast

America Inspired

Your votes decided who shared $100,000

Go see 'A Christmas Carol' and think 'Yellow Submarine'

Steve Marinucci's photo
Beatles Examiner
 

     Jim Carrey as Ebenezer Scrooge in a scene from "A Christmas Carol."
     (AP Photo/Disney, ImageMovers Digital LLC)

When the whole idea of the "Yellow Submarine" remake hit the news, being Beatle traditionalists, we were skeptical about the idea.

Today, we caught Disney's new version of "A Christmas Carol" at a local theater. It's directed by Robert Zemeckis, who'll helm the new version of the Beatles movie for the Mouse House.

Our skepticism hasn't disappeared. However, seeing "A Christmas Carol" made for some interesting thoughts. If they do the new "Yellow Submarine" like they did "A Christmas Carol," the effects should be amazing, maybe beyond amazing. ImageMovers Digital, who did the animation in "A Christmas Carol," will also be working with Zemeckis for "Yellow Submarine." So Pepperland won't be cartoonish -- it will live on the screen and be as real as animation can get.

That's the kind of stuff you see in "A Christmas Carol." We're imagining the characters will jump out at you -- and we're not talking about the 3-D effects. The Beatles' animated characters will probably transcend what you see in "The Beatles: Rock Band." And the Blue Meanies will probably be more than "bluish" and a bit cute. They'll be as mean and nasty as they can be.   

As beautiful as the Yellow Submarine looks in "The Beatles: Rock Band," you can expect the new movie Yellow Sub to be a work of art. There will be a new dimension to the Sea of Time as it will probably add an element of 3-D time travel. The Sea of Holes won't be flat black circles. And the Sea of Monsters will be a scary place to visit.

If this sounds like a wholesale endorsement of the remake, it's not. Jim Carrey, for all his superb work in becoming Ebenezer Scrooge and the three ghosts, looks otherworldly as the old miser. His face couldn't be more craggy nor his body any thinner. We hope the Beatles don't look like that.

And we had the fortune (or misfortune) to see it first on a regular screen, then later on an IMAX when the projector broke down at the first showing. The characters all looked robotic with uneven eyes on the regular, though they looked a little more lifelike on the IMAX. And some kids who have loved the story in the original movie could find parts of the new new "Yellow Submarine" frightening if those same type of realistic effects in "Carol" are used for "Submarine."

Finally, do we really want the Beatles to look in the style of the characters from "Shrek" if Zemeckis lightens the story up? Or do you prefer "Polar Express" if he stays serious? Either one could what future audiences remember about living in a "Yellow Submarine."

So go and see "A Christmas Carol." It's great, honestly. And you'll get an unscheduled preview of a coming attraction besides the trailers you see on the screen.  

Recent stories: 

Advertisement

, Beatles Examiner

Steve Marinucci's website, Abbeyrd's Beatles Page - http://abbeyrd.best.vwh.net - is widely regarded as the most accurate Beatle news source on the internet. A former journalist for over 30 years at the San Jose Mercury News, he has interviewed celebrities including Yoko Ono, Bruce Johnston and...

Comments

  • Adam 2 years ago

    I think it will be fine, and cool to see. Hopefully this means Yellow Submarine[original] is sold again on DVD, it's hard to find. I'm sure it will be.

  • Mike V 2 years ago

    I originally thought a sequel could be better, and offer a new exciting sountrack especially if Paul and Ringo revisited unreleased John and George material.

    However your article brings up exciting possibilities.

    I would expect that Zemekis will make them more realistic than Rock Band, but with an animated flair over "realism" to keep it from getting too creepy.

    Zemekis could have some fun and throw in some original cartoon style sequences and to be real campy put in a sequence with the stiffer cartoon characters by Brodax albeit nbow in CGI.

  • Steve Marinucci - Beatles Examiner 2 years ago

    Mike V: Yeah, seeing what Zemeckis had done with "A Christmas Carol" brought up some interesting possibilities. There are many ways he can go with this, certainly.

  • Kevin Bradford 2 years ago

    It's Ok to be skeptical...some are just plain close-minded..Heaven forbid anyone tread on the fanatics vision of their Beatles.. My thoughts are ..any new product for a defunct band that broke up 40 years ago is just incredible on it's own..

Add a new comment

Join the conversation! Log in here or create a new account if you've never registered before.

More information about text formats

Got something to say?

Examiner.com is looking for writers, photographers, and videographers to join the fastest growing group of local insiders. If you are interested in growing your online rep apply to be an Examiner today!

Don't miss...