Skip to main content
  1. News
  2. Politics
  3. Political Buzz

Gingrich's race-based appeal finds a standing ovation in South Carolina

Newt Gingrich is calling it "The Moment", when the South Carolina audience at Monday night's Republican debate in Myrtle Beach, stood up to give Gingrich a standing ovation for declaring that he, following the will of what he called "the Creator", would "continue to find ways to help poor people learn how to get a job, learn how to get a better job, and learn someday to own the job."

The Moment came at the end of a confrontation between Gingrich and Fox News analyst Juan Williams, which has ignited debates on many fronts in the last couple of days, with one key issue being whether or not, and to what extent consciously, Gingrich was pandering to the racist attitudes of the seemingly all-white Republican audience.

Williams began by asking Gingrich if his comments about poor people and black people lacking a work ethic and how poor kids should be put to work as janitors were, as Williams put it, "insulting to all Americans, but particularly to black Americans?"

To be fair to the audience, when Williams asked this there was some tepid, scattered, applause.

But when Gingrich replied: "No. I don't see that", the room erupted into loud applause and cheers. Gingrich said his daughter had gone to work at the age of 13 as a janitor at a church and that "she liked earning the money", and that "she thought it was a good start."

Gingrich went on to argue that firing one unionized janitor, and replacing that adult with "30-some kids to work in the school" would be good because the children would be "getting money", which Gingrich said "is a good thing if you're poor."

Then Gingrich said "only the elites despise earning money." He did not say who he thought the "elites" were, or why they were particularly opposed to earning money.

One problem with Gingrich's assessment and solution, in addition to his repeatedly stated contempt for child labor laws and his enthusiasm for firing janitors, and other school personnel, is that in the example Gingrich gave of 30 children dividing up a janitor's salary, the children would be making less than $1/hour.

This is based on Gingrich's earlier statement that he was "talking about [children] working 20 hours a week." This would produce a great deal for school districts and governments trying to cut costs by eliminating union contracts, for example, but it would push labor conditions and decent treatment of the most vulnerable citizens of the USA back 100 years to a time of wholesale exploitation of children by ruthless employers.

Williams at this point reminded Gingrich about being asked a question by a black woman at a South Carolina church about why Gingrich calls Barack Obama "the food stamp president". Williams was being booed at this point quite a bit every time he asked Gingrich a followup. Gingrich was quite amused to find the crowd seemingly on his side.

Gingrich replied to Williams that it was a "fact…that more people have been put on food stamps by Barack Obama than any president in American history."

Gingrich has often been criticized for offering factoids instead of facts and this seems to be yet another of them.

As Factcheck.org pointed out, Gingrich was wrong in what he said. In fact, it was under George W. Bush that more Americans went on food stamps than at any other time. It is true that under Obama, almost as many Americans have gone on food stamps, but that is because the already steady growth in poverty experienced during the Bush years became a huge increase in the poor, and in food stamp recipients, as a result of the 2008 economic crisis and its lengthy aftermath.

Comments

Advertisement

News

  • Israel, Hamas clash in Gaza
    Hamas claims to have captured an IDF soldier on the bloodiest day of the conflict
    Video
    Video
  • Missing bodies
    38 bodies have not been found from the MH17 debris field in eastern Ukraine
    World News
  • Peeping Toms in NSA?
    Has the NSA seen you naked? Edward Snowden says it's not unlikely
    NSA
  • Autism study
    The newest, largest study on autism suggests that it mostly has to do with genetics
    Science
  • McIlroy takes Open
    Rory McIlroy hangs onto the lead and wins the 2014 British Open
    Sports
  • $23 billion payout
    A jury sides with the widow of a smoker, tobacco company shells out $23 billion
    Headlines