Skip to main content
  1. News
  2. Business & Finance
  3. Personal Finance

Getting to the bottom of phone fraud calls, stolen identity

See also

Does your person wear glasses? Is your person wearing a hat? Is your person a male or a female? These are the types of questions that are asked in a 1979 board game called Guess Who?

And the more correct guesses a person states, the more cards she flips down. Slowly one board game player figures out who you are.

That's about how phone fraud and credit card fraud companies work. All they need is the right guess to figure out how to get your information, and if you're a little too chatty and your guard is down, they'll win the game of Guess Who? every time.

After recently changing a cell phone number (and forgetting to automatically add the new number to to avoid solicitors and telemarketers), the phone number that showed up on my phone was (708) 000-0001.

Warning 1: When a company calls you from a number you cannot recognize outside of the area code, ask for their company name immediately. On a landline phone, the company's name will sometimes pop up. On cell phones, a random phone number is more common.

The company, which called itself "Member Services," told me I was eligible for a better credit card interest rate because my current credit card balance was over $6,000.

Warning 2: Guessing a credit card balance only takes a Google search. The average American, according to CNN, had approximately $15,950 in credit card debt in 2012. PBS' "Frontline" special: "Secret History of the Credit Card" made me cut up my cards a few years ago and get as far away from that statistic as possible. But with the current unnemployment rate and need for basic living, it's not unreasonable to believe that some people do indeed need credit cards.

I asked for the company associated with the card. They ran off a list of companies, including JP Morgan Chase and Target.

Warning 3: When a credit card company wants to speak with you, someone from that credit card company will contact you directly. Third-party representatives are not only unnecessary but unrealistic. It's more likely to see skinny Santa Claus than it is for a big-name company to send you no snail mail with their logos, e-mails from their secure website or in-person representatives to stop you as soon as you enter the buildings.

I asked for the website address of the company that I was speaking to. The website I got was

Warning 4: A company with an Illinois area code doesn't usually need to add "us" in their website. Don't be fooled by a company just because it has ".com" at the end. Anyone with money can start a website. But this company didn't even have a working fake website. I checked while he was still on the line and told him so.

Finally I asked him to tell me what my name is. When a financial expert can call you, know your account balance (or estimate) and know what companies you have financial ties to, it's not too much to ask for them to be able to identify you as well. He could not tell me my own name.

By this time, I'd already pulled up the Better Business Bureau (BBB) site and started my report about this number. I explained to the representative what I was doing and he hung up mid-sentence.

Warning 5: A legitimate company won't freak out when you mention BBB. Accredited businesses will usually have no problem with you going to BBB to search for their company. With the recent Target credit card hacking, BBB confirms that scam artists are taking advantage of naivete even more.

Subscribe to BBB's scam alerts for more information.

In the meantime, if you legitimately think there's a possibility that a company you work with is willing to give you a better deal, tell the incoming caller that you are busy at the moment and you will call back. Then immediately make an outgoing call to the phone number of the actual company (listed on the company's site or on the back of your credit card) and ask to speak with one of their representatives.

Follow Shamontiel on Pinterest for all her latest Chicago finance, employment and savings tips, or subscribe to her Chicago Personal Finance channel at the top of this page.



  • Ukraine
    Ukrainians have photo evidence that connect Russian soldiers to unrest in the country
    Watch Video
  • Drone strikes in Yemen
    An estimated 65 al-Qaeda militants were killed in drone strikes over the weekend
    World News
  • FBI investigates stowaway
    After a teen snuck into a plane's landing gear, the FBI will reevaluate airport security
  • American wins Boston Marathon
    Meb Keflezighi becomes the first American to win the Boston Marathon in decades
  • Search for MH370
    As the search for MH370 in the ocean goes dim, crews may shift the search area yet again
  • Ferry disaster claims over 100 lives
    The death toll for the South Korean ferry disaster rises above 100
    Watch Video

User login

Log in
Sign in with your email and password. Or reset your password.
Write for us
Interested in becoming an Examiner and sharing your experience and passion? We're always looking for quality writers. Find out more about and apply today!