Skip to main content
  1. Life
  2. Pets
  3. Dogs

Florida man accused of beating puppy will be assigned a new judge

See also

A Florida man who was found guilty of animal cruelty after he allegedly beat his Labrador retriever puppy, is being provided with a new judge to review the case because his defense attorneys have successfully argued that the prior judge was "too prejudiced" to fairly make a ruling, reported Friday's publication of the Bradenton Herald.

In May 2012, a jury of six found Noah Mitchell, 35, guilty of animal cruelty, a third degree felony, for an alleged beating which took place on October 3, 2010.

Mitchell was accused of beating his eight-month-old puppy "Bubba," after the pup stole a piece of steak. The puppy suffered six fractured ribs, two collapsed lungs and a damaged larynx and was "near death" at the time that he was discovered.

Mitchell maintains that he did not beat the puppy, but rather, dropped him after being bitten on the hand.

The judge who previously presided over the case told Mitchell that he did not believe his story.

Judge Luis Garcia stated:

"So, Mr. Mitchell's version of what occurred, as far as the court is concerned, is not credible.... Mr. Mitchell, you lost control ... and hurt that dog severely.... You basically refused to get help."

Mitchell's attorney, public defender Jerome Gilhooley, felt that Judge Garcia's statement amounted to prejudice and he was successful in obtaining a new judge to listen to the case.

Even though Mitchell was found guilty almost a year ago, he has not spent any time behind bars.

The dog was was so severely injured in the incident has since recovered and he has been adopted to a new guardian.

Prior story on this case here.

If you would like to continue receiving the latest animal related news, tips and advice, please click the "Subscribe" icon which is located near the top, left portion of this column. It is free and anonymous to sign up.

Follow the National Dog News Examiner on Facebook and Twitter!

I am human, if you see a typo, please let me know. Questions, comments or story ideas can be emailed to Please note - due to the heavy volume of emails received, I am unable to respond to each and every request, but they are all appreciated!



  • Dead babies found
    Seven dead babies were found in Utah resident Megan Huntsman's old home
    Shocking Discovery
  • Kendall Jenner
    Get the Coachella looks: Kendall Jenner’s nose ring, green hair and edgy nails
    Coachella Look
  • Dog's Easter basket
    How to fill your dog’s Easter basket with the perfect toys
    Easter Basket
  • Rabbit owners
    Bringing home the bunny: Important information for rabbit owners
    7 Photos
  • Haunted island
    The world’s most haunted island may soon be the most haunted luxury resort
    Haunted Resort
  • Sunken ferry
    Search continues for missing passengers after a ferry sinks off the South Korean coast
    Sunken Ferry

User login

Log in
Sign in with your email and password. Or reset your password.
Write for us
Interested in becoming an Examiner and sharing your experience and passion? We're always looking for quality writers. Find out more about and apply today!