America swooned over Colin Powell during and after the Gulf War. Despite his uncomfortable first name, Powell struck a dignified stance as Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. He was the ultimate soldier and he could have been president. Powell's stint as Secretary of State under George W. Bush proved to become his political undoing. The question is, was he a noble scapegoat or a cowardly stooge?
Powell was the first cabinet member chosen by Bush. It was a transparent effort to provide the chimera of moderation to the administration. The team of Bush, Cheney, and Rumsfeld were going to be running the show and that set up an untenable role for the Secretary of State. Powell did succeed at installing his lifelong buddy Richard Armitage as Rumsfeld's deputy. Armitage shared Powell's philosophies, which caused a lot of trouble at the Pentagon. Rumsfeld and Armitage did not have a collegial relationship.
An instinctual impatience was the modus operandi of the Bush Administration. Powell took the opposite approach. As a general, Powell earned the nickname "The Reluctant Warrior." Armed conflict was always to be the last resort, after all diplomatic attempts have failed. In addition, if war became inevitable, victory must be uncomplicated. Overwhelming force was the key component of acheiving the desired goal.
Diplomatic efforts by Colin Powell as Secretary of State yielded very few successes. Missions regarding Iraq, North Korea, and Israel often showed how at odds Powell was with the rest of Bush's team. If the U.S. did not seem to take it's own top diplomat seriously, why would another country? More than once, Powell would make a seemingly honest public statement, only to be reprimanded immediately. For someone as conscious about his public image as Powell, these were humiliating events. 
The climactic act of Powell's tragedy was when he presented to the U.N the case for an invasion of Iraq. Before the trusted Powell made his argument, American public opinion was on the fence. Overnight, Powell won the support of citizens, who had concluded this action was needed for self-defense.
It turned out that Colin Powell spewed a litany of, if not outright lies, than at least conscious untruths. There were no WMD's, at least not in Iraq, and the claim of Saddam's attempt to obtain yellowcake from Africa was a forgery. Do we feel sorry for this formerly sanctified statesman, or be disgusted at his playing the role of good soldier to a fault?
Powell was extraordinarily skeptical of the Iraq invasion. He thought he had made his case to the president. When it became clear that he did not, he should have left his post. Ever the loyal soldier, Powell was compelled to serve his president and country. In the end, Powell was fired.
Rumsfeld and Cheney continue to quarrel with Powell as both sides jockey for the right to define history. Powell donated the maximum amount to John McCain in 2008, but ultimately publicly threw his support to Obama. Despite a well-earned distate for the political theater, it would not be a surprise to see Powell emerge as an elder statesmen for the Democratic Party.
Coming up next: Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld
If you enjoyed this article, check out: http://www.examiner.com/examiner/x-11800-Bush-Legacy-Examiner~y2009m6d25-Dick-Cheney-was-brutal-and-effective
Comments
Because of Powell's incompetence, the 4th Infantry Division’s (ID) invasion of Iraq, from the North, never occurred. In the lead up to war with Iraq, Powell, (then) Secretary of State negotiated with Ankara’s parliament for permission to use Turkish territory to launch 62,000 US troops against Iraq – he failed. It wasn’t until almost a month later that the 4th ID finally joined the war effort after having been re-routed through Kuwait, arriving too late to be part of the initial attack.
It is now understood that many troops loyal to Saddam abandoned their posts and uniforms and took up as insurgents when the Coalition forces reached the outskirts of Baghdad. Had there been a simultaneous push down from the North, as originally planned, it is altogether possible that many of those who have perpetrated terror for so many years would have been captured or killed at that time.
It can be said with a fair amount of certainty that, had Collin Powell succeeded diplomatically with the Tu
It can be said with a fair amount of certainty that, had Collin Powell succeeded diplomatically with the Turks, a lot of Americans and Iraqis would be alive today and the responsibility for most of the death and destruction in post-Saddam Iraq, rests squarely on the shrugged but haughty shoulders of Collin Powell - Screw him.
Got something to say?
Examiner.com is looking for writers, photographers, and videographers to join the fastest growing group of local insiders. If you are interested in growing your online rep apply to be an Examiner today!