Skip to main content
  1. Life
  2. Religion & Spirituality
  3. Western Religions

Christian baker ordered to violate his faith, endorse gays or face jail, fines

See also

An on-going battle has been brewing in Colorado between a gay couple and a Christian baker since 2012. The baker, Jack Phillips, owner of Masterpiece Cakes had a complaint filed against him by two gays after he refused to provide a cake for their same-sex "wedding."

A ruling handed down Friday by the Colorado state agency board which demands that Phillips violate his faith and create a cake for the gay couple or face jail time and fines. Phillips declined to bake the cake for the homosexuals citing his Christian beliefs.

Phillips believes what the bible says about marriage being between one man and one woman. "The Colorado Civil Rights Division is telling the Lakewood, Colorado, baker must violate his faith and create “wedding” cakes for same-sex duos," according to the WND report.

The ironic thing is that same-sex marriages aren't recognized by the state Constitution of Colorado, and the marriage wasn't even going to be held in Colorado but rather in Mass. The Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) which represented Phillips explained the legal filing handed down by the judge by saying:

The government … seek[s] to impose a new belief system upon Jack [Phillips], one that is fundamentally at odds with his conscience and his liberty.

Phillips told the gays what they wanted violated his Christian beliefs. He declined to produce a message on the wedding cake which conflicted with his faith. However, he did offer to provide other products for the gays but that wasn't good enough for them, so they filed a complaint against him.

Furthermore, according to the report, "Administrative Law Judge Robert Spencer, had earlier ordered Phillips, on pain of fines or even jail time, to violate his faith and provide the wedding cake to homosexuals Charlie Craig and David Mullins."

As expected the ADF filed an appeal of the “erroneous” ruling, with a petition for review to the commission. However, the commission on Friday decided to uphold the judge's opinion and rejected the ADF's contentions that Judge Spencer, "under the state’s court rules of procedure, should have dismissed the complaint."

According to the notice that ADF filed in the petition said Phillips "did not discriminate ‘because of’ sexual orientation” but acted “in accordance with the provisions of the Colorado Constitution, state law and the public policy of the state.”

The ADF further stated that "Phillips’ “conduct and expressions in declining to design and create a wedding cake are protected by the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment of the United States Constitution and by Article II, Section 10 of the Colorado Constitution."

The lawyers who argued the case said that Phillips and his company has the right to "actual and symbolic speech." This should mean that Phillips "cannot be forced" to endorse or convey a message that he is for something that he disagrees with, in this case same-sex marriage.

The ADF believes that Spencer's ruling is wrong and they also contended “the ALCU’s recommendation that respondents ‘[c]ease and desist from discriminating against complainants and other same-sex couples by refusing to sell them wedding cakes or any other product respondents would provide to heterosexual couples’ is overbroad and exceeds the scope of relief authorized [under state law].”

"America was founded on the fundamental freedom of all citizens to live and work without fear of government punishment,” said Nicole Martin, lead counsel in the case.

However, the arrogance of the seven commissioners was on display as they refused to listen to the ADF's arguments on Friday. Instead they insisted that Phillips must submit "quarterly reports detailing what he’s doing to prevent such actions, such as store employee training, and a tally of whether any customers were turned away."

The ACLU contends that, "the treatment the homosexuals" supersedes Phillips' Amendment religious freedom protections." In the ruling suggested that "Phillips’ constitutional rights are secondary, because otherwise the “cost to society” isn’t considered. He granted homosexuals a special standard."

Spencer also bluntly put it this way, in order for Phillips to not make cakes for same-sex marriages he should close his shop.

Christianity Commentary

This is what's happening in our nation when Christians publicly differ on what's immoral is that they are often ridiculed and persecuted for our biblical beliefs. Most feel that what the bible says about same-sex marriage is open to the analysis of mankind. To violate what God says about same-sex marriage is a rejection of his word plain and simple.

What we are really dealing with here is that society chooses to reject the parts of God's word they don't agree with. When the foundation God's word is questioned, it becomes much easier to progress to the next level of immorality. What has become so troubling with rejecting what God says about certain things in his word is that all shame is lost.

As acceptance and support of same-sex marriage rises in the US, it shows that the biblical beliefs of society doesn't tolerate the views of Christians.

If you enjoyed this article please consider subscribing to receive an email notification when new articles are posted. Just click the blue subscribe link near the photo that accompanies this article. You can follow Joseph on Twitter @cybervoyager62.

For hard-hitting conservative commentary, please visit Joseph’s author page at the Conservative Firing Line. If you would like to read more Christianity Examiner articles click here. You can also find Joseph’s Marine Corps Examiner articles by clicking here.

You can also connect with Joseph on Facebook, at Spokane Conservative Examiner, The Independent Examiner and The Red Shirt Regiment, a page mostly dedicated to our troops.

To read inspirational works and view photos by Joseph please visit Joseph L. Parker Freelance Writer and Nature Photographer. You can also watch inspirational videos on Joseph's Youtube channel.

Advertisement