The ad, featuring the famed Anheuser-Busch Clydesdales, beat out Tide's "Miracle Stain" commercial by a nose with a quality score of 7.76.
More than 7,000 panelists voted on the Ad Meter panel, which for the first time was open for anyone to register.
Among the other top favorites, the Dodge RAM commercial about farmers and featuring the voice of Paul Harvey, the Doritos "Fashionista Dad" user-submitted spot, and Jeep's commercial about solders returning home narrated by Oprah.
The worst: GoDaddy's 30-second make out session between model Bar Refaeli and a tech nerd.
To see all the ads, check out YouTube's Ad Blitz.