Skip to main content

See also:

Books and movies Part 1

Movies based on books are commonplace--they are also a common source of complaints: "The movie ruined the book!" The movie left out so much! The movie changed everything!"

Benedict Cumberbatch, Jonny Lee Miller, even Robert Downey, Jr.--all respectable Holmeses. The definitive Holmes, however, remains Jeremy Brett. His 1988 version of The Hound of the Baskervilles is a reliable rendering of the original text.
cover from Wikipedia

It is impossible for every book-inspired movie to satisfy every book-lover, but some book-inspired movies do a better job than others at respecting their origins. Many of the books in this slideshow have multiple movie versions, ranging from faithful renderings to "Why did they bother?" mishmashes. The slideshow captions list the more faithful renderings.