Skip to main content
  1. Arts & Entertainment
  2. Books

Book Review: "Mrs. Lincoln's Rival" by Jennifer Chiaverini

See also

Mary Todd Lincoln may have been the First Lady, but she was not the toast of the town. That honor went to Kate Chase Sprague, the daughter of the ambitious and proud Salmon P. Chase, President Abraham Lincoln's Secretary of the Treasury. Kate was known as "The Belle of Washington" and Washington D.C. society looked to her as their reigning queen. This caused a rift between the First Lady and the Belle of Washington. In "Mrs. Lincoln's Rival" by Jennifer Chiaverini, readers meet the woman that was a thorn in the side of Mary Todd Lincoln and was Washington D.C'.s darling.

"Mrs. Lincoln's Rival" is a novel about the life of Kate Chase Sprague. The novel follows her blossoming years in Ohio as the devoted daughter to her three-times widowed father and wonderful older sister to her beloved sister Nettie. Kate served as her father's companion, the one who planned the events and get-togethers, and the one always there for him. Kate had high hopes for her father to become President of the United, but a charming, intelligent, and kind "nobody" from Illinois named Abraham Lincoln stole that dream from Kate. President Lincoln appoints Kate's intelligent and hard-working father as Secretary of the Treasury and the family moves to Washington D.C. where Kate meets two people that will play major roles in her life. Kate meets the aloof, odd, but larger-than-life Mary Todd Lincoln, the new First Lady and there is automatic dislike. Mary Todd Lincoln is not readily accepted by Washington society, but Kate is loved by them. This causes friction between the two women. The other person Kate meets is the handsome and wealthy young governor of Rhode Island, William Sprague. Kate eventually marries William and their marriage is passionate, but ends up breaking Kate's heart and almost, her spirit. The novel follows the years of Kate Chase Sprague during the presidency of Abraham Lincoln and what her role was during this time period. The novel is a tribute to a woman who never was the First Lady, but beloved by Washington D.C.

"Mrs. Lincoln's Rival" is a disappointment. The novel hardly focuses on the rivalry or dislike between Kate Chase Sprage and Mary Todd Lincoln. There are a few instances here and there throughout the novel, but it hardly shows the difficult relationship the two different yet similar women had. The novel instead is more of a portrayal of Kate's life.

The novel also suffers from a lack of energy or flow. It reads almost more like a history book or recap of the events of the time period. There is no passion, personality, or voice to this novel. Kate hardly has a voice and the secondary characters serve as nothing more than people who somehow played a role in Kate's life rather than being defining characters on their own.

Chiaverini does give a factual account of Kate's life and the time period. She expertly describes the events of the presidency of President Lincoln and the Civil War. It's more a historical account than a historical fiction novel.

Still, if you are a fan of this time period and want to know more about the people surrounding Abraham Lincoln's presidency, this is a solid novel. You will get history, facts, and learn some new things while reading this novel.

To purchase "Mrs. Lincoln's Rival":

For more information on Jennifer Chiaverini:


Arts & Entertainment

  • Cuba Gooding Jr.
    After 20 years of wedded bliss, Cuba Gooding Jr. will be heading to divorce court
    Celebrity Buzz
  • Blake Shelton
    Find out who will be performing at the first iHeartRadio Music Awards
    Music Buzz
  • Jimmy Fallon and Brian Williams
    Jimmy Fallon has struck viral gold with these hilarious video clips
    Pop Culture
  • Kristen Wiig
    Exclusive: Kristen Wiig talks 'Secret Life of Walter Mitty,' new on Blu-ray, DVD
    Celebrity Q&A
  • Eminem
    Jam-packed Austin City Limits Music Fest lineup announced
    Festival News
  • Stephen Colbert
    David Letterman and Stephen Colbert talk about 'The Late Show' and much more
    TV Buzz

User login

Log in
Sign in with your email and password. Or reset your password.
Write for us
Interested in becoming an Examiner and sharing your experience and passion? We're always looking for quality writers. Find out more about and apply today!