Skip to main content
Report this ad

A Moment with Kabbalah

Ward off that evil eye, Madonna!
Ward off that evil eye, Madonna!
Photo: Associated Press

Google ads have me all wrong. Sometimes they pick up on keywords accurately and make a guess about me: "Are you 26?! Do you like to eat?!" Why yes! Yes, I am! And yes, I do! But other times, it draws terrible conclusions: "Are you looking for Jesus?" Mm, no. Not really. But sometimes these bad guesses turn out in my favor. Such was the case a week ago, when an ad offered me 29 minutes of wisdom from the "ancient" religion of Kabbalah. Quickly, I registered and convinced a friend to join me. And within a few days, we were sitting in a large room, filled with elaborate chandeliers and women dripping with jewelry, learning about Kabbalah.

The Kabbalah Center of Los Angeles must have these events frequently. They are deceptively titled "29 minutes," though the keynote presentation lasted a good 45, and was followed by indefinite conversation with a volunteer at each  of the tables. The talk itself was vague and uninspired, drawing on old oratory tricks like asking us to leave behind our skepticism, to "open our minds" to what the speaker had to say. She expertly walked the line between vaguery and cockiness, telling us stories like the one about the student who insisted he didn't need Kabbalah-- that he was "in control." "So I said to him, 'Okay. Fine! You're in control? Take off your glasses!" A rumble of giggles came from the believers in the crowd. I wondered how many of them had thrown out their contacts since paying the $270 for the introductory Kabbalah class.

The speaker claimed that Kabbalah was completely based in scientific discourse, yet glossed over key points to the contrary, such as a belief in astrology (which does not stand up to even basic scrutiny).

When the speaker had finished congratulating herself on all her knowledge and gotten off the stage, the volunteer at my table, a beautiful woman with a clean yellow sweater and silver jewelry (I hate how dark skined women can wear yellow; it's so unfair), turned to me and my friend (a fellow skeptic named Ross), when the talk was over and asked us if we had any questions. Perhaps she mostly hears "Where can I sign up?!" because she was ill-prepared for our questioning, but had the ovaries to answer each question with a confident one-to-three word sentence.

"So... you said the beliefs of Kabbalah have been proven in the last twenty years.  Is there a study showing the existence of a soul?"

"Oh, I'm sure there is. There's a book where... he goes into... all that."


"If all the revelations of Kabbalah can be independently verified by science, wouldn't you not need Kabbalah anyway, since you could come to those conclusions naturally anyway?"

"No, you need revelation."


"It's hard to believe the universe exists for us when everything existed for billions  of years before us. So do you believe all the universe is here for us?"

"Yes. I would say so."


"Now, I heard that the red bracelet is to ward off the evil eye. Is that right?"

"Yes, for protection."

"And is there a study showing that?"

"Yes. There's a book, The Red String, where he talks about all that."


"Do you think it's possible to live a fulfilling life without Kabbalah?"



"So you said the book of Formation was written by Abraham 5,000 years ago, but there was no written Hebrew word til about 900 BC. So wouldn't it just be oral tradition at that point?"

"No, he wrote it."

Oh. Well then.

But what about all the  creative visionaries of history? Einstein, Newton?

"Well, many of them secretly were Kabbalist."


I learned many other pieces of history heretofore unknown, such as that the Big Bang occurred because souls already existed in the universe (the universe?) and "had desire to be creators of our own destiny." And boom! The Big Bang. Because of desire. Oh.

What's perhaps most extraordinary about these claims (and boy, are they extraordinary claims!) is that they are successful. Without any reference to reality or support to back them up, these claims draw in a crowd to the tune of almost $300 a pop. In fact, when the speaker announced the cost of the introductory class, two girls at my table gave each other a look that said "Not bad!" I, on the other hand, would rather have 100 bottles of soy mayonnaise.

And before you say "wait a minute, this was just one volunteer's opinion," consider this: this organization claims to have  THE SECRETS OF THE UNIVERSE, and to offer them to their adherents. If I can't trust their followers, who can I trust?

 After our two hours at the Kabbalah Center of Los Angeles, Ross and I quietly made our way out before erupting into laughter.  A few days later, they called Ross and offered him a free session of the introductory course. They never called me.

It's just as well.


  • Thomas 5 years ago

    lol the best part is "(the universe?)". Yeah the big bang took place INSIDE the universe... Idiots. Nice article.

  • RoomMate 5 years ago

    Why don't I live in LA? I would have gone to that with you :)

  • SG 5 years ago

    I especially like the assertion that we had the Hebrew written word 4,000 years earlier than anyone thought.

  • Ross 5 years ago

    Great report of our "investigation", Carrie! When the guy called me on my cell phone to ask what I thought about our introductory session, I said, "I consider myself to be a rational person, and I'll be honest with you - it was a bunch of nonsense." He was completely unphased, and asked me why I felt that way. I mentioned that both the speaker and our "mentor" stressed that Kabbalah is consistent with science, and yet in the next breath were championing unscientific ideas like astrology and the evil eye. That, and numerous factual and historical claims that were simply false. His response was to ask me if I'd like to attend the first free course. I said maybe, but to send emails and not phone calls. I also had to remove myself from their automated text messages. Yikes.

  • greg bart 5 years ago

    Very nice job, but your little venture cries out for pictures.

  • Avistrange 5 years ago

    This is awesome, Carrie! What kills me about the relatively recent commercialization of Kabbalah is that it goes against the traditions from which Kabbalah itself stems. Historically, the tradition of Orthodox Judaism has limited who is allowed to study the teachings of the "secret keys to the Torah and subsequently to the universe" to male Jews who are 40 years old and older and who have a family. Yet, in Beverly Hills, it's available to anyone with some cash.

    While the Torah itself, wich I was forced to read growing up, is full of stories about war, bloodshed, tests of faith, sexism, justified shame and what could be considered no less than magic, it supposedly contains secrets to the origins of the universe. I guess one has to read between the lines to find all of these "secrets". Lol.

  • Anonymous 3 years ago

    "Oh No, Ross and Carrie!" said the Kabbalists when you two showed up.

Report this ad