Many living on edge of homelessness
More than a hundred people gathered in the Mission district on Sunday to give and hear testimony about the plight of families in The City that are not living on the streets, but might be on the brink of homelessness.
(Jason Steinberg/Special to The Examiner)
More than a hundred people gathered in the Mission district on Sunday to give and hear testimony about the plight of families in The City that are not living on the streets, but might be on the brink of homelessness.

SAN FRANCISCO (Map, News) - Jose Alfredo and Olga Contreras live in a backyard garage in the Mission district with their two young children. The couple’s teenage daughter sleeps on a bed, the 6-year-old on a couch. The garage is humid, the paint is chipping, the carpets are torn up. Alfredo says the children have asthma.

“I work and work and work,” Alfredo said. “It is never enough to afford a place for my family with dignity.”

According to a group of community leaders in the Mission district, Alfredo’s family falls into a category they call the invisible homeless. They are people who are not living in the streets, but may be on the brink, and have a difficult time navigating The City’s complex affordable-housing process because they are illegal immigrants or do not speak English. Many of the families share one-room trailers, garages and studios with multiple people.

On Sunday, the San Francisco Organizing Project, a faith-based advocacy group, held a community meeting in the Mission district about the invisible homeless, and more than 100 people attended to share stories about living on the edge of homelessness.

“I’m afraid I may end up living in an abandoned car or garage,” said Maria Guadalupe Garcia, who lives in a trailer in the Mission district after fleeing an abusive relationship in Mexico six months ago. “I want to keep working. I always want to have a smile on my face. I can’t meet those goals.” Garcia said she earns $650 a month from cleaning jobs, but her monthly rent is $600.

Since Jan. 2004, The City has created more than 2,500 new affordable housing units, according to Matt Franklin, director of the Mayor’s Office of Housing, who attended Sunday’s forum. There are 3,000 more units in the development pipeline, he said.

“This is a very robust program, but it is not enough,” he added.

Franklin said there are 225 beds in shelters that are reserved for families, and they are full each night. There are also 80 families on a waiting list for the shelters, he added.

Community members on Sunday asked for an easier, streamlined application process for affordable-housing units. They want materials in both Spanish and English and do not want immigration status to be a factor in the process. They also pushed for lottery exemptions.

“We recognize and accept the concept of the invisible homeless,” Franklin said. “But until we have enough units to meet the need, I can’t imagine eliminating the lottery.”

arocha@examiner.com


Name
Comments

characters left


Comments from Examiner Readers

11:35 AM MST on Thu., Oct. 11, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner Reader said:
Our prisons and jails provide Housing, Health Care, Gangs and three square meals a day for 17% of Illegal Aliens. America what a wonderful nation.

110 agree | 102 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree

10:27 AM MST on Thu., Oct. 11, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

HA HA HA said:
In LA you can now legally sleep on the sidewalks in any part of town between 11:00PM and 6:00AM.

106 agree | 101 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
9:05 AM MST on Thu., Oct. 11, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner Reader said:
Brilliant thinking... Let's make SF a sanctuary city, and provide ID cards for illegals. When they move here in droves, we can whine and cry about how unfortunate it is that they can't afford places to live, so then we punish the legal residents and raise their taxes to support subsidizied housing for them. Repeat process when more respond to the incentive we have provided...

106 agree | 98 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
8:07 PM MST on Tue., Oct. 9, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

speedstan said:
Note the emphasis on providing subsidizied housing to people of questionable immigration status, as well as Boxer's recent proposal in the US Senate to suspend enforcement of immigration laws during the 2010 census. It's not about "compassion" whatsoever. It's about establishing RESIDENCY STATUS for ILLEGAL ALIENS in order to inflate the census figures and get more ELECTORAL VOTES for liberal, Democratic population centers. Don't say you have not been warned...

110 agree | 107 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
6:14 PM MST on Tue., Oct. 9, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

response to "Heartbroken in SF" said:
Maybe you should think less with your heart and more with your brain... it's not "love" or "compassion" when you punish law-abiding taxpaying citizens by confiscating their hard-earned money to provide subsidies for people who aren't even originally from SF, have never bothered to learn English, and in all likelihood are not even in this country LEGALLY. As for having their land "stolen": given that at least one of these persons is from Mexico, who exactly stole their land again? If you're going to repeat a bunch of La Raza crap that somehow Mexicans had their land stolen by Americans, then you better learn something about history. Try reading the treaty of Guadelope-Hidalgo as well as the Mexican Constitution of 1917 before you blather about things you know NOTHING about!

107 agree | 108 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
5:31 PM MST on Tue., Oct. 9, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner Reader said:
So these people are complaining that they can not afford to live in a high-cost area, but who forced them to move here? Sounds like they made a bad choice, and need to move somewhere they can afford.

120 agree | 93 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
3:41 PM MST on Tue., Oct. 9, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

sickofrisco said:
"what a lot of americans don't seem to know or get is that a lot of illegals do pay taxes. I have worked in big retail and hospitality chains that hire illegals and take their false social security numbers." - Their tax payments are MINISCULE and do NOT cover the money spend on various social programs for them. In addition, the use of someone else's SSN is a CRIME. These people are ILLEGALS and CRIMINALS; we don't need to be providing them incentives to come where they don't belong in the first place.

91 agree | 89 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
2:21 PM MST on Tue., Oct. 9, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner Reader said:
Yes, we have to be softhearted and open. When legal residents don’t have medical coverage and schools are the worst in nation, you start to be more careful of giving away. We can not support illegal immigrants that aiming to send more money home and expect us to cover their rent. We spend tremendous funds on medical coverage, education, and legal system on illegal immigrants. I would better apply billions of dollars toward infrastructure that will benefit all of us, not people that enter this country by breaking the law.

102 agree | 97 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
12:24 PM MST on Tue., Oct. 9, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner Reader said:
I'm with heartbroken on this one. Let's balance some compassion against the needs of a major city. Cities function well because they are home to a variety of people, with a variety of skills, to meet the various needs of an urban area. From a number of these postings, it appears San Francisco is only to be populated by well-resourced individuals. Not only does this strike me as homogenously boring, I doubt many of these people intend to accept employment below their station in life. The problem is, eventually the trash must be taken out and toilets cleaned.

101 agree | 85 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
12:03 PM MST on Tue., Oct. 9, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

heartbroken in SF said:
seriously, where is the love? what has happened to us? i am heartbroken and shocked to read so may of these comments utterly lacking in any compassion whatsoever. i'm always amazed at the audacity of people who say that immigrants, illegal or otherwise, are somehow undeserving of the human rights of food and shelter. need i remind you all that this land was STOLEN from it's indigenous peoples. we who have benefitted from theft and genocide have no god-given dibs on the prosperity of this nation. besides do you think this nation would be so prosperous were it not for the folks who risk their lives to come here and work so very hard for meager pay just to try to provide their children with a better life then they've had to endure? the prosperity of this country has been built on the backs of free labor (slavery) and cheap labor (immigrants and the poor). to all you folks who only care about how much you're paying in taxes, and nothing for the suffering of others, i say have a he

106 agree | 103 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
11:54 AM MST on Tue., Oct. 9, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Nicolas said:
what a lot of americans don't seem to know or get is that a lot of illegals do pay taxes. I have worked in big retail and hospitality chains that hire illegals and take their false social security numbers. as long as they have something on file they seem to be covered. i know they are still risking serious fines but they still do it. plenty of people have told me they just make up their numbers. where does THAT money go? also - a known illegal rarely gets paid minimum wage in this town, i havewell off friends in this town who pay almost nothing to their undocumented housekeepers. this country and it's citizens exploit illegals as much as they exploit us.

98 agree | 85 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
9:12 AM MST on Tue., Oct. 9, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

james said:
"Community members on Sunday asked for an easier, streamlined application process for affordable-housing units. They want materials in both Spanish and English and do not want immigration status to be a factor in the process." - Translation: yet another attempt to use sob stories to facilitate breaking the law, and provide taxpayers money to illegal aliens. When are we going to say enough is enough?

112 agree | 96 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
7:57 AM MST on Tue., Oct. 9, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner Reader said:
Jason Grant Garza here .. what a great society. I am fully disabled living on my Social Security. I have only asked for housing help for ten years and have the records to prove it. When I called the agency they told me that their priority was housing the homeless. To hell with the fact that after rent I have nothing left. Now, I hear that the government is planning some sort of help/bail out for subprime homebuyers. So because I didn't "play the game", overstate my earnings, etc I didn't get a home loan. Now my good planning, clear thinking, and responsible acts will NOT be rewarded? Maybe I should become homeless or NOT responsible (take a home loan I can not pay) for all I know is that my responsible actions have resulted in NO HELP. When the game is rigged .. we are all losers. Don't believe me that all is crazy .. type my name into a google search engine and read how the city (SF) denied me emergency services and I now have a settlement agreement acknowledging guilt but no REME

99 agree | 109 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
12:06 AM MST on Tue., Oct. 9, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Taylor said:
Where do these so-called "community members" get off insisting that we provide special favors to people who not only refuse to learn English, but most likely are illegal aliens? We're just supposed to open the doors to anyone to come here, regardless of whether they have any compensatory job skills, speak the language, or are even in the country legally? And we blame the tax-payers for not wanting to subsidize this madness?

115 agree | 115 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
11:57 PM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

ford said:
the landlords are the biggest scammers. they don't have any pity on the immigrant population. rent is just collection money to them and the more they fleech the poor population, it doesn't matter as long their bellies are fatten.

110 agree | 104 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
11:31 PM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner Reader said:
I hope that your taxes go up so that more illegal aliens can come here and get free education, free health care and free food stamps. Viva La Raza!

107 agree | 121 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
8:57 PM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner Reader said:
SF is a sanctuary city because it's an event/tourist/service city catering to European, Asian and American clientele. This requires a large disposable work force... erecting tents, fences, and all support. Subcontractors of all kinds need a large disposable work force. Supply and demand. SF is no longer a union town. Where are they all going to live? Don't bother with the details.

92 agree | 107 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
8:53 PM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

frederick said:
I have my own small business (legal, licensed) and am struggling to get by, so I have moved out of my apartment and into my office until the cash flow gets better. I would never think of whining and crying about my current "invisible homelessness" as if it entitles me to some type of special favors of consideration. I live with it...

132 agree | 105 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
6:20 PM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Apres said:
Local law enforcement should check on immigration status during routine investigations. If a person is stopped and questioned and does not have command of conversational English and has a heavy accent, there is a good chance that person was not born or schooled in the United States! That should be the 1st clues to ask further questions about immigration status. Police should not conduct mass investigations; I refer only to routine stops with probable cause and investigations in the course of the performance of their duties! They should then ask for the persons appropriate documentation. After all, if a citizen is asked for identification, the police can detain you pending verification of who you are.

111 agree | 96 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
6:19 PM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Apres said:
I bet Jose Alfredo and Olga Contreras, the family profiled who live in a garage that does not meet code does not carry their resident alien card and doesn't report their current address to ICE! The Permanent Resident Card, Form I-551, is issued to all Permanent Residents as evidence of alien registration and their permanent status in the US. The card must be in your possession at all times. This requirement means that you are not only required to have a currently valid Form I-551 at all times, but also that you must carry your currently valid Form I-551 on your person at all times. The Permanent Resident Card currently is issued with a 10-year validity. You are required to notify us of any change of address within 10 days of that change. Form AR-11 is used for that purpose. Sooo... are they illegal immigrants.

117 agree | 107 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
5:27 PM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

a reader... said:
Note how the activists are calling these people "invisible homeless", in order to puff up the homeless statistics and solicit support for whatever new social program that the taxpayers will have to pay for...

105 agree | 124 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
5:24 PM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

sickofrisco said:
So the same city that rolls out the welcome mat to bums and illegals is wondering why we have so many impoverished people here? Get a clue...

111 agree | 112 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
4:25 PM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner critic said:
You know, I would rather live in Beverly Hills than the Mission. Can any of these agencies place me in a nice 5 bedroom house there, close to private schools and shopping with room for my extended family of 25 people? I am an illegal alien, and I make 9.00 an hour. But my expenses are low since I get everything I need to live a nice, healthy life from the lib symps in California. Can you get back to me with a move date?

102 agree | 119 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
4:03 PM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner Reader said:
San Francisco is a great place to live, but if you don't have any specialized job skills and the rent levels are forcing you to live at the poverty line, perhaps it isn't the city for you. I feel for people who have to choose between rent and food, but sometimes we put ourselves in these situations by making unrealistic choices. Is San Francisco a really nice place to live? Of course. Is there somewhere more affordable for people trying to get back on their feet? Absolutely.

99 agree | 99 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
3:24 PM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner Reader said:
They don't talk about how much money is sent back home to Mexico.... for their own family and then the public in America supports those who are sending money home.. what a mess..

142 agree | 123 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
2:21 PM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Apres said:
Whether the people profiled are legal or illegal immigrants, the Examiner parsed that fact. Instead of complaining, the daughter should teach the parents English and the two adults should be working two full time in a sanctuary city with a minimum wage of $9.14. That translates out to $5,922 a month or $71,000 a yr. The Examiner should enlighten us to important facts so we can provide important information and refer them to Ms. Latimore, Dept. of Social Services who provides literature and talks on SF services (Working to Survive). She earns $17 an Hr. (33,000 with benefits) based upon a previous profile. She is responsible for her 23 yr. old daughter who is in college and the daughter has a 7 yr old son. Why is the daughter not paying her way and not receiving court ordered child support? I bet the family profile does not carry their resident alien card and doesn't report their current address to ICE!

124 agree | 105 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
2:04 PM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner Reader said:
They came illegally don’t speak English and want us to pay for their services. Mexico is not providing affordable housing and we have our own citizens that require our attention. America was a safety net for the people prosecuted for their political or religious believes by the government and not drunken husband. They can not afford let them leave back where they came from.

125 agree | 119 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
1:55 PM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner Reader said:
This morning Yahoo's website reports that nicer flats in NYC are renting for 3100.00 and 80% of the city's residents are renters. Nicer flats in SF are renting for 2100.00 and 65% of the city's residents are renters. The 5 most expensive places to rent in the U.S. are, in order; NYC, Seattle, San Francisco, Oakland and Los Angeles. At these prices in these areas I'm not surprised apparently many are living at the edge of homelessness?

116 agree | 103 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
12:31 PM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner Reader said:
Yahoo's website reports this morning nicer flats in NYC are going for 3100.00, where 80% of the city residents rent. SF's nicer flats are going for 2100.00, where 65% of the city residents rent. The website reports the most expensive places to rent in the U.S are, in order; NYC, Seattle, San Francisco, Oakland and Los Angeles. At these prices, why should we be surprised many are apparently at the edge of homelessness?

117 agree | 117 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
11:47 AM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Apres said:
I recommend the profiled family's daughter teach her parents English and that the Dept. of Social Services dispatch Ms. Latimore (Editorial profiled in Working to Survive - transportation article) who earns a government wage of $17 an hour ($33,000 with benefits). She could deliver her city services literature. She has a lot in commom: she is responsible for her 23 yr. old daughter who’s in college and her daughters 7 yr. old son, but the daughter is not paying her way there is no court ordered child support for her son? Maybe together they could pressure the government to raise Ms. Latimore's salary to $55,000... along with other city employees who don't make a living wage!

101 agree | 112 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
11:36 AM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Apres said:
This profile above is a family of four. Two adults whether legal or illegal aliens who are working two full time jobs in San Francisco, a Sanctuary City with a minimum wage ordinance of $9.14 an hour should be doing well. That equates to %5,935.68 a month or $71, 228.16 a year. I think they can afford that garage! Remember: The Permanent Resident Card, Form I-551, is issued to all Permanent Residents as evidence of alien registration and their permanent status in the US. The card must be in your possession at all times. This requirement means that you are not only required to have a currently valid Form I-551 at all times, but also that you must carry your currently valid Form I-551 on your person at all times. The Permanent Resident Card currently is issued with a 10-year validity. You are required to notify us of any change of address within 10 days of that change. Form AR-11 is used for that purpose.

97 agree | 85 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
10:56 AM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner Reader said:
Hey, don't we have an abundant supply of affordable "public housing" available in the City ?? Or is that only being rented to African Americans ??

96 agree | 100 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
10:52 AM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

HA HA HA said:
Another reason why I am hapy not to be a San Francisco taxpayer!

124 agree | 102 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
10:49 AM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner Reader said:
The audacity of some of these people, the homeless advocates, the aiders and abetters of illegals and the city.

112 agree | 107 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
9:30 AM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Native Robert said:
and there will be more and more of such people with insatiable needs as liberal and conservative politicians alike allow open borders and disregard for immigration law enforcement. Living in San Francisco is not an entitlement for any Mexican that's able to sneak across the border. Wake up, fools!

107 agree | 99 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
9:21 AM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

examiner critic said:
So what are they? Illegal or not?

92 agree | 115 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
8:33 AM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner Reader said:
American citizens are afraid they may end up living in a car. Many do. What claim do the illegals have on our culture?

97 agree | 108 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
7:14 AM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner Reader said:
"They want materials in both Spanish and English and do not want immigration status to be a factor in the process. They also pushed for lottery exemptions." So when they are poor and impoverished in Mexico, they come to this country and now want us US taxpayers to contribute to their living? They should go home! Improve Mexico. The US will soon be bankrupt trying to pay for people who should not be here. I am not sympathetic when it involves my taxes and future. And why should they be exempt from a lottery? Now we will soon have ILLEGAL ALIEN getting housing before US citizens? Give me a break!

115 agree | 107 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
6:44 AM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Examiner Reader said:
Have you been wondering just why many in the government have been acting in the interest of businesses and against the will of, "We the People"? I believe the same group controls both major political parties. A group of bankers and businessmen had been trying to monopolize the banking industry. In 1912 Woodrow Wilson was elected President with the aid of a bribe from them. They formed the Federal Reserve and are like our personal credit cards are for us except they are the credit card for the government. Well that and they pay no taxes that I know of. Anyway they’re at about at their 100-year anniversary. They have grown to proportions that I believe they now control many of the politicians of the world. Not only can they buy politicians of both parties here, and control our borders, they can also control much of our spending. Have you also wondered why our once great nation has been spending money the way it does. It is sort of like how it would be to have a hundred wives on

118 agree | 103 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
5:18 AM MST on Mon., Oct. 8, 2007 re: "Many living on edge of homelessness"

Am I a Legal Alien said:
What is wrong with this picture? “I’m afraid I may end up living in an abandoned car or garage,” said Maria Guadalupe Garcia, who lives in a trailer in the Mission district after fleeing an abusive relationship in Mexico six months ago

133 agree | 115 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
 
 

(page generated in 0.11 seconds)