
|
Los Angeles City Guides
|
SAN FRANCISCO (Map, News) - A proposal to build a temporary band shell for acoustic performances in the Golden Gate Park Panhandle is drawing opposition from neighbors who say the structure would bring unwanted trash, noise and crowds.
The band shell, made of used car hoods, computer circuit panels and plastic water bottles, is part of the Black Rock Arts Foundation ScrapEden SF project, funded in part by a $50,000 grant from the San Francisco Department of the Environment.
The project is pitting advocates against some neighbors who say the structure is better suited for one of Golden Gate Park’s larger areas. Advocates say the band shell would bring an interactive art endeavor to a stretch of park often overlooked for such uses.
“We’re always looking for ways to keep [the Panhandle] beautiful since it has been saved from becoming a freeway,” said Rose Marie Dennis, spokeswoman for The City’s Recreation and Park Department.
The Panhandle, which stretches eight blocks between Oak and Fell streets, is the oldest part of Golden Gate Park, Dennis said. Basketball courts, a playground and a pedestrian path are used daily. Picnickers and people playing catch with their dogs are a common sight.
Under ScrapEden SF, the band shell, which would be 30 feet wide and 18 feet tall, would be the first of three temporary art structures installed in the Panhandle. If The City approves the band shell Thursday, it will be up from June 1 to Sept. 15.
“It’s a good project, and I believe it will add well to a neighborhood that is starting to see a lot of families grow or return,” Supervisor Ross Mirkarimi said.
Project directors plan to schedule nonamplified performances from noon to dusk daily at the band shell, from jazz and puppet shows to theatrical performances. The shows are expected to attract fewer than 25 people.
“Our hope and intention is to sponsor and promote community building projects,” said Leslie Pritchett, executive director of the Black Rock Arts Foundation, developed by Burning Man founders. Some Panhandle neighbors, however, are not convinced the performances would attract small crowds.
“The noise factor is definitely a deterrent for anyone in the neighborhood,” said Maureen Murphy, who lives on Oak Street. “Although they said there would be no amplification, any time you construct any sort of a band shell … Things start out with the best intentions, but things get out of hand.”
Murphy said she is concerned about safety, since the Panhandle sits between two major thoroughfares, and about trash generated from the crowds.
Deborah Chiarucci said Sharon Meadows in Golden Gate Park would be a better venue for the band shell.
“It’s such a small area. It would be unfair to put that burden on that location,” she said.
The City’s Recreation and Park Commission will discuss the proposed band shell at 2 p.m. Thursday at City Hall.
Not ranked |
EMAIL ME THIS STORY |
|
Sports
Business |
Real Estate Family Movies and Books Venues, Sports and Music Concerts, Artists and Tickets Be Inspired - Quotes and Stories |
Comments from Examiner Readers
2:05 PM MST on Wed., Jun. 20, 2007 re: "Neighbors divided over Panhandle band shell"
Report as inappropriate
3:08 PM MST on Wed., May. 2, 2007
re: "Neighbors divided over Panhandle band shell"
Report as inappropriate
2:38 PM MST on Wed., May. 2, 2007
re: "Neighbors divided over Panhandle band shell"
Report as inappropriate
Examiner Reader said:
HAHAHA, the NIMBYs lost this round. How does it feel to be reminded that a PUBLIC park is not your PRIVATE lawn? Bet some of you are so angry you could chomp through concrete. HA HA YOU LOST!
195 agree | 182 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
Former Fell St. Resident said:
"Picnickers and people playing catch with their dogs are a common sight." So why the heck do you want to mess that up? The amount of vagrancy in the panhandle will only INCREASE if you give people a place to loiter and sleep overnight in the park. This is a BAD IDEA! The police have enough to deal with, let's not make their jobs even tougher. DPT doesn't remove the buses parked Illegally around the PH as it is... Why give them a place to shoot up or smoke out on top of the garbage and raw sewage they dump nightly in the PH already. NTM "used car hoods, computer circuit panels and plastic water bottles" Recycle that stuff instead of killing the plants and contaminating the ground water with lead solder and old car paint. Tell the burners to erect that monstrosity in front of their own houses. They invade the PH every year with loud music and drinking to set up their Burning man crap every year already. And Yes... I AM a Professional artist living and working in the city.
232 agree | 211 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
Panhandle Resident said:
This would be a horrible experience for the neighbors who live around the panhandle. Noise from the panhandle carries so much, it's impossible to escape the noise of drumming if even 1 drummer is out on a bench. Having a band shell would be even worse. This should be placed inside the park, where you have the CHOICE to listen to it or not. I'm all for increasing the art projects within the city, just not at the expense of people's sanity. Thank you.
213 agree | 213 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree