3 Indiana congressmen breeze to primary victories
Article History
There are updates to this article.

INDIANAPOLIS (Map, News) - Three Indiana congressmen easily won their primaries Tuesday, but two others faced serious challengers.

Republicans Mark Souder in northeast Indiana's 3rd District and Steve Buyer in central Indiana's 4th District and Democrat Baron Hill in southeast Indiana's 9th District all defeated their challengers, with Hill's victory setting up his fourth consecutive rematch with former Republican Rep. Mike Sodrel in November.

The toughest races, however, were in the 7th District - where new Democratic Rep. Andre Carson faced seven challengers in his effort to retain the seat he won in a March special election - and in the 5th District, where longtime Republican Rep. Dan Burton faced what many saw as the strongest opponent of his 25-year career.

Burton had more than 60 percent of the vote with 22 percent of precincts reporting, while challenger John McGoff had 34 percent, according to unofficial results tallied by The Associated Press.

Early results showed Carson in a tight race with former state Health Commissioner Woody Myers and state Rep. David Orentlicher. State Rep. Carolene Mays was among others running in the Indianapolis district.

Voter turnout was high in Indianapolis, which could hurt Carson, said Robert Dion, a professor of American politics at the University of Evansville. The pool of voters in the urban district would be much larger than the party loyalists who might favor Carson and appreciate the work done by his grandmother, Rep. Julia Carson, who died in December after 11 years in Congress.

Some voters drawn to the exciting presidential primary knew little about the 7th District candidates. Media exposure - and the money it takes to pay for it - was important to win over those voters, Dion said.

"They go by what they've heard, and what they've heard is Woody Myers on TV," Dion said.

Myers put more than $1.6 million of his own money on his campaign to help pay for advertising.

"We will see on May 6 how this investment pays off," Myers said last month. "I'm willing to do what it takes to get the job done."

The winner was likely to face state Rep. Jon Elrod - who lost to Carson in the March special election - although Cat Ping and Larry Shouse also sought the Republican nomination.

In the 5th District, McGoff, an emergency room physician, hoped to unseat Burton, the state's longest-serving congressman.

Burton came under fire last year amid reports that he missed 19 House votes during a trip to California for a charity golf tournament. Burton has said the golf trip was a mistake and that House votes had typically not been held during that week in recent years.

McGoff's campaign played up Burton's travels with a Web site - wheresdanburton.com - that featured photos of the congressman's head on cartoon drawings.

"People are really ready for a change here," McGoff has said. "People are paying attention."

Getting out the GOP vote was key for McGoff. A low Republican turnout, which was possible because Sen. John McCain already had locked up the party's presidential nomination, likely would favor Burton as the party faithful support their incumbent.

Even if voters were unhappy and McGoff won a substantial portion of the vote, it would take a lot to actually defeat Burton in a primary, Dion said.

"He may get a slap in the face, but I'd be surprised if he lost," Dion said.

Indiana's other incumbents - Democratic Reps. Peter Visclosky, Joe Donnelly and Brad Ellsworth and Republican Mike Pence - were unopposed in the primary.

Copyright 2008 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


Name
Comments

characters left

INCLUDED
 

(page generated in 0.13 seconds)