Divining the mystery of the eternally dumped
Article History
There are updates to this article.

Ever look out across a giant landfill and think, “It’s like looking into a mirror.” No, not because you collect garbage and seagulls, but because you’ve been dumped as regularly as the trash. Why does this happen? You’re a good person, right? You didn’t vote for Sanjaya on American Idol. You believe in truth, justice and liposuction, so you look good and are good. But you keep getting left in the proverbial love dust. This week, our two Titans of the Tryst explore the mystery of the perpetually dumped.

DAN: Happily, I can say I have not been perpetually dumped. Sadly, I can say that’s because I haven’t been in enough relationships to have had much statistical chance at the experience. But let’s take a look at what generally will get your butt punted through dating’s metaphorical uprights. The No. 1 reason a guy dumps a woman: fear.

This occurs when the woman comes on way too strong, i.e. three dates and she’s got a couple dresses in your closet and expects you to baby-sit her pet iguana while she’s exploring the subcontinent for six months. “But he seemed so interested, why did he reject me?” Well, lady, that’s because you’re No. 3 of the Four Horsewomen of the Dating Apocalypse: The Bitter, The Wounded, The Desperate and The Insane — also known as Carrie, Miranda, Charlotte and Samantha from “Sex and the City.” There’s a reason why it’s called “the stink of desperation.” Not the flowery aroma. Not the morning dew scent. Stink, as in get it the heck outta here. It’s up, it’s good! You just split the uprights, you are gone!

JOAN: If you’re getting perpetually dumped, Mike Brenner, a mind-body therapist at Intentions in Reisterstown, says there’s good news and bad news. “The whole pattern is a reenactment of some basic experience in childhood. Until they find out what experience of betrayal, disappointment or rejection they carry into their adult life, it will keep happening over and over.”

He says the solution is to get help in self-discovery and to track back to how this got started. “The bad news is, if this is not addressed at its root, it will go on forever. The good news is, it can be remedied.”

DAN: It’s been said that a woman is a creature that wants what it wants when it wants it. So buck up, you’ll feel fine tomorrow, but lousy again on Thursday.

In all fairness, men are creatures who suffer from a strange form of duality, not unlike Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. On the one hand, we’re pragmatic masters of the outdoor grill, but we also have this second nature, driven by testosterone, that makes us abandon our brains when a lovely female is near. It’s like you black out and then suddenly wonder why you’re cohabiting with this woman who hogs the bathroom and doesn’t seem to like anything at all about your clothes, haircut, mother, etc. It’s at this point we square up the tee, if you follow me. But don’t blame us, ladies. You jump in a pool, don’t complain if you get wet.

JOAN: WPOC-FM’s Country Road host Father Joe Breighner is one of my favorite people, and when I asked him about people who constantly get dumped he said the following:

“I go back to the traditional understanding [that] mostly we act out our unconscious in picking our mate. Fifty percent is genetic wiring; 40 percent is our unconscious; 10 percent is free will. If you’re stuck in the cycle of picking the wrong partner, you’re acting out a script. If you saw your parents struggle, or your mom wasn’t happy, then you think you’re not supposed to be happy. If they’re being perpetually dumped, they’re setting themselves up to attract these people. It’s like that [Rolling Stones] song — ‘You can’t always get what you want, you get what you need.’ We think we want a good partner, but some part of us thinks we don’t deserve a good one, and that’s what we get. We keep acting out the unconscious until we can heal an unhealed wound in ourselves."

Dan Collins is a terminally single 40-something writer and local PR maven. Joan Allen is a noted matchmaker extraordinaire and author of “Celebrating Single and Getting Love Right: From Stalemate to Soulmate.”


Name
Comments

characters left


Comments from Examiner Readers

3:00 PM MST on Wed., Jul. 23, 2008 re: "In the game of love, sports is a major player"

Nancy-Single on the Road said:
From working with ESPN and an 90% crew of men every weekend for over 10 years, I can comment on this one! Every weekend that I show up for work, I am bombarded by comments on my outfits, and this is from men that breath and eat sports! AND THEN they quickly move on back to sports. Unless they are clothes designers, metrosexuals, or extremely in touch with their feminine side- I just don't think it merits much attention or is a top priority for men to spend time on the subject of our outfits. I think they make a mental note of our choices over time and make a mental summary (just like they would with their favorite -or soon to be not so favorite by those choices- quarterback.) Men ARE from Mars, but keep those new dresses coming without expecting a response and they will appreciate you like Venus. Even if its sharing nachos watching the game.

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree

2:38 PM MST on Thu., Jul. 10, 2008 re: "Survey says, trust yourself, not the research"

Nancy-Single on the Road said:
Just moved back from SoFla and your articles my Mom sent me I now enjoy right off the driveway!I've been living in the dating nightmare capital of the world for women over,well, 35 is over the hill down there.Add to that I'm 5'11" so I was one of the tallest people down there and am not enhanced with plastic surgery...yet.So,it was time to come home and meet a nice guy only to find everyone tell me its a dating nightmare HERE!(Just one reason for the move btw.)Also, I work with almost all men on the road in the TV /Sports Industry and travel alot.Bitter?Airplane for one please.You'd think it would be easy to find one crispy in a stale bag of chips, but its not! You know the OJ book,'If I Did It?' Well, mine is,"If I Dated It!" The sad part is all the stories I gather from singles(sorry Dan, usually women-the men are busy showing pictures of their wives-NOT) on the road are just as pathetic.So what words of wisdom do you have for this tall,45ish,nomadic newcomer to Balto.?

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
8:25 AM MST on Sat., Jul. 5, 2008 re: "Making the most of every day, relationship"

Examiner Reader said:
"“Now I’m waiting on a birth mom in Florida. It’s very hard to find a birth mother if you are single in the U.S. I have a room set up for a baby, a rescue dog, and a new career that I love. Now I want to save a child, not the world.”" Ugh. You really need to education yourself about adoption before you consider it. If you're going in with the idea of 'rescuing' you've got a long way to go. Also, birth mother is a sexist and offensive term. It implies that a woman is only an incubator. A pregnant woman is an expectant mother.

0 agree | 2 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
3:09 PM MST on Sat., Mar. 8, 2008 re: "Putting a corporate spin on the dating game"

Examiner Reader said:
Joan, try a valium.

7 agree | 7 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
1:20 PM MST on Tue., Jul. 3, 2007 re: "The perilous world of online dating"

Happy Mom said:
My son went on J-Date last year, connected with a young lady living in Hawaii for a year, started talking long distance and he decided to go visit her (he figured if she didn't work out he knew he would love Hawaii). Long story short, he called 6 days later and said he loved both. They are on their honeymoon right now. My daughter met her husband on same site, he was living in Virginia, but distance didn't seem a problemk. They are now married for 3 years. So sometimes these services do work and make the parents happy to see their children happy!

743 agree | 180 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
7:17 AM MST on Tue., May. 29, 2007 re: "What’s with men who date only younger women?"

Examiner Reader said:
re: "For me, it can take months to trust and truly love someone, and during that time I am open to meeting others." -- I think the ambiguity and potential conflict comes from people who say what you say but are also willing to have sex with the person in the mean time. Many people equate sex with exclusivity. If she does and you don't, there's a problem. Either you have to wait to have sex until you're ready to be exclusive, or she has to be willing to have sex without being exclusive. The problem is no one likes to talk about this until after having sex. ;-)

229 agree | 207 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
 
 

(page generated in 0.14 seconds)