
|
Los Angeles City Guides
|
Article History
SAN FRANCISCO (Map, News) - Marilyn Rodriguez says she thought it was a gunshot she heard Monday morning as she walked her dog Benson in Stern Grove, but she quickly realized it was the cracking and collapsing of a branch.
In a freak accident, a woman was killed Monday when a 50-foot redwood tree branch fell upon her as she stood in the Sloat Boulevard parking lot of the heavily wooded park.
“A car alarm went off, and then I realized what I heard was a branch,” said Rodiguez, a Sunnyside resident.
The partial tree with protruding branches damaged the rear of the car, a Subaru Outback, and lay across the woman’s body.
The victim was transported to San Francisco General Hospital, but doctors pronounced her dead at 12:14 p.m., San Francisco police Sgt. Wilfred Williams said.
The broken piece of tree appeared to be “a portion of the top of the tree and had branches coming off of it,” San Francisco Fire Department spokeswoman Lt. Mindy Talmadge said, estimating it fell 30 feet.
“This big section of the tree broke, came down and hit — crushed her car,” Talmadge said.
The official cause of the break was unknown, but she said it “was very windy out.”
The woman’s three dogs — two labradors and a Chihuahua-corgi mix — were uninjured and cared for by Animal Care and Control before a family member retrieved them Monday, Capt. Vicky Guldbech of Animal Care and Control said.
This was not the first incident in Stern Grove. Recreation and Park Department spokeswoman Rose Dennis said a city employee conducting tree work there died during a storm in 1981.
“Trees here shed branches from time to time,” said John Rossi, who has lived near Stern Grove his entire life and was walking in the park Monday afternoon.
Rossi was surprised at the news of a fellow hiker’s death, but doesn’t feel unsafe walking in the grove.
“That’s too bad — like being struck by lightning,” he said. “It’s just really unlucky.”
Vehicle access to the park will be denied until Thursday or until the department has “assured people and ourselves that it was a fluke,” Dennis said. “There’s nothing wrong with Stern Grove, but we need to make sure we’ve done our due diligence,” she said.
Examiner Staff Writer Beth Winegarner contributed to this report.
Not ranked |
EMAIL ME THIS STORY |
ARTICLE HISTORY |
Sports
Business |
Real Estate Family Movies and Books Venues, Sports and Music Concerts, Artists and Tickets Be Inspired - Quotes and Stories |
Comments from Examiner Readers
11:54 AM MST on Thu., May. 1, 2008 re: "Killer tree was flagged as danger"
Report as inappropriate
11:03 AM MST on Wed., Apr. 30, 2008
re: "Killer tree was flagged as danger"
Report as inappropriate
8:39 AM MST on Wed., Apr. 30, 2008
re: "Killer tree was flagged as danger"
Report as inappropriate
8:31 AM MST on Wed., Apr. 30, 2008
re: "Tree limb snaps, kills woman"
Report as inappropriate
8:10 AM MST on Wed., Apr. 30, 2008
re: "Killer tree was flagged as danger"
Report as inappropriate
12:47 PM MST on Tue., Apr. 15, 2008
re: "Tree limb snaps, kills woman"
Report as inappropriate
Examiner Reader said:
Why do tree branches fall off? Mostly due to expanding/contracting of the wood.
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
Examiner Reader said:
Looks like another big settlement for the taxpayers to pay. We need new leadership in the city desperately. Please resign Newsom and dept heads.
1 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
Examiner Reader said:
Hey, good on the Examiner for digging up the information behind this avoidable tragedy. How come no other news outlet it the Bay Area could find out that for years the tree was a known hazard?
4 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
Examiner Reader said:
So long as the Recreation and Park Department continues to maintain that the woman was killed by a "fluke," they won't do anthing to remove the ongoing threat to park visitors. They just deny responsibility and continue to irresponsibly do nothing. The trees in Stern Grove are individually identified according to their degree of hazard, including the one which killed the woman. RPD should refocus its priorities toward visitor safety. It makes no sense to cut down healthy, non-hazardous trees (as they have done in Stern Grove/Pine Lake)and leave the dangerous ones in the park.
8 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
Examiner Reader said:
The Park Dept’s spokesperson claims that “on an ongoing basis all those trees are looked at.” I would like her repeat this bogus claim while sitting in the witness stand with her hand on the bible. Anyone who knows how short-handed and under-funded the Park Dept's Urban Forestry Division is, knows that this isn't true. The Urban Forestry crew barely has time to haul away the many trees that fall in the parks because they are full of hazardous trees like the one that killed Kathleen Bolton. The only thing unique about Stern Grove is that the Dept paid a highly qualified arborist good money to evaluate all the trees over 5 years ago, then ignored their advice. There are just as many dangerous trees in all the parks in the City. I'm also sorry that the Stern Grove Festival Assoc is “optimistic that the accident won’t deter" 100,000 from going to the concerts this summer. It's irresponsible of the Festival to even hold their concerts until the dangerous trees are removed.
6 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
Examiner Reader said:
This incident was no "tragic fluke" as stated by Ms. Dennis on TV news. It's been a so-called fluke waiting to happen for years. On March 17 just a little over 3 weeks ago, the same potential "tragic fluke" happened as a friend and I were walking toward that same parking lot. A thunderous crash and huge branches fell into the entry road completely blocking it. This should have been a warning to Rec & Park. Within this past year a tree fell onto the other entry road at Vale St and a tree fell onto a walking path leading down to the parking lot where this sad incident happened. How much warning does RPD need to take notice and action? Each of these tree falling incidents had the potential to injure or kill. It's only luck so far that no person or car was in their path at the time. Calling this incident a fluke or freak accident covers up the fact that RPD has ignored the potential danger from at-risk, aging trees which exists every day for people who visit and walk in Stern Grove park
9 agree | 2 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree