Examiner.com // 37 mins ago
ABC7.com // 41 mins ago
ABC7.com // 1 hr 11 mins ago
CBS2-KCAL // 1 hr 34 mins ago
ABC7.com // 1 hr 57 mins ago
CBS2-KCAL // 2 hrs ago
KTLA.com // 2 hrs 47 mins ago
ABC7.com // 2 hrs 51 mins ago
CBS2-KCAL // 3 hrs ago
CBS2-KCAL // 3 hrs ago
 
   
Teens guilty in Baltimore bus beating case
Article History
There are updates to this article.

BALTIMORE (Map, News) - Sarah Kreager sat stonefaced in the front row of court as the judge read the verdicts. She put her arm around her longtime boyfriend, Troy Ennis, Tuesday as teenager after teenager was convicted of brutally beating her — breaking two bones in her face — aboard an MTA bus in December.

For the first time in a Baltimore City courtroom, the 26-year-old woman smiled.

“Sarah Kreager and Troy Ennis have been vindicated,” prosecutor Janet Hankin said outside the courthouse. “The allegations made against them are untrue and uncalled for. They have caused an unnecessary rift in the community and I hope now the verdicts are in the community can heal from the hurt and the unnecessary racial tension.”

Baltimore City Juvenile Judge David Young convicted four teens —two females and two males — of first-degree assault in the beating of Kreager and Ennis, 30, on the No. 27 bus Dec. 4. A fifth student, a male, was convicted of second-degree assault against only Ennis.

Kreager and Ennis were quickly escorted out by officers with the state’s attorney’s witness protection program.

Hours earlier Kreager had cried as defense attorneys verbally attacked her, accusing Ennis of using racial slurs and her of starting the fight with the middle school students.

“It wasn’t bad enough she had to be beaten on the bus,” Hankin said. “She was beaten up on closing arguments. Now she had to listen to the fabrications of the defense.”

But defense attorney Garland Sanderson said he was “deeply disappointed.”

“There was absolutely no evidence that supported the decision,” said Sanderson, who represents one boy.

During closing arguments, defense attorneys said Kreager and Ennis began the brawl.

“This is about race,” defense attorney Margaret Desonier said. “African-American children were all telling the same story and nobody would believe them.”

But prosecutor Dawn Jones said it was absurd to think Ennis used a racial slur on a bus packed with 40 black students.

“In that situation, the grand wizard of the Ku Klux Klan [wouldn’t say] the N-word,” Jones said.

Sentencing is scheduled for April 3.

lbroadwater@baltimoreexaminer.com

Take our poll

Vovici Online Survey Software


Name
Comments

characters left


Comments from Examiner Readers

5:03 PM MST on Mon., May. 12, 2008 re: "Kreager: Bus attack ‘strengthened my soul’"

Examiner Reader said:
What did the kids learn? That if the mob is big enough, you can get away with attempted murder. I am very sorry for every child that took away this lesson -- life is going to be harder for them -- and for the rest of Baltimore, too.

1 agree | 1 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree

4:36 PM MST on Wed., Apr. 30, 2008 re: "Kreager: Bus attack ‘strengthened my soul’"

emma said:
i unfortunately had to spend a short period of time in a jail for traffic nonsense and i'll never forget this black woman in there about 40 years of age with the mental capability of maybe an 8 year old who told me all about the money laundering she'd done, robberies (she was in for probation violation), how here father would shoot at her and her siblings with a pellet gun for fun that was set up in the den, how she was raped by an uncle...etc...i could not believe her life. and she actually had a sense of humor about it but was totally bonkers and didn't seem to realize it. just nutso. and she had 5 kids all with relatives living off the welfare system. do not get what is wrong with the black community. two of her kids were in jail in the maximum security area (she and i were in minimum security)for grand larceny. i mean, her father sounded like a sociopath the way she described him and she knew he was crazy but also thought him funny. i think we cannot even being to get their live

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
12:22 PM MST on Tue., Apr. 29, 2008 re: "Kreager: Bus attack ‘strengthened my soul’"

Examiner Reader said:
I think Wright is half right. I think there is a different brain function with regard to many blacks. But when he says that "different does not mean deficient", I have to take issue.

2 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
12:01 PM MST on Mon., Apr. 28, 2008 re: "Kreager: Bus attack ‘strengthened my soul’"

Examiner Reader re: re- 8:26 said:
cont.- and graduation rates and the comparison would be embarassing on every level. The beat that the marching band marches to is THE LEAST of their differences and Wright would have been better to point to those African Americans who know that speaking gramatically correct English is speaking "business" English, not White European English instead of celebrating their differences and asserting that they are not a disability. To be unable to converse clearly with others globally who speak in standard English that is the official language of the U.N. is to be disabled in the marketplace, and destined to be economically deprived. For him to then talk about brain differences is a VERY SLIPPERY SLOPE. Educated Black professionals had better get a handle on this guy FAST. Obama won't. As predicted, Wright has signed a book deal. Obama has more on his plate than he knows I'm afraid.

1 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
11:48 AM MST on Mon., Apr. 28, 2008 re: "Kreager: Bus attack ‘strengthened my soul’"

Examiner Reader re: re- 8:26 said:
This was a classic example of mob mentality and could have ended tragically. As to Rev. Wright's sppech where he mentioned the difference in brain function between blacks and whites. I listened to the entire speech-TWICE- and he made several interesting points in regard to music, cadence, religious service differences. His mocking interpretations of northeastern speech vs.southwestern speech-using whites as examples of people who speak differently but aren't considered deficient as opposed to black gramatically incorrect speech may have worked against rather than for him. Left him with too many ugly sound bites yet again and of course the mocking black speech would have been intolerable had a white rev. done this. The musical/clapping differences though interesting completely missed the most important point in his comparison of Mi. State and U. of Mi. marching bands vs. Grambling and Texas A&M. Again any reporter with a computer can pull up the student profiles and, GPAs. (above)

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
11:31 AM MST on Mon., Apr. 28, 2008 re: "Kreager: Bus attack ‘strengthened my soul’"

Reader said:
Civility is an issue, however humanity and love for all human kind would be the lesson. Kreager will move on with her life. No more low self-esteem I hope. She has a good man looking out for her= GOD! School will be out for summer and Sheila Dixon better issue a curfew and stop brushing this city under the carpet.

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
10:42 AM MST on Mon., Apr. 28, 2008 re: "Kreager: Bus attack ‘strengthened my soul’"

Examiner Reader said:
To Conscious Reader You are not the only one that cannot comprehend the hatred that these kids displayed on the MTA bus. It's unfathomable. I agree with what so many have said and that this was more about civility than race.

1 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
10:04 AM MST on Mon., Apr. 28, 2008 re: "Kreager: Bus attack ‘strengthened my soul’"

Trickle Down Effect said:
Pawns for the righteous Bus driver. Get a clue. We are all equals to an extent.

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
9:17 AM MST on Mon., Apr. 28, 2008 re: "Kreager: Bus attack ‘strengthened my soul’"

Examiner Reader said:
I hope Ms Kreager can now get on with her life. I hope Nakita McDaniels gets the physciatric help she so desperately needs, and is able to salvage her life as well. I my greatist hope, is that the Black community will finally look inward, recoginize their is a real problem with black youth, and begin to honestly deal with the problem. The time for blaming other races, or some notion of an oppressive government is long gone. It's time for honest, constructive solutions -- Not the excuse mills like rev wright who would have you believe blacks have a different brain function.

5 agree | 1 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
9:03 AM MST on Mon., Apr. 28, 2008 re: "Kreager: Bus attack ‘strengthened my soul’"

Paul said:
I was forced to grow up and attend school in an African American neighborhood as a white kid. While I cannot accuse all of them of acting like animals, by and large that would be an accurate assessment of a majority of their individual behavior. Because of intergration, I was forced to fight my way through school and was lucky to receive any education - at all. Learing in the classroom was almost an impossibility, as there is very little regard for order in African American culture, as well as value for education. Most African Americans seem to be unable to escape a barbaric tribal mindset that Americans of European descent have left behind. Unlike the liberal elite in this country, my experiences and experiences like this poor women have left me with the conclusion that a racialy divided society is not only desirable, but the only logical conclusion. Unless African American culture evolves, they will continue to fill our prisons and spread collective misery in our country.

4 agree | 2 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
8:26 AM MST on Mon., Apr. 28, 2008 re: "Kreager: Bus attack ‘strengthened my soul’"

Examiner Reader said:
I think we're reaching a point where reasonable people can see the double standard in America. Blacks have a different idea of what consitutues criminal behavior. Maybe that has to do with what Rev Wright referred to as a difference in brain function between blacks and whites.

0 agree | 2 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
8:20 AM MST on Mon., Apr. 28, 2008 re: "Kreager: Bus attack ‘strengthened my soul’"

Examiner Reader said:
Shes right, there is a double standard in the US> If you make a comment about a black person based on race the NAACP is all over you, but you make a comment about a white person and there isnt anything that happens. Black racism is all over the place in BAltimore

1 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
8:01 AM MST on Mon., Apr. 28, 2008 re: "Kreager: Bus attack ‘strengthened my soul’"

Examiner Reader said:
GOD bless Ms. Kreager, and I pray she teaches her children to keep their hands to themselves, unlike the uncivilized ones who hurt her. And shame on their parents who did nothing but stand by...oh wait that's the reason these teens are out of control, no conscience...just like how they were raised.

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
6:14 AM MST on Mon., Apr. 28, 2008 re: "Kreager: Bus attack ‘strengthened my soul’"

Examiner Reader said:
Sarah Kreager has been beat up by countless individuals. Possible permanent damage to her eye at this young age? As she said, the medical bills will be immense. Who will pay the bills? These kids have gotten away with so much and it has sent the wrong message in Baltimore. Why do we insist on making the attackers look like the victims when they literally could have killed Sarah Kreager? As gregory Kane said Joyce King is the hero in this story.

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
6:01 AM MST on Mon., Apr. 28, 2008 re: "Kreager: Bus attack ‘strengthened my soul’"

Conscious Reader said:
I have lived in other urban areas, but the black people in Baltimore (children, parents, all of them - and yes, I am black), are from some other realm! I hope that this incident doesn't put a mark on all black children, or people. I know that this type of thing makes it very difficult to be able to trust, but please know, there are many of us - and our children - children that have involved families - that have a conscious, morals, and respect for the law and our fellow "humans". I understand when she said that there are 20 other people out there that know her face, it is scary. But I hope you know this isn't a black white thing, to me, it is a "civilized vs. uncivilized" thing. I can't fathom what those people did, the hatred and anger to a stranger. I grew up poor, but it didn't make me angry at people who had no responsibility in how my life was being lived. On the contrary, I used that anger to make sure that I wouldn't be caught in the same place as my parents.

3 agree | 2 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
5:54 AM MST on Mon., Apr. 28, 2008 re: "Kreager: Bus attack ‘strengthened my soul’"

Examiner Readerre: 5:16 said:
Let's include their lawyers in "these people".

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
5:16 AM MST on Mon., Apr. 28, 2008 re: "Kreager: Bus attack ‘strengthened my soul’"

Examiner Reader said:
"these people" The people who did this horrible beating!

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
4:33 AM MST on Mon., Apr. 28, 2008 re: "Kreager: Bus attack ‘strengthened my soul’"

Examiner Reader said:
This might have been what's called a defining moment in Sarah Kreager's life. She had SO many personal problems prior to the attack and this might have been the wake up call that made it clear to her that life is short and unpredictable. Time to turn her life around and focus on herself and her children and making a better, stable life for them as a family. Maybe time to find an alternate means of transportation too..........

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
11:54 AM MST on Sun., Apr. 27, 2008 re: "Judge sentences one teen to juvenile jail, four others to detention in bus beating"

Examiner Reader said:
Leave room for GOD'S wrath.

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
3:40 PM MST on Thu., Apr. 24, 2008 re: "Judge sentences one teen to juvenile jail, four others to detention in bus beating"

Examiner Reader said:
Children attacking children, having babies, without any hope of a future that does not repeat the past like a vicious circle. How does Baltimore break this ugly cycle? How do our inner cities escape from this self fulfilling prophecy of poverty crime violence and the breeding of future victims and perpetrators...by children.

3 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
1:39 PM MST on Thu., Apr. 24, 2008 re: "Judge sentences one teen to juvenile jail, four others to detention in bus beating"

Examiner Reader said:
What does "these people" mean, exactly?

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
12:31 PM MST on Thu., Apr. 24, 2008 re: "Judge sentences one teen to juvenile jail, four others to detention in bus beating"

Examiner Reader said:
Yet again we don't punish because it would be racist. These animals walk down the street just to do it again. Anyone that lives in Hampden know these animals and one of these days they are going to mess with the wrong people. On the bright side; they're breeding!

1 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
11:10 AM MST on Thu., Apr. 24, 2008 re: "Judge sentences one teen to juvenile jail, four others to detention in bus beating"

Examiner Reader said:
These Slip-N-Fall lawyers have a debilitating weakness with their case; Their bone head clients.

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
9:13 AM MST on Thu., Apr. 24, 2008 re: "Judge sentences one teen to juvenile jail, four others to detention in bus beating"

reader said:
The Judge wants to know what went wrong to cause this - He should look in the mirror. These are unbelievably light sentences for all concerned. Nakita M has 6 documented cases of what appears to be aggravated assault - one involving a stabbing; and now a near-homicidal beating. But she gets detention in juvie. She, if not the others, should have gone into the adult system, where she should have been all along. Tell me someone who has 6 priors who doesn't know the adult rules, here? Age has little to do with it; knowledge does. As for the others - they learned a valuable lesson, too: that if your skin is black and you live in Baltimore, the penalties are minimal.

3 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
9:07 AM MST on Thu., Apr. 24, 2008 re: "Judge sentences one teen to juvenile jail, four others to detention in bus beating"

Examiner Reader said:
At the very same time this "sentence" was being handed down, a group of wilding thugs was boarding the metro at the Johns Hopkins station. I took video with my cell phone that shows them jumping up and down, cursing and running up and down the length of the car. They tried to intimidate me after they realized I was recording their behavior, but quickly retreated after I let them know that I was no Sarah Kreager, and would have no problem handing out my own justice. It's time we all take back our city from this scourge.

4 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
7:24 AM MST on Thu., Apr. 24, 2008 re: "Judge sentences one teen to juvenile jail, four others to detention in bus beating"

Examiner Reader said:
To the thuglets who plan to sue....When all is said and done, the lawyers are going to do to you what you did to Sarah Kreager.

2 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
7:20 AM MST on Thu., Apr. 24, 2008 re: "Judge sentences one teen to juvenile jail, four others to detention in bus beating"

Examiner Reader said:
The judge has ordered individual psychiatric treatment for Nakita-not more therapy which hasn't been successful. We'll see a diagnosis one of these days. Good job David Young. At last more than a slap on the wrist and some counseling for this girl.

0 agree | 1 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
6:57 AM MST on Thu., Apr. 24, 2008 re: "Judge sentences one teen to juvenile jail, four others to detention in bus beating"

Examiner Reader said:
What has gone so wrong? Look in the mirror Judge David Young. Nakita had a long prior arrest record for assault and you did nothing. You and the system you represent are the problem.

2 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
6:47 AM MST on Thu., Apr. 24, 2008 re: "Judge sentences one teen to juvenile jail, four others to detention in bus beating"

Examiner Reader said:
Well, this looks like the end of the road for Nakita at the tender age of 15. Maybe she can be rehabilitated. maybe not but I think the judge was right that this girl was steadily working her way toward homicide. The remaining members who will get probation will need to be supervised and counseled carefully. David Young is right.What has gone so wrong? To the thuglets who escaped prosecution and now want to file suit, I say bring it on baby and let the light shine on what you've been up to at home, in the "community" and in your school records. Better think twice before opening that door to the media and public scrutiny.

0 agree | 1 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
5:35 AM MST on Thu., Apr. 24, 2008 re: "Judge sentences one teen to juvenile jail, four others to detention in bus beating"

Examiner Reader said:
Have fun in jail Nakita!! I hope you're there for a long long time. Kudos to this judge for setting an example for other wanna-be thugs.

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
3:51 PM MST on Sun., Apr. 13, 2008 re: "Sarah Kreager's attackers convicted in bus beating"

EffEmAll said:
Anybody who is trying to dig up dirt on Sarah Kreager, the homeless girl who lives in a homeless shelter, and was ruthlessly gang beat on a Baltimore City Bus by a gang of 9 savages, is an absolute moron, not worthy of rebuttal.

2 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
5:16 PM MST on Thu., Apr. 10, 2008 re: "Sarah Kreager's attackers convicted in bus beating"

Examiner Reader said:
Sarah Kreager has been beat up by so many people--the thugs on route 27 and the media, too. The only reason the public even knows about the drug distribution charge is because she was the victim of a beating. She gets to be victimized all over again because she was beaten. What is the sense in that? Imagine if every drug charge were reported in Baltimore newspapers? There wouldn't be room for any other news... What a shame.

1 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
10:10 AM MST on Tue., Apr. 8, 2008 re: "Bus beating victim guilty of drug charge"

Examiner Reader said:
Too bad you have to report about this poor woman, I see at least she has admitted to her mistakes in life. Too bad you didn't let us all know - who were waiting - that the sentencing was postponed - what a shame, Examiner. Hopefully, you'll let us know, and make a bigger headline out of the sentencing in the beating cases than you did here. Leave this woman alone, she's been thru enough!!! Shame on you....

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
8:28 AM MST on Tue., Apr. 8, 2008 re: "Bus beating victim guilty of drug charge"

Examiner Reader said:
This while drug sub culture in urban America is a terrible drain on the rest of society. I hope, with whatever she can recover from the teens who beat her and the MTA for not providing a minimum level of safety, she will be able to have a better life.

1 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
5:39 AM MST on Tue., Apr. 8, 2008 re: "Bus beating victim guilty of drug charge"

The Undertaker said:
I wish her the best of luck. Hopefully one day we will end this immoral and stupid war on drugs.

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
3:49 PM MST on Mon., Apr. 7, 2008 re: "Sarah Kreager's attackers convicted in bus beating"

Examiner Reader said:
Dear all, My suggestion was for those interested in this issue is to write not only to the MTA, but to the City Council and to your local representatives as well. I agree that the issue is a larger one about the perpetration of hate crimes. At the same time, when local politicians hear enough complaints they are more likely to respond. If everyone puts just a few minutes of energy into writing letters of complaint, the issue is less likely to be pushed under the rug.

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
2:54 PM MST on Sat., Apr. 5, 2008 re: "Sarah Kreager's attackers convicted in bus beating"

Examiner Reader said:
Sentencing was postponed. The judge was unavailable. It's rescheduled for April 23.

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
2:10 PM MST on Sat., Apr. 5, 2008 re: "Sarah Kreager's attackers convicted in bus beating"

Examiner Reader said:
I read on a blog somewhere that the sentencing was postponed, but I could not find an article or mention of this anywhere else on the internet.

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
5:41 PM MST on Fri., Apr. 4, 2008 re: "Sarah Kreager's attackers convicted in bus beating"

Examiner Reader said:
Where is the article on the sentencing? Is the media going to keep the sentences a secret? It's been 17 days since the last article in which the miniature thugs were found guilty. When does the public get let in on the secret of the sentencing?

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
11:29 AM MST on Fri., Apr. 4, 2008 re: "Sarah Kreager's attackers convicted in bus beating"

EffEmAll said:
Of course thats not a bad idea, and certainly wont do any harm. But this thing is far beyond the MTA. Hate Crime laws need to apply to minorities, as they do to everybody else. Can you imagine if the racial roles were reversed in this case, and none of the perpetrators were charged with a "Hate Crime" ? I cant even imagine it. I want to know why this case isnt on Oprah. Why isnt there the same public outcry which would undoubtedly be the case if the racial roles were reversed ?

7 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
6:04 PM MST on Thu., Apr. 3, 2008 re: "Sarah Kreager's attackers convicted in bus beating"

Examiner Reader said:
I have a proposition for all of the intelligent and fair-minded people following this case. What if we mobilized and each wrote a letter to our representatives, city council, and the MTA about the state of public transportation in Baltimore and how current and potential MTA riders do not feel safe given the violence occurring on buses (as this is not the first of such incidents in Baltimore)? When the MTA and others feel that their bottom line might actually be affected by violence against citizens, that is when you will see changes in procedure (i.e., having working cameras on buses and stiff penalities for assaults on buses)happen. If the MTA sees this as something that just affects a person here and there and not the public at large, they won't make sweeping changes. If 100 citizens complained to the MTA and the city council, we might just see something happen. Will you be part of the 100? Let's do it! Write back and let's coordinate this effort. Let's shoot for 100 complaints.

1 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
5:07 PM MST on Thu., Apr. 3, 2008 re: "Sarah Kreager's attackers convicted in bus beating"

Examiner Reader said:
Is anyone interested in the sentencing in this case? I cannot find a single mention of it anywhere on the internet. Was the sentencing postponed? Or do we not care about what happens to passengers on public transportation in this country? You'd think there would at least be mention that the case was postponed and why.

2 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
3:09 PM MST on Sat., Mar. 29, 2008 re: "Sarah Kreager's attackers convicted in bus beating"

Civil Man said:
As youths, we all do stupid things. You may have smoked a bong or two. You may have slept around. You may even have vandalized a car, or smashed a window. But how many of you can add participation in a violent gang-beating of innocent people, unprovoked - to your list of youthful indescretions ? Not many, I presume. That's because these arent "youthful indescretions", but rather violent criminal acts, by which the perpetrators have served notice on society, that they are unfit to live among the civilized population. They have yelled it loud and clear, "We are not fit to live among civilized people. We have violent tendencies, which do not discriminate on the basis of provocation. We have no remorse, and do not care if our victims may be permanently damaged, physically, or emotionally. We owe no apologies to anybody." That's what these criminals are saying to all of us who live in civilized society...are we listening ?

8 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
5:01 AM MST on Fri., Mar. 28, 2008 re: "Teens guilty in Baltimore bus beating case"

Examiner Reader said:
Nakia: Why in the world would you want such violent people PARDONED?

2 agree | 0 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
12:21 PM MST on Fri., Mar. 21, 2008 re: