Critics: Intimidation alive at nuke plant
Article History
There are updates to this article.

BALTIMORE (Map, News) - Federal investigators aren’t addressing the fear of reprisal that discouraged employees from reporting sleeping guards at Peach Bottom nuclear plant, six miles from Harford in Pennsylvania, critics say.

“Multiple people had to be aware of this, but none of these people felt compelled to say, ‘Hey, I’m raising a red flag here,’ ” said John Jasinski, a former Peach Bottom Atomic Power Station security director who worked with security guard Kerry Beal to bring the sleeping guards to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission’s attention.

“Are people afraid to report these types of incidents?” he asked. “They don’t know how to report?”

Reports of sleeping guards had not gotten past shift supervisors — and at least one supervisor discouraged reports, plant manager Joseph Grimes said at a public hearing Monday at the Peach Bottom Inn in Delta near the plant.

“I don’t think you’ve defeated the culture of intimidation and corruption,” said Eric Epstein, of Harrisburg, who represents the Three-Mile Island Alert organization that monitors security at the Susquehanna region’s nuclear plants.

But NRC investigator Dana Caron said individuals had many reasons for not reporting similar incidents.

“Some individuals didn’t report, probably for personal reasons,” he said.

“Others didn’t report because they were discouraged from raising those kind of safety issues. ... They were afraid for their jobs, they were afraid for their advancement, they were afraid of actions by their supervisors.”

David Wachtel, a Washington lawyer representing Beal, said his client still felt threatened by those who lost their jobs because of the investigation.

Caron said the sleeping guards and the failures of the plant’s procedures for reporting problems constituted a threat “potentially greater than green,” referring to the lowest of the color-coded threat levels used by the NRC.

STORY SO FAR

March: John Jasinski sends the Nuclear Regulatory Commission a letter alleging guards are sleeping throughout the nuclear plant in York County, Pa. The NRC refers the concern to plant owner Exelon and security provider Wackenhut.

Sept. 10: WCBS in New York informs the NRC that it has a videotape of guards asleep or nodding off in a “ready room” near the nuclear reactor.

Sept. 21: An NRC inspection confirms only the 10 guards caught on tape were sleeping — only one of four shifts is implicated.

Nov. 1: Exelon terminates its contract with Wackenhut and takes over the plant’s security. Whistle-blower Kerry Beal, on leave during the investigation, is not among the Wackenhut guards rehired by Exelon.

Nov. 5: NRC inspectors follow up at Peach Bottom to ensure Exelon is correcting the problem.

December 2007-2008: NRC pledges to monitor corrective action by Exelon.

msantoni@baltimoreexaminer.com


Name
Comments

characters left


Comments from Examiner Readers

12:39 PM MST on Sun., Feb. 17, 2008 re: "Feds pledge new policies on guards, whistle-blowers at nuclear plants"

Darny said:
It's down right Un-American to fall asleep on the job. Keep up with policy and record these instances for future reference. Make the necesary changes. Homeland security needs to get involved. My own people are endangering us all with stupidity and not enough sleep. Know your co-workers. Kick there arse if they fall asleep. Put a coffee maker in the office for God sakes!!

38 agree | 38 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree

7:52 AM MST on Sun., Feb. 17, 2008 re: "Feds pledge new policies on guards, whistle-blowers at nuclear plants"

Examiner Reader said:
I find your choice of "...former Clinton-era Energy Department advisor Robert Alvarez..." as a commenter on the security issues at Peach Bottom to be interesting considering that he lost his position (a political appointment)as a senior policy advisor at DOE after his security clearance was lifted when he and his wife were arrested in 1999 by Takoma Park, Md. police for growing marijuana at home. They were turned in by their teen-aged daughter. So far as I can ascertain, he has spent most of his career in politically appointed policy positions dealing primarily with international nuclear weapons control and has no direct experience with commercial nuclear power plants. There certainly are more creditable "critics" of the NRC that could have been used in your article. David Lockbaum of UCS or Billie with GAP have consistently raised valid critical commentary on NRC and industry performance, in particular with whistle-blowers.

40 agree | 50 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
10:47 AM MST on Wed., Feb. 6, 2008 re: "Whistle-blower told don't worry"

Examiner Reader said:
This is par for the course for Wackenhut. While going to college I worked at a Government site in Alabama. The guards regularly slept on duty, watched television, and even misappropriated vehicles for personal business. When a female employee brought this to the ex prison-guard PM's attention, he conducted a sham investigation, handed out minimal punishments, and found a way to eventually fire the whistleblower. Amazingly enough the site renewed the contract, even awarding several additional security positions to Wackenhut. Somewhere, someplace Wackenhut has friends in the Federal Government, and they are being protected. Or worse, no one really cares what's going on out there. Incompetence is rampant. no one is really watching.

28 agree | 33 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
5:17 PM MST on Wed., Nov. 7, 2007 re: "Feds return to Peach Bottom"

Examiner Reader said:
The feds have found that "management did not effectively convey that sleeping was unacceptable"! That's great. What a wonderful way to spend taxpayers' money. I guess that federal employees and vendors who work under federal contract are now going to have to sign a special forms that reads, " I agree to stay awake while on the job and I understand that my sleeping on the job may result in my employment termination."

103 agree | 107 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
8:00 AM MST on Wed., Nov. 7, 2007 re: "Whistle-blower told don't worry"

Examiner Reader said:
I am sure his job with Wackenhut is protected under the whistle blowers law. Had Wackenhut not been fired, I am sure he would still have a job.

101 agree | 81 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
2:30 PM MST on Tue., Nov. 6, 2007 re: "Whistle-blower told don't worry"

Duh! said:
Duh! This will cost the company millions. What were they supposed to do, give this guy a raise and a promotion?

74 agree | 88 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
6:11 AM MST on Tue., Nov. 6, 2007 re: "Whistle-blower told don't worry"

G said:
What's the matter, you never took a nap while guarding a nuclear facility before?

97 agree | 97 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
 
 

(page generated in 0.17 seconds)