Opinion: Political winds blow bad deal past fiscal guardian
Article History
There are updates to this article.

Washington DC (Map, News) - Tomorrow night, Natwar Gandhi, the District's unbending bean counter for the past decade, will be honored by Governing Magazine as one of the year's top public officials. He will share the rarefied air with Washington Governor Christine Gregoire, L.A. Police Chief Bill Bratton and Houston Mayor Bill White.

"Fiscal Guardian," the magazine calls Gandhi.

Some D.C. pols and bureaucrats prefer less flattering titles. "Chief Fictional Officer," is Council Member David Catania's line for Gandhi. Some of Mayor Adrian Fenty's young department heads grouse that Gandhi is a tightwad. Most would agree he can be conservative to a fault in dispensing public funds.

As it should be. Gandhi's job is to guard the District's dough; everyone else can whine and complain at will. Guided by a law that says he must balance the District's budget every year, Gandhi wears my preferred moniker - Dr. No.

Say what they will about Gandhi, who served as head of D.C.'s tax and revenue department in 1997 until he took over as CFO in 2000, numbers speak loudest. When he showed up, D.C. was $500 million in the hole; financial records were strewn across floors and file cabinets. Now the District has a fund balance of $1.5 billion. While our neighbors in Maryland and Virginia run deficits and cut programs, Gandhi recently announced a $100 million surplus for DC.

How come?

"Our economy is very sound," Gandhi told me. "Our real property market is still strong. And there's the fiscal discipline we observe here."

What has Gandhi learned?

"We have to be eternally vigilant about the city's finances. We are a fiscally fragile jurisdiction with a limited tax base. We are at the mercy of the federal government. Our population is very needy."

Like more than a few politicians.

Some expect Gandhi to delve into the depths of the city's spending to guard against malfeasance, for instance, within D.C. Public Schools. Says Gandhi, "If I am presented with a bill, I have to pay it, even if the money is spent unwisely."

What Gandhi can do is bless or denounce deals that involve District funds. Like bonds to build the new baseball stadium, which he approved. Or the loan to keep a Southeast hospital running, which made him raise red flags.

Gandhi's nemesis, David Catania, raged like a bull at the red flag. Dedicated and hardworking, Catania can rightly claim to be the city's chief advocate for protecting public health. In that role, he rammed through a deal that gave $80 million to Specialty Hospitals of America, a company that would take over and operate the troubled Greater Southeast Community Hospital.

When Gandhi found the company had no audited financial statements and warned against the $80 million expenditure in early October, Catania went nuclear and threatened to blame Gandhi if the deal fell through. Weeks later, the council approved the transaction, which already reeks like a rotten fish.

Gandhi did his job. But the politics of keeping a hospital afloat in D.C.'s neediest neighborhood prevailed. Now all the Fiscal Guardian can do is write the check - and wait to say he told them so.

hjaffe@washingtonian.com


Name
Comments

characters left

Article Comments

Comments from Examiner Readers

10:53 PM MST on Wed., Feb. 6, 2008 re: "School Closing Manifesto II: Barry's Destructive Game"

J G G Coolidge "68" said:
Marion Barry has done more singlehandedly to create a Black middle class in Washington DC than any other single individual. As far as MR Jaffe's article is concerned, he does not remember, wasn't in DC OR was not affected, by DC Public Schools being the jobs program for the families of congressional staffers and elected officials while in town. DC had a carpetbagger led education system with not enough graduates of Miner College in leadership positions. Barry had faults, I see many people writing who live in glass houses. His singlemost political fault is not having the political will to mandate DC employees to remain DC residents. Thus they became disconnected with the community and its growth or safety. By the way for another who knows nothing than to complain Barry Farms was the first public project housing in DC built long before Mayor Barry entered DC. The nerve of you media and personal complainers who never did, fought, contributed or sacraficed for DC yet you enjoy and take

Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree

4:52 PM MST on Mon., Jan. 28, 2008 re: "School Closing Manifesto II: Barry's Destructive Game"

Examiner Reader said:
"when are we going to get past what Marion Barry did years ago and focus on today?" Pray tell, what has he done besides spend half his time in court for drug use and making headlines about his inability to manage his own finances? He certainly hasn't done anything for his Ward 8 constituency? Any new development has simply been a by product of having water views in his ward. Barry Farms - sonething he put name on - is a symbol for all that is wrong with this city. But say one thing for Barry, he got a good government job that he doesn't have to do anything but collect a check.

8 agree | 10 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
4:26 PM MST on Mon., Jan. 28, 2008 re: "School Closing Manifesto II: Barry's Destructive Game"

Muckle John said:
For the love of god, why is this slug still holding public office?!

8 agree | 7 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
3:12 PM MST on Mon., Jan. 28, 2008 re: "School Closing Manifesto II: Barry's Destructive Game"

GAB said:
"when are we going to get past what Marion Barry did years ago and focus on today?" When Marion Barry retires from the city council, and when all the lazy, chair-warming, and corrupt city employees he is responsible for hiring leave.

8 agree | 10 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
1:39 PM MST on Mon., Jan. 28, 2008 re: "School Closing Manifesto II: Barry's Destructive Game"

Examiner Reader said:
well said

7 agree | 7 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
1:23 PM MST on Mon., Jan. 28, 2008 re: "School Closing Manifesto II: Barry's Destructive Game"

Examiner Reader said:
when are we going to get past what Marion Barry did years ago and focus on today?

10 agree | 8 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
5:03 AM MST on Fri., Oct. 26, 2007 re: "Opinion: The whole city is watching Anacostia"

Examiner Reader said:
Not sure why there records were mentioned as that does not mean that they ae guilty. Why did they get so little time? This officer never stated what she said first to get the response from the boys which is the reason why they were no lengthy sentences. Officers need to hold themselves to higher standards. These boys are being targeted because she's not satisfied. On 10/19 she had the entire 7 district outside the boys grandma house just because she thought one of the two boys were outside the house (confirmed by a 7 district captain. Neither was present and as a result an estimated 30 police officers are on this one street when they could have been somewhere else doing nothing. By the way these boys do live with their grandma. Was it convenient to pick these two out of 10 because she knew them. What happened to the other 8?

110 agree | 105 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
6:17 PM MST on Thu., Oct. 25, 2007 re: "Opinion: The whole city is watching Anacostia"

Examiner Reader said:
Imagine that the "GRANDMA" calls to defend these kids, wonder where Mom and Dad are???? It's a matter of time and these kids will be in trouble again. Another kid brought up in a broken home blaming the streets for his decisions. Parents need to get a better grip on these kids.

99 agree | 86 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
3:54 PM MST on Thu., Oct. 25, 2007 re: "Opinion: The whole city is watching Anacostia"

Examiner Reader said:
why doesn't she just move? get out of a bad neighborhood?

85 agree | 81 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
12:07 AM MST on Tue., Oct. 16, 2007 re: "Parisian cool comes to D.C. on two wheels"

Mike Licht said:
Is DC Government letting the bike vending corporation use city streets for free, like they let advertising companies use it for bus shelters, or is there DC funding?

106 agree | 107 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
1:24 PM MST on Tue., Sep. 11, 2007 re: "Column: Feeding Frenzy Over $100 Million In D.C.'s Found Money"

Examiner Reader said:
Harry Jaffe...here you go again....postulating: "...Our commercial real estate market is still one of the hottest in the country, pushing tax revenues up by 16 percent.." Jaffe...every year [5 years past] this city has had a surplus...starting at 90 million -2002 up to $130 million in 2005...HIGH PROPERTY TAXES!!!!!!! Black Families property taxes where higher than most families homes west Rock Creek Park. Jaffe...you failed to ask or Follow WHAT HAPPEN TO THE DISTRICT TOBACCO SETTLEMENT MONEY.... JAFFE...YOU ARE TALKING SMOKE CIRCLES AND your background is definitely not FINANCE. CALVIN H. GURLEY

139 agree | 142 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
1:57 PM MST on Mon., Sep. 10, 2007 re: "Column: Feeding Frenzy Over $100 Million In D.C.'s Found Money"

EyesWideOpen said:
To Mayor Fenty: "Keep your promises. Fix the schools, train the jobless, repair the lousy roads and eat more leafy vegetables."

132 agree | 133 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
12:54 PM MST on Mon., Jul. 30, 2007 re: "Column: Peaceable coexistence in the wilds of Rock Creek Park"

Erica said:
This is just lovely. On a Monday afternoon it's nice to stop and appreciate Bambi and his still-living mom. I wish we could treat all of nature with this kind of respect.

152 agree | 165 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
7:06 PM MST on Mon., Jul. 16, 2007 re: "D.C. students will lack books on opening day - as usual"

Examiner Reader said:
Ms. D: Although the former superintendent had the support of Mayor Williams, why would the former superintendent need support to get textbooks? That is something superintendents all over the country do each year.

181 agree | 180 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
1:58 PM MST on Mon., Jul. 16, 2007 re: "D.C. students will lack books on opening day - as usual"

Elizabeth Davis said:
I don't know whether to regard this story as a 'news' article or merely a propaganda campaigned to trash the outgoing superintendent. It would have been more beneficial for me to know how many schools did not receive books and the list of schools rather than the blatant fingerpointing at an administration that never had the underpinnings and mayoral support that our chancellor is afforded. While I'm happy that the Mayor is so willing to provide Ms. Rhee the support she'll need to improve services to schools and children, it would have been great if Dr. Janey and former DC public school administrations had this same level of support from the Mayor and council. If Ms. Rhee fails to turn the system around in two years, I wonder if she will also get a media lynching by the DC power brokers and the media that serves them.

179 agree | 180 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
6:14 PM MST on Thu., Jul. 12, 2007 re: "D.C. students will lack books on opening day - as usual"

Mike Licht said:
>>Re: D.C. students will lack books on opening day - as usual<< Hilda L. Ortiz, DCPS Chief Academic Officer and Gloria L. Benjamin, Assistant Superintendent of Curriculum & Instruction, issued updated Learning Standards for many subjects last week. Have these folks order textbooks NOW. In September, as I understand it, Fairfax County Public School teachers will choose from among county-approved textbooks for the 2008-2009 school year, and books will arrive by June 2008. Why can't DCPS do this?

177 agree | 196 disagree
Vote on this comment: I agree or I disagree
INCLUDED
 

(page generated in 0.19 seconds)